connie 发表于 2005-4-6 15:36:35

Issue51 第一次写,请大家多多指教呀:)[请求]

51Education will be truly effective only when it is specifically designed to meet the individual needs and interests of each student.

Is education truly effective only when it is specifically designed to meet the individual needs and interests of each student? In my view, the speaker unfairly generalizes. It must depend on the objectives of the education. In fundamental stage of learning, education must give in forms of general designed, which will suit for most of the students. However, in professional stage, both general designed and specially designed education are need. In another cases, such as certain kind of promoting practice-learning process, the specially designed education will be the only one can fit the purpose.

To begin with, the fundamental stage of learning is laying a foundation that is important for every single person, no matter what his or her interests are and no matter what they will do in the future. For example, we are required the same standard in the primary schools for this stage because if one person who does not know how to solve a simple math problem, how can he or she be a mathematician? Moreover, all the basic knowledge required in this stage is usually the foundation that is the access to the generality that the students can choose from and eventually can meet the needs and interests of them. So education must give the overall a chance to know everything needed in future and it will be efficient to do this rather than delivering just special knowledge that the area covers.

By contrast, in the professional education stage both of the two kinds of manner for students are requested. Any scientific theory is a work, which is in need of great effort in digging into it. To master the knowledge and make a thorough study of one problem, a special program is the only choice of the ones who are facing the problem. While they are proceeding in certain depth of one subject, it is time that one should learn the subjects relevant to the very problem they meet and sometimes even the subjects that are having nothing to do with the things they are studying. Taking the students who study the paleontology for example. When they first reach the subject, they may be given many courses that are about the organisms that were living millions of years ago. But if they want to understand the whole problem well they would probably go to the library and find a book about geography and something related to the variation of the earth. And it is also conducive if they read some historic and philosophic ideas on the evolution.

However, there are some cases that education must be specially designed; otherwise the cost of the education will just be wasteful. When people come to a school or course in order to promote their certain kind of skill, the specially designed courses are actually required since the ones who engaged in the course are not only learners of this area. People usually participate the promoting classes with a definite aim hoping that they will improve in the very place their drawbacks are locating. Therefore, delivery of this kind of educational course will be designed on purpose, or it will be a waste of time and energy.

In sum, I conceded that there are cases that education should be specially designed under certain circumstances. However, the speaker overlooks many possibilities that individuals are in search of knowledge for different purpose. Accordingly, the way education should be designed is determined by the objectives one is searching for.

yogurt4 发表于 2005-4-13 19:47:54

来学习一下,hehe

yogurt4 发表于 2005-4-14 12:17:16

小看了一下

51Education will be truly effective only when it is specifically designed to meet the individual needs and interests of each student.

Is education truly effective only when it is specifically designed to meet the individual needs and interests of each student? In my view, the speaker unfairly generalizes. It must depend on the objectives of the education. In fundamental stage preliminary吧。 of learning, education must give give who? Or what? in forms of general designed, which will suit for most of the students.这句好像有问题 However, in professional stage, both general designed and specially designed education are need. In another cases, such as certain kind of promoting practice-learning process, the specially designed education will be the only one can fit the purpose.
句子的表达有问题。In my view 的后面是表达你的观点的重中之重,写简洁,概括一点好一些。
To begin with, the fundamental stage of learning is laying a foundation初期的教育给什么东西打下了基础? that is important for every single person, no matter what his or her interests are and no matter what they will do in the future. For example, we are required the same standard in the primary schools for this stage because if one person who does not know how to solve a simple math problem, how can he or she be a mathematician? Moreover, all the basic knowledge required in this stage is usually the foundation that is the access to the generality that the students can choose from and eventually can meet the needs and interests of them. So education must give the overall a chance to know everything needed in future and it will be efficient to do this rather than delivering just special knowledge that the area covers.
小的觉得for example 后面的不妥。数学知识的掌握->数学家,好像已经考虑到了个人的需要。
By contrast, in the professional education stage both of the two kinds of manner for students are requested. Any scientific theory is a work, which is in need of great effort in digging into it. To master the knowledge and make a thorough study of one problem, a special program is the only choice of the ones who are facing the problem. While they are proceeding in certain depth of one subject, it is time that one should learn the subjects relevant to the very problem they meet and sometimes even the subjects that are having nothing to do with the things they are studying. Taking the students who study the paleontology for example. When they first reach the subject, they may be given many courses that are about the organisms that were living millions of years ago. But if they want to understand the whole problem well they would probably go to the library and find a book about geography and something related to the variation of the earth. And it is also conducive if they read some historic and philosophic ideas on the evolution.

However, there are some cases that education must be specially designed; otherwise the cost of the education will just be wasteful. When people come to a school or course in order to promote their certain kind of skill, the specially designed courses are actually required since the ones who engaged in the course are not only learners of this area. People usually participate the promoting classes with a definite aim hoping that they will improve in the very place their drawbacks are locating. Therefore, delivery of this kind of educational course will be designed on purpose, or it will be a waste of time and energy.

In sum, I conceded that there are cases that education should be specially designed under certain circumstances. However, the speaker overlooks many possibilities that individuals are in search of knowledge for different purpose. Accordingly, the way education should be designed is determined by the objectives one is searching for.
最近有点小忙,只能帮你粗略的看看。总的来说,这篇文章结构划分的标准不太清楚:什么样的教育是基础的,什么样的又叫高级的?每当你第一次提到这些问题时,最好给出一些具体的例子。例子的叙述和有效性也有点问题。建议你看看鬼鬼谈例子的那个帖子。刚开始写的时候,多看看别人的作文,对拓展思路和怎样下笔,都有很大帮助。
Btw,想增强自信心,可以看我的gter第一篇,链接在下面:个人责任与环境。Hehe~~~

connie 发表于 2005-4-14 13:15:24

多谢了:)唉,看了你的第一篇我也没有找到信心呀,我是差得挺多的,要加油学习了!
页: [1]
查看完整版本: Issue31 第一次写,请大家多多指教呀:)[请求]