0606G同主题写作第九期——Issue123

liyan1800426UID：2180637

想想，马上写！
感觉是这样的，从以下几个方面入手：
一：过分强调了细节的作用，忽视：人的细节是可以通过主观加以克服和修正的，也是根据环境，交往对象的不同而改变的。唐人街上穿着唐装说汉话就不能信jesus了吗？
二：不能忽视人的政治倾向是慢慢形成的，是受到自身教育（学校，父母，朋友），个人经历，社会环境等因素所产生的，一群３岁小孩中间，您能辨别who the terrorist,who the racialist,who the Naziism,evenwho the communist,并且只给您几分钟．
三：不能忽视外表和内心的一致性！特例：就算某些人是有政治倾向的，您能保证这种倾向和他的穿着，谈话方式，朋友一致吗？很多女孩都期望去基督教堂里结婚，伴着神父的no matter in health or in illness, richer or poorer, better or worse...,说一句i will，并且告诉很多的朋友们，可这能证明她们是基督教信徒(Christian)吗？
哈哈，随便议论一下，大家指正啊！

[ 本帖最后由 liyan1800426 于 2006-2-28 04:55 编辑 ]

WeOnUID：2110447

第一篇issue，518W, 2h， 有拍必回
提纲：
同意
1，穿着，吃饭可以反映
2，朋友可以
3，说话方式可以
4，大多时候准确，但有些情况下不准确

https://bbs.gter.net/bbs/viewthre ... &extra=page%3D1

附：我上次的一篇argu109，必回
https://bbs.gter.net/bbs/viewthre ... &extra=page%3D1

[ 本帖最后由 WeOn 于 2006-2-27 23:52 编辑 ]

xfxfeUID：2151227

因为是第一篇完整的作文，所以写了很久，也改了很久。
因为是边写一边回忆熟悉常用的短语，肯定不够连贯。
例子方面我实在想不到朋友方面比较好的了，555

提纲：
态度是总体反对的，1正2反
b1。承认生活中某些线索可能反应了人们的political belief
b2。生活中，人们的行为更多的是因为其他因素的影响
b3。对人们political belief的观察需要更多的时间而不是短短的几分钟

恳请各位大大猛拍，必回

https://bbs.gter.net/bbs/viewthre ... &extra=page%3D1

abramboyUID：2172023

先占个坑。

小室黄瓜UID：2155213

提纲：在短期内通过相处了解一个人是非常困难的，有些人可以了解，有些人通过短期了解不了。
1 有些人很单纯也很真实，表里如一，这样就可以通过衣着，朋友，等方式了解。他们的衣服只穿自己喜欢的，朋友没有因为利益相处的，说话无拘束直言，吃的东西也是随性的，这样的人只要问问他的政治信仰是什么，那么就是什么。
2 但是有些人善于掩饰自己，甚至于善于欺骗别人，就很难通过这些方式了解，甚至通过这些方式正好被误导。一方面有人喜欢掩饰自己，她的衣服，朋友，说话的方式都是工作需要或用来展示的，也许信仰都不是她自己的想法，都是某种外界需要决定的。另一方面，欺骗别人更容易借助这些，例如间谍
3 总的来说还是应该通过长时间的考验来了解。事实胜于雄辩，在真实的表象也经不住时间的考验。例如政治家们，振奋人心的演讲和誓言都抵不过实际为民的行动。
结尾：虽然是可以通过简单的方式很短时间内了解人，但是这样容易让人了解的人太少了，因为人们都是或多或少的会受到外界环境的干扰，更重要的是主观因素包括善意的和欺骗性的掩饰。所以短时间往往不可取，要长时间考验。


https://bbs.gter.net/bbs/viewthre ... &extra=page%3D1
有拍必回~

[ 本帖最后由 小室黄瓜 于 2006-3-1 14:33 编辑 ]

savagettUID：2134686

政治而且抽象.
这个要练一下的.顶~

鬼冢UID：2133674

我觉得楼主的首贴有误导。

很多概念都是宗教和政治混为一谈。而且我并不觉得列举的内容必须被完全提到。

鬼冢UID：2133674

好像只有我是支持的。。。

yogurt4UID：198389

原帖由 fhxywei 于 2006-2-27 18:35 发表
政治信仰和宗教信仰是两码事，不要混着谈

的确是这个样子的.这个题目写到完全的宗教就是跑了.

S.YUID：2188052

https://bbs.gter.net/bbs/viewthre ... &extra=page%3D1
以上看法仅代表个人意见,如有雷同,既然巧合,如果愿意请留贴交流...

savagettUID：2134686

https://bbs.gter.net/bbs/viewthre ... &extra=page%3D1

不知道写的是不是有点偏题了
我认为
朋友是可以体现一个人的政治信仰的,物以类聚
对于某些狂热的人,food or dress also can
但是再现代人们的政治观念淡薄了,所以政治信仰的表现对于大多数人来说不是很明显了..
不知道这个第三电会不会有点偏题呢

DIEGE0185UID：184118

提纲：
  1   通过选举期间人们的困惑，引出话题，提出反对意见。
  2  指出两者无直接联系，比如：吃面条不代表反对kfc侵略，喜欢蓝色不代表民主 狂热
  3  指出强行建立联系会导致悖论。比如中美日三者的政策异同。另外，不同时间细节不同，会得到多种不同结论。
4  指出实践上，会导致欺诈行为：选举中的作秀，以及之后的变脸。
5 总结，提出只有多收集信息才是解决问题的办法。

   // *号表示拿不准是否正确或地道的用法  …^表示觉得重复用词或觉得不好地
//    方。
***************************************************************
   帮忙改改吧，至少我也会替你们改的
*********************************************************
Anyone who have experienced even once an election campaign and deeply confused by different candidates yet with political belief almost identical to others, may conceive* an inerasable desire in mind that ,whether, there is a easy-handled way as an sufficient effective solution? Someone believes so. They propose that every common aspect of daily life, including clothes, friends, talking style, even food, serves as the mirror of one's character and thus, becomes conductive for us to deduce from this evidence one's political beliefs. In my opinion, It is true that detail of lives* reflects one's physical and emotion features , yet to take it as a method to analyze one's political belief sounds premature, especially within a very short time.

Individual details* serve only as emotion expression, rather than politics, at least no direct links. A great number of details, the individual custom and aesthetic interest which is cultivated and finally forms through the whole life, depends more fundamentally on family backgrounds, education, and living experience than that of political beliefs. One may take spaghetti as his/her favorite food not because it is the best weapon to protect the local restaurant industry from the competition of KFC, but more probably for a joyful memory* about once before had spaghetti picnic with friends. A young man^ choosing blue as his "luck color" * may come out of his mind when he enjoy the beauty of Xia men's seashore at the first glance, rather than a democratic mania.* Unfortunately, this intrinsic link always ignored and overshadowed by the external represent*.

In practice, there is no constant link^ between political beliefs and their live details^. Obstinately insisting on these unrealistic illusions* must leads to some paradoxical and ridiculous conclusion. For instance, It is untenably that custom of Japanese is more identical to Chinese, ranging from food to philosophy, than that of American. However, in politic level, Tokyo generally* adjusts their policy to keep the step of Washington D.C but ironically assumes that China plays a role of potential competitors in the future.. Even, supposing that there indeed exists such a "constant link", new confusion comes out: how can we discover the adequate evidence and proof appropriate to deducing^ the outcome^ in a very short time?  No one hopes to wear the same clothes, talk to the same friends just for keeping so called "valid evidence" no matter when and where. What if, once a politician was reported to have a conversation with a writer of the right*, can we ensure the conclusion that he/she will become another conservative senate?  

The unreasoning utilizing of this method dooms to exert destructive influence on a fair and harmony society. A politician, realizing that electorate review* him through details, would   deceive them with little effort by just carefully selecting fascinating details. Some of them during the campaign become enthusiastic to visit mill workers, have dinner with low-income family, or exhibit austere* furniture in his house, just for the vote of laboring worker* class. But as soon as he successfully governs the whole nation, the first bill he acts may decrease the tax, which only benefits to the plutocrats.

The life experience indoctrinates us with the axiom* that: what we have seen is not always truth. Just like that the advertisement on TV tells us little about the taste of products. The identification of one's politic beliefs requires more information, analysis, and patience than just a glance. After all, we firmly believe that this great effort ^ will be finally pay off.

DIEGE0185UID：184118

https://bbs.gter.net/bbs/viewthre ... type%26typeid%3D101

原谅我的过失，多谢光临