太阳下的葡萄干这一题就没做清楚过...

w_wbyUID: 2942658

原文
In Raisin in the Sun, Lorraine Hansberry does not reject integration or the economic and moral promise of the American dream; rather, she remains loyal to this dream while looking, realistically, at its incomplete realization. Once we recognize this dual vision, we can accept the play’s ironic nuances as deliberate social commentaries by Hansberry rather than as the “unintentional” irony that Bigsby attributes to the work. Indeed a curiously persistent refusal to credit Hansberry with a capacity for intentional irony has led some critics to interpret the play’s thematic conflicts as mere confusion, contradiction, or eclecticism. Isaacs, for example, cannot easily reconcile Hansberry’s intense concern for her race with her ideal of human reconciliation. But the play’s complex view of Black self-esteem and human solidarity as compatible is no more “contradictory” than Du Bois’ famous, well-considered ideal of ethnic self-awareness coexisting with human unity, or Fanon’s emphasis on an ideal internationalism that also accommodates national identities and roles.

In which of the following does the author of the passage reinforce his criticism of responses such as Isaacs’ to Raisin in the Sun?
(A) The statement that Hansberry is “loyal” to the American dream
(B) The description of Hansberry’s concern for Black Americans as “intense”
(C) The assertion that Hansberry is concerned with “human solidarity”
(D) The description of Du Bois’ ideal as “well-considered”
(E) The description of Fanon’s internationalism as “ideal”

为什么不能选E?

w_wbyUID: 2942658

yflyf 发表于 2012-8-12 17:10
因为ideal of ethnic self-awareness coexisting with human unity有contradictory的意思，而Fanon那个idea ...

.......................................................
似乎好像说得过去...............................
:mad:

w_wbyUID: 2942658

yflyf 发表于 2012-8-12 17:10
因为ideal of ethnic self-awareness coexisting with human unity有contradictory的意思，而Fanon那个idea ...

但是又 觉得 有点 牵强......................

gonggong1UID: 3298210

个人认为应该怎么思考:  1. 题目很重要: "reinforce his criticism of responses " 哪里有 作者的criticism ? 文章最后.    2. reinforce 说明了程度还要深哈
看题  其实A 抛开题目的话就是对的,但是在这道题下就不对.   BC都是最后一句的一部分.
看看DE.  最总要的就是最后一句话: But the play’s complex view of Black self-esteem and human solidarity as compatible is no more “contradictory” than Du Bois’ famous, well-considered ideal of ethnic self-awareness coexisting with human unity, or Fanon’s emphasis on an ideal internationalism that also accommodates national identities and roles.
self-esteem 不就对应 self-awareness         human solidarity对应human unity    compatible 对coexisting with        而FANON的显然没有这样的对应哈.

w_wbyUID: 2942658

gonggong1 发表于 2012-8-12 17:48
个人认为应该怎么思考:  1. 题目很重要: "reinforce his criticism of responses " 哪里有 作者的criticism ...

那为什么不能说这里提到Fanon前面用了一个or, DB和F是并列关系, 并且描述F的时候还有一个also, 可能是因为F后提到,不用重复了啊

gonggong1UID: 3298210

因为最后一句话其实想说的是contradictory 这件事情, or Fanon’s emphasis on an ideal internationalism that also accommodates national identities and roles.    OR这里是跟前面并列,但是并列的是 contradictory,  而 ALSO 是说 F接受internationalism的同时也接受national identities and roles.   

gonggong1UID: 3298210

OR 是表示F以及DB都做了一些事情,而他们做的事情是contradictory的.  而Isaacs’ to Raisin in the Sun也是有矛盾的地方, 他们3位都做了某些自己打自己的事情.  问题就在题目中的REINFORCE 这个单词哈, 如果换个比如SUPPORT什么的, 我觉得DE都可以.  而现在只能说D 对比其他选项更好吧.

w_wbyUID: 2942658

gonggong1 发表于 2012-8-12 18:13
OR 是表示F以及DB都做了一些事情,而他们做的事情是contradictory的.  而Isaacs’ to Raisin in the Sun也是 ...

这里没有QQ里面那个眼睛旋涡状旋转的表情...........

gonggong1UID: 3298210

我觉得这道题不用纠结, 考试的时候我情愿多花时间在别的提上, 这个蒙了.

w_wbyUID: 2942658

gonggong1 发表于 2012-8-12 18:27
我觉得这道题不用纠结, 考试的时候我情愿多花时间在别的提上, 这个蒙了.

那就有好多要蒙了..................我觉得PP2里面的文章比36套要绕得多....  T.T

xywustUID: 3462520

这个题目还请大神来讲解一下，，我也没弄懂。我觉得D可以E也可以啊~

gairlyUID: 2664452

这道题真的纠结太久也是浪费时间

xywustUID: 3462520

gairly 发表于 2013-12-3 15:58
这道题真的纠结太久也是浪费时间

不能同意的更多    = =  很多变态题

Calcifer.wuieUID: 3163422

这道题我也好纠结，感觉是不是E选项本身的错误

（1）原文是：
“Fanon’s emphasis on an ideal internationalism that also accommodates national identities and roles.”
说Fanon对于“理想国际主义与国家地位的相互协调与适应”的强调。

（2）选项中是：
“The description of Fanon’s internationalism as “ideal” ”
说的是Fanon的国际主义的理想

这种国际主义在文章中应该并没有说明是Fanon的，Fanon只是强调这个国际主义，强调这种看似矛盾的东西，但实际上不是Fanon提出的。不知道这样理解对吗？