寄托天下
查看: 1988|回复: 3
打印 上一主题 下一主题

[i习作temp] issue36 P:后人评价更客观,有些情况当代人也可以评价(参考了zhoulin00001的作 [复制链接]

Rank: 2

声望
0
寄托币
632
注册时间
2003-12-1
精华
0
帖子
0
跳转到指定楼层
楼主
发表于 2005-3-8 10:32:24 |只看该作者 |倒序浏览
------题目------
The greatness of individuals can be decided only by those who live after them, not by their contemporaries.
------正文------
In many cases, I believe that the evaluation of greatness of individuals from the ones live after them is more objective than that of their contemporaries. After all the long time after them may give people chances to do more thinking and checking on the greatness. However, there indeed exist some greatness can be decided by their contemporaries.

First of all, descendents would indeed realize the greatness of certain contributions which experience wide comparisons and tests of time. As is well known, great theories or inventions are often advanced or invented by great genius whose ideas may not be easily understood and accepted by average people, even normal scientists. We can take Einsten's story as an example. When Einsten first published his theory--theory of relative, there is no people believe his notion since his abstruse idea has been far beyond the knowledge limitation of other scientists, let alone average people. However, with the development of science and its application in some field, although most of us still can not understand it, the theory has been generally accepted in scientific circle, and Einsten has been regarded as one of the most gifted scientists for his contribution.

Besides, in the past centuries, people usually held a prejudice on innovation, and have a nature to refuse to accept new ideas. In other words, they are inclined to maintain traditional conception and cognition. During the church's period, churches own the inviolable authorities, any one including those who are regarded as great figures now raise a new theory opposed to the doctrine of church will encountered prison even death penalty. Famous naturalist Darwin's theory of evolution based on natural choice is a good example. It is obviously contradicted with the church's believes that the existence of human is due to that of god, but not evolution. Thus his theory was sentenced as heresy and Darwin was compelled for a long time. Also, another figure Corpernicus is worth considering in this point, whose famous heliocentric theory drastically conflicted with the church's geocentric theory. Corpernicus's theory was considered as a misbelief, whereas it has been evaluated the greatness now.

While we claim that the greatness of individual can be better decided by their descendents, we cannot rule out some cases, especially the cases in realm of humanities and sociology, which may have direct and closed relationships with average people. In this point, we can take Teresa's experience as an example. Teresa, as an Albanian-born Indian nun, dedicated herself to relieving the suffering of India's desperately poor and dying people, thus she won the 1979 Nobel Peace Prize. It is believed that her contribution to Indian people cannot be forgotten or disvalued forever. With the similar experience, Martin Luther King's contribution that she dedicated herself to objecting to racialism, with no doubt, can be decided by the contemporaries as well as descendents.

In conclusion, due to the increasing development of human's cognition and knowledge, descendents have more advantage in evaluating the greatness of individual, in that they tend to be more objective and equitable. In spite of that, we have to admit that some greatness happened around normal people can be decided by contemporaries also.
Nothing is important but love.
5T and 6G
0 0

使用道具 举报

Rank: 3Rank: 3

声望
0
寄托币
470
注册时间
2004-6-27
精华
1
帖子
0
沙发
发表于 2005-3-8 19:18:37 |只看该作者
In many cases, I believe that the evaluation of greatness of individuals from the ones live after them is more objective than that of their contemporaries. After all the long time after them may give people chances to do more thinking and checking on the greatness. However, there indeed exist some greatness can be decided by their contemporaries.

First of all, descendents would indeed realize the greatness of certain contributions which experience wide comparisons and tests of time. As is well known, great theories or inventions are often advanced or invented by great genius whose ideas may not be easily understood and accepted by average people, even normal scientists. We can take Einstein’s story as an example. When Einsten(Einstein) first published his theory--theory of relative(relativity), there is no people believe his notion since his abstruse idea has been far beyond the knowledge limitation of other scientists, let alone average people. However, with the development of science and its application in some field(fields), although most of us still can not understand it, the theory has been generally accepted in scientific circle, and Einstein has been regarded as one of the most gifted scientists for his contribution.

Besides, in the past centuries, people usually held a prejudice on innovation, and have a nature to refuse to accept new ideas. In other words, they are inclined to maintain traditional conception and cognition. During the church's period, churches own the inviolable authorities, any one including those who are regarded as great figures now raise a new theory opposed to the doctrine of church will encountered prison even death penalty(这一句整个时态是不是错了now raise,will,你是说过去还是现在,我觉的说过去才对). Famous naturalist Darwin's theory of evolution based on natural choice is a good example. It is obviously contradicted with the church's believes that the existence of human is due to that of god, but not evolution. Thus his theory was sentenced as heresy and Darwin was compelled for a long time. Also, another figure Corpernicus(Copernicus) is worth considering in this point, whose famous heliocentric theory drastically conflicted with the church's geocentric theory. Copernicus’s theory was considered as a misbelief, whereas it has been evaluated the greatness now.

While we claim that the greatness of individual can be better decided by their descendents, we cannot rule out some cases, especially the cases in realm of humanities and sociology, which may have direct and closed relationships with average people.(意思没说全,加上类似In these cases, the greatness of individual can be decided by their contemporaries 的话是不是更好一点) In this point, we can take Teresa's experience as an example. Teresa, as an Albanian-born Indian nun, dedicated herself to relieving the suffering of India's desperately poor and dying people, thus she won the 1979 Nobel Peace Prize. It is believed that her contribution to Indian people cannot be forgotten or disvalued forever. With the similar experience, Martin Luther King's contribution that she (King 是男人呀,怎么能用she,严重错误,注意)dedicated herself (himself)to objecting to racialism, with no doubt, can be decided by the contemporaries as well as descendents.

In conclusion, due to the increasing development of human's cognition and knowledge, descendents have more advantage in evaluating the greatness of individual, in that they tend to be more objective and equitable. In spite of that, we have to admit that some greatness happened around normal people can be decided by contemporaries also.
写的不错,逻辑和思想都不错(你用的是大多数人采用的思想),语言也很好,但是你最大的问题是把大牛的名字和性别都记错了,一定要注意呀。

使用道具 举报

Rank: 16Rank: 16Rank: 16Rank: 16

声望
19
寄托币
49553
注册时间
2003-6-1
精华
40
帖子
59

Scorpio天蝎座 荣誉版主

板凳
发表于 2005-3-8 21:54:56 |只看该作者

Re: issue36 P:后人评价更客观,有些情况当代人也可以评价(参考了zhoulin00001

最初由 lunatic 发布
[B]------题目------
The greatness of individuals can be decided only by those who live after them, not by their contemporaries.
------正文------
In many cases,..

以下省略...... [/B]

]]文章写的可以,论述也是比较到位。另外,dvdworm的修改也非常认真和仔细。的确,你最好注意一下:小爱同学拼写错误和King同学is not a she.
重返寄托

三十而立 战战兢兢
如临深渊 如履薄冰

使用道具 举报

Rank: 2

声望
0
寄托币
632
注册时间
2003-12-1
精华
0
帖子
0
地板
发表于 2005-3-9 14:44:21 |只看该作者
非常感谢dvdworm 的批改和忠告,记人名是我的死穴,一定得注意了
同时感谢davidjacky斑竹的强调
决心克服这个小破问题
Nothing is important but love.
5T and 6G

使用道具 举报

RE: issue36 P:后人评价更客观,有些情况当代人也可以评价(参考了zhoulin00001的作 [修改]

问答
Offer
投票
面经
最新
精华
转发
转发该帖子
issue36 P:后人评价更客观,有些情况当代人也可以评价(参考了zhoulin00001的作
https://bbs.gter.net/thread-253495-1-1.html
复制链接
发送
回顶部