寄托天下 寄托天下
查看: 1857|回复: 3

[问答] Manhattan Prep 一道逻辑题目求解,谢谢~ [复制链接]

Rank: 2

声望
50
寄托币
61
注册时间
2019-7-11
精华
0
帖子
6
发表于 2020-1-9 09:59:05 |显示全部楼层
The national infrastructure for airport runways and air traffic control requires immediate expansion to accommodate the proliferation of new private, smaller aircraft. The Federal Aviation Authority (the FAA) has proposed a fee for all air travelers to help fund this expansion. However, this fee would be unfair, as it would impose costs on all travelers to benefit only the few who utilize the new private planes.

Which of the following, if true, would allow the FAA to counter the objection that the proposed fee would be unfair?

(A) The existing national airport infrastructure benefits all air travelers.
(B) The fee, if imposed, will have a negligible effect on the overall volume of air travel.
(C) The expansion would reduce the number of delayed flights resulting from small private planes congesting runways.
(D) Travelers who use small private planes are almost uniformly wealthy or traveling on business.
(E) The Administrator of the FAA is appointed by the President, who is subject to national election

这是一道例题。按照S-W-Slash chart方法训练解答。书内关于选项A解释,看不明白。

书内关于A的解答:
Answer choice (A) suggests that the existing infrastructure benefits everyone who would be asked to pay the fee. This seems to speak to the question of fairness. However, the fee itself does not benefit the wide range of air travelers, and it is the fairness of the fee that is in question. This choice is best categorized as irrelevant.
自己的解答:
A应该是weaken the conclusion. 结论说收费不公平,前提/假设/论据是所有旅客都承担成本然而只有少数使用私人飞机的人获益。A是直接否定论据,所以认为是weaken。。。

书内解释应该怎么理解呢?谢谢~

回应

使用道具 举报

Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14

声望
702
寄托币
12333
注册时间
2012-3-14
精华
0
帖子
19001

香港offer勋章 经济offer勋章 寄托22周年 加拿大offer勋章 英国offer勋章 人文版offer勋章 美国offer勋章 19周年勋章 中秋勋章 寄托兑换店纪念章 23周年庆勋章

发表于 2020-1-9 11:11:11 |显示全部楼层
帮顶

使用道具 举报

Rank: 2

声望
50
寄托币
61
注册时间
2019-7-11
精华
0
帖子
6
发表于 2020-1-10 12:01:53 |显示全部楼层
自己顶一下

使用道具 举报

Rank: 2

声望
50
寄托币
34
注册时间
2018-12-14
精华
0
帖子
14
发表于 2020-2-26 23:14:17 |显示全部楼层
这道题是选C吗?
A选项只说这个基础建设对所有乘机的人有好处,但是没有说这项收费(扩展基础建设)对所有人有好处。所以A不对。
A选项我认为如果把existing national airport infrastructure改为newly added expansion就对了。

使用道具 举报

RE: Manhattan Prep 一道逻辑题目求解,谢谢~ [修改]
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 立即注册

问答
Offer
投票
面经
最新
精华
转发
转发该帖子
Manhattan Prep 一道逻辑题目求解,谢谢~
https://bbs.gter.net/thread-2314980-1-1.html
复制链接
发送
关闭

站长推荐

寄托24周年庆,发祝福送寄托币!
寄托24岁生日,邀请寄托的小伙伴在本命年周年庆发出你对寄托的祝福, 可以是简单的一句“生日快乐”, 送出祝福小伙伴将会有寄托币奖励!

查看 »

报offer 祈福 爆照
回顶部