Dec 2008 2 19

lily88888UID: 2828533

None of the students taking literature are taking physics,

but several of the students taking physics are taking art.

In addition, none of the students taking rhetoric are

taking physics.

Which one of the following statements follows logically

from the statements above?

(A) There are students who are taking art but not

literature.

(B) None of the students taking literature are taking

art.

(C) There are students who are taking rhetoric but

not literature.

(D) None of the students taking rhetoric are taking

literature.

(E) There are students who are taking both art and

literature.

duijinxiaoziUID: 2585955

题干：
None of the students taking literature are taking physics 的 逻辑结构：
literature-----》非 physics
即：
physics------》非literature
---------------------------------------------
several of the students taking physics are taking art 的逻辑结构：
physics 《--------（several）----------》 art
------------------------------------------------
合并：
art《-----（several）-----》 physics ------》非literature
简化：
art-----（several）-----》非literature
即选项（A）