- 最后登录
- 2011-10-18
- 在线时间
- 57 小时
- 寄托币
- 253
- 声望
- 1
- 注册时间
- 2009-8-10
- 阅读权限
- 20
- 帖子
- 1
- 精华
- 0
- 积分
- 319
- UID
- 2680175
 
- 声望
- 1
- 寄托币
- 253
- 注册时间
- 2009-8-10
- 精华
- 0
- 帖子
- 1
|
Do you agree or disagree with the following statement? People should be allowed to use mobile phone in public transportation (plane, train, bus)?
1,空间是大家共有的 就像公共场所能不能吸烟一样 要区分利弊 在这里 利大于弊
2,移动电话是人语言功能的延伸 如果禁止用手机 就像不准说话一样 只有在完全需要安静的地方才 要禁止 如果某人太吵应当 个别情况的阻止
3,涉及到安全 就要禁止 比如 飞机 比如 驾驶员 比如驾驶员旁边 等等
I agree with the statment. In my opinion, people should be allowed to use mobile phones in public transportation except a few situations which may cause dander.
First, in public transportion. The space in the vehice is owned and shared by all the passengers. So a passenger has the right to make sounds in the space, speaking, laughing, crying, singing are possible acceptable behaviors, and so should phone calls be accepted. There have long detabes overing smoking in the public. The smokers have the right to smoke, and for some of them, smoking is an urgent desire that can not be simply depressed. But smoking has been connected with lung cancer and other respiratory diseases, so smoking in the public could be a possible danger to others. The nonsmokers also have the ownership of the air of public place, so they strongly argue aginst smoking. There is an argument because the connection with health damage and smoking is not clear, when doctors reveals the sure connection, most of the public place abandon smoking, and considering the rights of smokers, they are provided with specific places to solve their needs. In public vehicles, we see smoking place.
However, using mobile phone is another kind of situation. In this process, people just make some noises. The side effects it cause depend on the context and loudness. We can not ban peole from speaking in the public transportation, so it is not concious for us to abandon phone calls. It is not reasonable to shut down people's mouth just because he or she is not taking with people nearby. So, in most of situations mobile phones should not be banned, it is just an important part of the civil privacy.
However, in some specific situations, mobile phones should be banned. I conclude these situations into two kinds. The first is using mobile phones is endangering the transportation or other people's life. The second is using mobile phone greatly impinge others' rights, and cause malaise. The first kind of situations should include phonecalls on the plain which may affects the elecotronical waves the plain should normaly receive. And loud and noisy talking which greatly distracts the driver and affects his or her driving technique. In the public, when we come across some talktive person who talks loudly and untiringly all the time, we may feel very unpleased. When people around can not tolerate him or her anymore, we have two choices, the first is to leave and the second is to shut him up. In the public transportion, we could do similar things. We could go to deck to aovid the noise down or sit in differnt apartment of the train or just let him or her low down the voice or shut him or her down. The process is unformal and personnal, which should not be legislated. Moblie phones benefit a lot, they are a powerful tool of communication especially the mordern phones like iphone. Most importantly people still have rights to speak, so they have rights to make phone calls. Mobile phones should not be banned. |
|