pooh 发表于 2004-2-21 11:23:31

[color=#ff00bf]大家来批,看看是不是跟e-rater的结果一样[/color]

给ets送了dollar给我批的,大家看看能得几分,作文原封未动,答案下期公布。

Topic:
"It is important for higher education to challenge established traditions and values."

Present your perspective on the issue below, using relevant reasons and/or examples to support your views.



Nowadays students of universities or colleges are inspired to have critical thinking to any knowledge they received . At the same time, seminars are held to question established tradtions and values. I agree with the speaker that this it is crucial for higher edcation not only to teach students some facts and laws but encourage them to challegne entranched ideas and customs, since it is necessary to question the values and it is possible for higher education to afford the responsibility.

To begin with, any established traditions and values still need proving and examing. Traditions and customs passed by generations may be accustomed to our ancestors but have already cannot be suitable to contemporary soceities. For instance, our ancestors may believe in some magic in curing diseases, and some of them even believe that they could recover without having any formal treatment . Children born in such a family that they all have such an opinion could also deny modern medical care. Undoubtely, from today's view, modern medicine is scientific in curing diseases, so , the tradition is harmful for the children. When it comes to our values, it is the same. When we are young, most of our values are installed by others subconsciously, so that we all accept them no matter they are right or wrong.

After having analyzed the necessity of challenging entranched traditions and values, I will go on with the point that why it is in higher education that should this challenge take place. It is in college that our minds are becoming mature and our ability of critical thinking gets developed to the extent that enables us the analyze any ideas or theories. Therefore, higher education should have afforded the responsibility to educate our younger people to have a critical thinking towards traditions and values. Consider, a little boy born in a Christine family, whose members are all Christine and observe all the rules of Christine. Most likely that the boy will grow up as a Christine and believe in that human is a creation of God, because every idea is instilled by his family and his own analytical thinking is still unawakened. However, after he has been taught Darwinism and natural selection theory, and encourage by the teacher to think carefully about some questions and read more books recommended by the teacher in university or college, his old value system may shackled. That 's why some children break away from Christine when they have grown up and received higher education. Thus, universities and colleges are the best place to encourage students to challenge established traditions and values.

Moreover, should only the students are equipped with critical thinking and question ideas? Teachers, professors an scholars in universities or colleges should also afford such responsiblity. Becasue those group of people are experts in particular areas and may have already made research into such traditions and values, so that their opinions should be authoritative and more challenging to old values.

Additionally, to challege established values and traditions does not mean to disdain their and throw away all of them. The important of such challenge lies that it encourage students or any scholars to question the ideas in order to understand it . If the idea is wrong, more scientific ones will propounded to substitute it; otherwise, people could received it with strengthened belief.

On balance, I contend that higher education should play ther role of challenge established traditions and values , because such values or traditions may have rooted in people's mind, but that doesn't mean they are totally right or they are still helpful in our age. Moreover, it is suitable for higher education to afford the responsibility to challenge such ideas , since students are equipped with such ability and knowledge. Of course, to question doesn't mean to overturn everything and replace with totally new, it is also to way to think carefully and understand them.

so猫 发表于 2004-2-21 11:42:56

我看了 我的感觉 强4弱5吧
逻辑关系里面 body的最后两段感觉不是太好
伤其十指不如断其一指 JJ想做到无懈可击 但感觉有点平
呵呵 一家之辞 呵呵~~~~
pooh姐姐偶们一起加油呀~~~~

pooh 发表于 2004-2-21 11:51:58

考的时候根本顾不到什么了,就是狂打,所以写的很平,头5分钟时间感觉过得很快。 so 猫mm说的有道理,我会努力提高的,还有20天时间有希望做得更好。

这篇issue我怎么没找到号呢。。。

这次argument考的很差,还没有贴出来,这次模考最大的收获就是看到了自以为不错的argument居然问题不少,以后要再argument上多下功夫了!

coolwits 发表于 2004-2-21 11:57:04

我不这么认为,我觉得能到5分往上。
Consider, a little boy born in a Christine family, whose members are all Christine and observe all the rules of Christine.
这个例子有点敏感,要是碰到宗教人士心里不爽可能会摆pooh一道也说不定。不过是e-rater就没关系拉。:)
我觉得到数2,3段逻辑没什么问题阿,适当外推不存在偏题
恭喜pooh
辛苦没有白费,赞一个

雪夭 发表于 2004-2-21 12:01:25

我想看看你argument,行不?
还有就是怎么让那个东西评啊,步骤说一下,还有在gre,org的哪里啊?两篇一共是10$还是分别需要10啊

pooh 发表于 2004-2-21 12:21:35

楼上mm既然想看argument ,我一会儿就贴出来献丑了。
我会再写一篇关于ets的评分系统“Score It Now" 的文章。

两篇一共$10

imong 发表于 2004-2-21 12:24:39

pooh MM又要做大贡献了
在这里bow一个

//bow

我现在在家里,晚上回学校还要开会,等到有空一定好好研究一下,把这个水帖换掉.

雪夭 发表于 2004-2-21 12:28:21

郁闷啊,我刚刚去gre呢里了,可是我收到的email中那个confirmation link点不了,就每办法什么purchase了
我不明白哦
还想问一下你这篇文章是它给你抽的topic吗?直接在那个上面写的还是你的pp3啊

pooh 发表于 2004-2-21 12:40:18

imong :
偶可不敢当啊,my pleasure.
有空还想请你仔细分析一下,有的地方我自己也不太明白到底哪里的问题比较严重,尤其是argument.  e-rater 居然说我没有thesis, 我倒,估计是这个要了命

pooh 发表于 2004-2-21 12:41:20

ets最后的评分是issue 5 分

~白鸽~ 发表于 2004-2-21 12:44:22

有钱人阿~-

而且和so猫一样属于写手级人物,一紧张就狂写的那种:)
特牛,小生极为叹服~~~~~~~~

雪夭 发表于 2004-2-21 12:52:04

开始担心argument了~~~~~~~~~~~

雪夭 发表于 2004-2-21 12:54:08

我刚才复制了一下你的文章,发现文字错误还蛮多的,难道不扣吗?5分?不是说错两个字开始扣粉的啊?

galaxysong 发表于 2004-2-21 13:25:21

写得真多!
第二个body中的例子是不是太长了?issue是以分析为主的吧。

pooh 发表于 2004-2-21 13:40:19

错误真的是大大的多,写完后没有检查,恐怖!!!
页: [1] 2
查看完整版本: 一篇ScoreItNow判定的5分Issue