[i习作temp] issue144 [复制链接]

kele05 该用户已被删除	电梯直达楼主发表于 2005-12-17 09:25:26 \|只看该作者 \|倒序浏览提示: 作者被禁止或删除内容自动屏蔽
kele05 该用户已被删除
	回应 0 使用道具举报

Berlinbear
UID: 207694

中级会员

Rank: 4

声望: 0
寄托币: 882
注册时间: 2005-5-1
精华: 0
帖子: 1

沙发

发表于 2005-12-18 13:41:23 |只看该作者

ＩＳＳＵＥ
144"It is the artist, not the critic, who gives society something of lasting value.
提纲：
观点：the speaker的说法是片面的、不合理的。批评家的评论对整个社会艺术的发展同样做出了不可忽视的贡献。
1）       承认，如果没有艺术家，就不会出现许多优秀的艺术作品，而这个世界也就不会是一个完整的世界。
2）       但，具有专业知识的艺术批评家在帮助我们理解艺术作品和提高这些作品的质量方面发挥了重要作用。

The speaker asserts that it is the artist who provides something of lasting value to society instead of the critic. I agree insofar as without artists there would be no works of art, such as novels, films, music, paintings, etc. At the same time, however, the criticism from the critic helps us understand and appreciate works of art of any sort. Then, the comments of the critics are useful to improve the artists’ writings.(开头部分模版的痕迹好像有一点点重呢~~)

As is known to everyone, any work of art is produced through the hard working of the artist. What will happen if there are no artists in one nation? The end result is that we will cannot(情态动词和助动词不能连用呀...) read interesting novels, see many moved films, listen to comfortable music, and enjoy beautiful paintings, etc. It is hardto imagine that human beings are willing to live in such a world.  People will have no spiritual life and cannot construct the whole civilization which exists in the history of today. A person communicates with others and gains broad knowledge just through the study of works of art of any sort. Similarly, the development of the society is depended on the artists.（有点过于绝对了，社会进步同样也需要科学家、人文学家等等许多人的推动，不仅是艺术家可以加个程度副词限定一下） In this sense, we can say that: no artist, no the world.
However, the critic also does a lot in the process of constructing civilization of the world.
First of all, generally speaking, the critic has the special knowledge to appreciate the artists’ works. Common persons only enjoy works of art and seldom estimate them, because they lacks of expertise. Any work of art, if it wants to be something of lasting value in the society, should accept a variety of comments whether they are good or not.（为什么艺术作品拥有长久价值必须经过许多评论呢？这里好像没有论证就直接说了结论，不是很具说服力~~） In addition, the critic’s criticism helps us understand and appreciate works of art of any sort. It is possible that some works of art are so obscure and indigestible that they are hard to understand for the common people. In this circumstance, the critic will reinterpret them to make them easy to understand. Finally, the criticism helps the artist to improve his or her writing. The critic can provide many good ideas which are helpful to the artists’ modification. For example, every novel which is perfect ultimately needs lots of amending. It is the critic who discovers the problems and faults existed in the manuscript.（强调句式，精彩~~） Without the hard working of the critic, it is impossible for the artist to provide something of lasting value in our society.
In the final analysis, it is irrational and impartial that the speaker only admits the contribution of the artist and ignores the significance of the critic’s work. The development of something of lasting value in our society is related to the interplaying between the artists’ works of art and the critic’s criticism.（结语很好~~）

文章的语言很好，说理部分可以进一步加强~~~
楼主加油！~~

【2025FALL】全站祈福已开放~~来领祈福章，求offer得offer

使用道具举报