Issue4 0607G airbots处女作

airbotsUID: 2225434

TOPIC: ISSUE4 - "No field of study can advance significantly unless outsiders bring their knowledge and experience to that field of study."
WORDS: 254          TIME: 0:45:00          DATE: 2006-10-17

Outline
1+, 承认门外汉可能帮助某领域专家取得显著成果
2-, 没有门外汉，专家一样能够取得成果
3-, 门外汉缺乏对某一领域的基础知识，提出的问题不具有帮助性
4-, 门外汉的意见可能悟到某领域的专家，导致大量时间与金钱的浪费

The speaker asserts that If any field of study can advance significantly, outsiders must bring their knowledge and experience to this field of study. I basically agree with it, however, there are also significant advance has been made in some field of study without knowledge and experience of outsiders. Moreover, those knowledge and experience can contribute the particular study, but not necessary in all field of study.

Admittedly, it is true that the knowledge and experience of outsiders can help the experts to make significant progress in some field of study. A good example can give some light to this assertion,

However, without those kinds of outsiders, the expert in field study can also make great advance. Here is a example,

Furthermore, Outsiders have no systematic knowledge of the certain study field; they can only provide some basic experiences. For instance, a blacksmith may not give any useful idea to a nuclear physicist for his aim to win the Nobel Prize in quantum theory, just because they have different background of knowledge and experience.

Finally, some outsiders' opinion may cause negative effect in field of study. If some kind of experience or knowledge do not obey the natural principle, or it is a not a scientific measure to study, and if the experts admit it without thinking, it will cost a lot of time and money to get the experts back from the wrong way.

All in all, without the knowledge and experience of outsiders, meaningful advance also occur in some field of study.

例子想破头都没想出来，望大侠指导，谢谢。

paul_zhang007UID: 2192981

老大 。。。 。。。 254个字  你让我怎么改啊

强烈建议 你 重新写这篇文章  看看别人的文章 看看别人的例子  不要现时了  你这种情况限时是没有任何意义的。