- 最后登录
- 2018-7-30
- 在线时间
- 596 小时
- 寄托币
- 22408
- 声望
- 427
- 注册时间
- 2006-9-29
- 阅读权限
- 175
- 帖子
- 644
- 精华
- 55
- 积分
- 23915
- UID
- 2257608
   
- 声望
- 427
- 寄托币
- 22408
- 注册时间
- 2006-9-29
- 精华
- 55
- 帖子
- 644
|
发表于 2007-7-22 13:31:40
|显示全部楼层
From the Stone Age to the steam age, then electrical age, and the information age, we human beings have gone through a wide span of human history climbing up step by step along the rungs of technological advancement ladder. On the road targeting to realize the value of human beings, the high-tech is really playing an important role. The primary goal of technological advancement is not to increase people's leisure time but to improve people's producing ability, as Marx discussed in his "Economics Principles". Without these abilities, technology advancements are just castles in the air.(问题出来了, 仅仅是提高producing ability? 本题的目标和这个不具备可比性, 因为不处于同一逻辑层面上: 怎么增加空闲时间? 提高劳动效率, 怎么提高劳动效率? 提高生产力. 因此你说科技发展的目的是提高生产力, 不代表它的目的就不是提高空闲时间, 相反, 很可能为了提高空闲时间我们才要提高生产力. 不处于同一逻辑层面上的问题不能够成取舍对比逻辑, 因此你的出发点有点对不上题. 要证明首要目的不是提供空闲时间, 可以用跟它同一层面的目的来说这些才是提供最基本目的, 或者由于它们并列所以没有首要目的, 比如提高生活质量, 实现个人价值, 也可以进一步用辨证法分析空闲时间本身, 比如有的人工作的时候也很享乐, 因此空闲时间的增多对他们没好处, 而技术在这些人眼中则是使工作更具吸引力的工具.--有关这个出发点我也不太确定, 你自己思考下吧, 觉得是这样)
Admittedly, some new technologies really lifted up people's living standard and made our lives cozier than ever before.(effective=make lives cozy and lift living standard? 两码事, 这个让步曲解了作者的意思, 同时也让你自己少了一个出发点) Internet is convenient for us to know what is happening around world, and is also creating several working positions such as SOHO, net manager and information guard, etc. Air conditioners are making people's working and living places much more comfortable. And most commonly, people don't have to worry about the darkness at night because electricity and bumps are produced. People are solving their daily problems with new technologies. And in some cases, these new technologies really increased people's working efficiency and some works even just could not leave them, such as computers, cars and so on.(效率直接关系到时间, 只是提升生活质量的一个方面,象你提到的空调则是提供了与时间同步的空间优势, 即条件好转, 与时间没有直接联系, 象工作机会这种跟效率就更没关系了, 因此可以认为这段跑题了.)(这里感觉你的问题是出在没有把题目的层次分开, 题目有两点 1 提高效率 2 增加业余时间, 其实是忽略了总工作量也增加的问题, 形成了单纯的因果, 也就是imong所说的1+1关系, 所以写的时候应该把题目的层次分开来论证, 而不是写到一块, 这样很容易混淆题目概念, 进而跑题)
Although we could not deny that technologies advancement really improved our livings and, in some conditions, working efficiency, these improvements are also bringing new problems. (bring new problems是副作用, 和目的不是一会事, 难道我们是为了找麻烦而发展科技? 这里的表达有问题, 我想你的意思是效率提升的同时带来的问题, 使得这种提升变得不利于我们生活, 进而不能成为科技发展的目的, 而仅仅是客观发展的某项附加值) For another example of computer, researches in communications and networking management and its efficiency are still undergoing. (前面那个for an another example多余, 因为这个引导等于你就举一个电脑的例子, 举完例子要进行说明, 但你却转向了交通, 此时这个词不能覆盖后面的话, 反而限定了行文的完整性.) The speed of transportations is still rising tremendously through the invention of maglev and planes, etc. The road accessing to these success are paved by the hard works of those diligent scientific researchers and arduous workers. (but 注意句子之间的逻辑关系, 适当加入引导词能让你的思路比较明晰)Life nowadays is not leisurer but much busier than before. Cars could cause accidences making the policemen busier. Goods and products are much complex than before making the businessmen much busier. (I need more examples) Almost everyone is distributing his life to his career. Some of them are even sacrificing their leisure time in the study of high-techs. Merely can we see a scientist could finish a TV show taking my father as an example? It really pays when we gets.
The goal of the development of new advanced technology is abstract and indefinite. If we just sleep on the successes we have already made and being satisfied with them doing nothing more, the future would be an unpredictable darkness. Suppose we are still satisfying with fire we accidentally found and do nothing else, bumps will not be invented. Edison would be still thinking that "well candle is okay” and we sleep early enjoying our leisure time. Development stimulates development. The prosperous cycle ripples when even the minority was found or invented. Nothing could stop this trend.(这段的论证赞, 提升了文章的整体高度, 但主题句太笼统了, 抽象和不确定等于把你自己的论证也变的抽象和不确定, 一来统帅不了本段的论证内容, 二来也不知道你要说什么, 其实这里不就在说人类总是以更爽为目标发展的么, 进行深入的剖析能让你的论证有更多的支持, 而不止是无证据的断言: development stimulates development, nothing could stop this trend. 说明这种trend是由人类天性决定的, 由物种发展趋势决定, 由基因决定的...等等)
Life is easier with more difficulties. On the road of development, people still have a long way to go. Although helping people get more leisure time though new advanced technology is an ideal thinking, it is obviously hard to realize. The purpose of our creation is apparent: to reach our utmost goals of belief, knowledge, and spirituality; to reflect on the universe and humanity, and thus prove our value of existence. Technological advancement is just a necessary process during the whole project.
总评: 总体而言是一篇很出色的ISSUE, 特别是段落间的逻辑衔接很好, 考试的时候写成这样应该有5分以上了, 唯一的硬伤就是把leisure time和cozy life混淆了.
另外你这里的重点安排不太好, 其实最有力地是倒数第二段, 我想重点应该放这里, 相反, 你说缺例子那里其实论证已经够多的了, 那段是表面现象, 后一段才是分析说理, 因此后面更重要. |
|