查看: 2974|回复: 4

[GRE诊断] 一道逻辑题，急求答案和解析 [复制链接]

wcjjudy UID：2919312 wcjjudy 当前离线最后登录 2018-10-25 在线时间 327 小时寄托币 1148 声望 30 注册时间 2010-10-1 阅读权限 5 帖子 57 精华 0 积分 615 UID 2919312 禁止发言声望 30 寄托币 1148 注册时间 2010-10-1 精华 0 帖子 57 关注TA 加好友标签发消息	电梯直达楼主发表于 2016-5-18 13:54:22 \|只看该作者 \|倒序浏览提示: 作者被禁止或删除内容自动屏蔽
	相关帖子 • 北美MFE求定位 • 有没有econ美国就业的指点帖子呀，看了半天全是在说econ不好就业 • Adidas全新女鞋出售（因鞋码不合） • Adidas 全新转售（因鞋码不合） • 坐标波士顿！求助暖气还不来怎么办！ • 作文求批改，互相进步 • 14年第一次裸7.5,1/9二刷感想分享 • GRE阅读36套exercise4第一篇第2题 • 9.15苏大考场归来二战159+170 • argument 40 求助求列提纲
	回应 0 使用道具举报

larry0
UID：3407591

中级会员

Rank: 4

声望: 89
寄托币: 741
注册时间: 2013-1-16
精华: 0
帖子: 193

沙发

发表于 2016-5-18 14:42:01 |只看该作者

为啥我觉得该选A(￣▽￣")
C说有些含gamma多的食物大部分人不吃，但是可能这些食物本来就没包含在typical diet里，所以即使不吃gamma也够了，不用额外添加
D说diet里gamma吃的多的人更会去吃补充剂，那补充剂里加不加gamma就无所谓咯反正本身也吃够了

而A说吃仅有alpha的补充剂会造成伤害，所以必须要加gamma？

正确答案是啥？

使用道具举报

xxxyw1993
UID：3675916

中级会员

Rank: 4

声望: 139
寄托币: 1316
注册时间: 2015-12-1
精华: 0
帖子: 189

板凳

发表于 2016-5-18 17:49:27 |只看该作者

同问答案是啥。。。读完原文觉得空里的句子大概是“不是每个人都会吃typical diet”的，所以可能是C？

使用道具举报

shine1020
UID：2281832

寄托新兵

Rank: 2

声望: 32
寄托币: 60
注册时间: 2006-12-9
精华: 0
帖子: 10

地板

发表于 2016-5-24 22:57:52 |只看该作者

觉得都不太正确
FACTS:
1) Vitamin E is helpful
2) Two forms of vitamin E exist
3) One form of vitamin E is alpha, on form of vitamin E is gamma
4) gamma is supplemented by typical person's diet
5) gamma should be added into supplements

17. Which of the following most logically completes the argument?
A. Any boost in the level of the alpha form in a person’s body will tend to suppress the level of the gamma form in that person’s body.
-Supplements Facts 3, 4
-contradicts fact 5, adding alpha supresses gamma, so a supplement adding alpha and gamma may cancel out!
B. The alpha and the gamma forms can easily be combined in a stable form suitable for use in vitamin supplements.
-Supplements Facts 3, 5
-easily combinable doesn't persuade one to actually do so, no benefit listed
C. There are some foods containing high levels of the gamma form that are not a part of most people’s diets.
-Contradicts fact 4, typical diet should typically include "most people's diets"
-Does not supplement fact 5
D. People who take vitamin supplements are more likely to maintain a diet containing high levels of the gamma form than are people who do not take vitamin supplements.
-contradicts fact 5, this would be an argument against adding gamma
E. In the process currently used to manufacture vitamin E supplements, the gamma form of the vitamin is actually removed as a result of steps taken to purify the alpha form.
-contradicts fact 5, argument against adding since it would either be removed, or require a new manufacturing process

使用道具举报