报AD@UCL, Durham, Warwick; Rej@Edinburgh并

cheesechanUID：3505689

aakpon 发表于 2015-1-24 05:03
如果想要读博士的话，我觉得在国内考研去那几个好学校，比这些硕士都更有收获。而且，也不用太花钱。

just based pn the chpice available here
warwick should be the choice combinig for considering:
科目相關性及硬度
學術排名
fina industry reputation

cheesechanUID：3505689

HugoDang 发表于 2015-1-24 18:26
我对这几个项目的了解肯定还没你多，只能说我个人觉得没必要再申HK了，看看其他大神怎么说吧~

的確沒必要再申HK
除了財政原因

cheesechanUID：3505689

FTFTF 发表于 2015-1-24 16:14
比较经济理论，从我的个人观点来说，主要是比较不同经济流派的（废话），涉及经济思想史的东西比较多，理论 ...

ucl 他家的那個不是幹這個的

cheesechanUID：3505689

玉溪山 发表于 2015-1-24 22:48
嗯是的，但是从课程上来讲，感觉还好..确实对找工作什么的帮助不大，不过我是想继续读博来着

then still Warwick one:
- for the UCL one, at most 15 credit can be choosen outside the department (1 course) <--- academically the choice is clear
- 如果想留英國, (finance方向, as i saw you applied to durham econ and fina), banking and finance industry的話, 兩間都是target, 分別不明顯
- 唯一會選UCL (comp busi econ) over Warwick MSc 的原因是, for the general reputation <--- 當某人打算直接回國用
- 不選durham的原因就不用多說了. (for all revelant dimension: academic ranking, local industrial reputation)

cheesechanUID：3505689

wilfrid613 发表于 2015-2-8 18:54
现在的HR根本不会完全根据大学的名气来招人。很多已经细化到专业在那个大学录取的难度，学习内容层面了 ...

the HR are not really likely to look into that detail of each program,
but rather look at the quality of the applicant one by one.

e.g. for a technical job, the quality of education received highly affected the knowledge of the student, and thus highly affect the interview result.
不過econ的technical job又有幾多……

cheesechanUID：3505689

jituotianxiaaa 发表于 2015-2-8 21:52
其他的industry我不清楚，但是就finance领域来说，回国想进券商总部，商行总行，投行那样的公司岗位，例如 ...

其他的industry我不清楚，但是就finance领域来说，in UK想进券商总部，商行总行，投行那样的公司岗位，例如固收、资管、行研等，是的，就看学校reputation。 (for selection into interview)
- and the reputation of UCL and Warwick in UK is quite negligible. I will choose a better program for sure in this case.

申博士从排名高的department往排名低的department申请容易过从排名低的department往排名更低的department申请，所以，选Warwick吧。 (as the UCL one is not the econ department)
- in academic, the circle is small enough that the ad com will know the difference between programs. and RA/PhD is quite similar to a technical job - what one learnt is very important and that is what is going to be asked during interview.