香港和巴黎如何抉择？

wuhuaming2006UID: 2923170

前段时间参加了港大EEE PhD的面试，前天教授打电话来同意给我offer，但一旦决定就不能放他鸽子，不然他会遭受巨大损失，让我在周末前给答复。 同时我还联系到了欧洲的一些大学，本打算走公派的，比较想去的是法国的巴黎六大和十一大，已经拿到邀请函，巴黎大学也挺有名的，教授都不错，都是专业的系主任。但申请公派的话至少得5月份才有结果，办签证的话还得学三个月法语，我的语言天赋一直不怎么样，这也是比较纠结的地方。 另外还有个美国50后的大学老师答应给我offer了，但还得让我补个GRE成绩。所以这个至少得7月份才有结果。 我不知道如何抉择，该不该现在接受港大老师的offer？ 大家帮我出出主意，香港还是巴黎？

srorangeUID: 2394002

HK的牌子在国内蛮管用的

turkeykUID: 208840

看哪个的专业实力强吧。综合来说港大和巴黎大学系统在国内知名度差不多，但好像港大工科通常在香港还是比中大和科大差一点，巴黎大学的工科在法国可能也不如某些高等专科学校，所以建议lz再仔细看看。

turkeykUID: 208840

记得上海交大的大学排名有工科专业分类的，不过好像网页打不开了。

turkeykUID: 208840

如果看times的工科分类排名，貌似港大比巴黎好。

	1	California Institute of Technology	United States	95.9	98.9	49.2	89.9	98.6	99.1
	2	Massachusetts Institute of Technology	United States	94.7	98.6	76.7	84.0	93.7	96.6
	3	Stanford University	United States	93	97.9	27.9	70.8	96.7	99.1
	4	Princeton University	United States	91.3	89.7	62.7	Data not supplied	90.1	98.8
	5	University of California Berkeley	United States	90.5	88.5	36.3	Data not supplied	97.4	94.5
	6	University of Cambridge	United Kingdom	87.8	94.5	83.6	62.6	93.6	80.3
	7	Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich	Switzerland	87.2	86.1	90	Data not supplied	95.2	79.8
	8	University of Oxford	United Kingdom	85.9	89.4	76.3	80.5	94.3	76.3
	9	Imperial College London	United Kingdom	85.8	90.5	94.1	71.3	92	75.9
	10	Georgia Institute of Technology	United States	83.2	87.2	74.2	78.4	93.9	70.9
	11	Carnegie Mellon University	United States	82.3	92.6	40	61.1	95.4	69.5
	12	Cornell University	United States	80.9	79.8	56.1	36.1	81.7	93
	13	University of Toronto	Canada	80.1	77.4	Data not supplied	Data not supplied	83.9	79.1
	14	University of Michigan	United States	79.5	86.2	76.8	51.9	91.4	65.9
	15	University of Illinois - Urbana	United States	77.8	80.6	50.9	Data not supplied	89.4	67.9
	16	National University of Singapore	Singapore	77.5	76.2	98.9	44.8	75.6	82.6
	17	University of California Santa Barbara	United States	75.4	62.7	91.6	99.9	65.1	91.5
	18	Northwestern University	United States	75	65.4	51.3	Data not supplied	66	97.5
	19	University of Hong Kong	Hong Kong	72.3	62	86.1	62.0	61.8	92.4
	20	Tsinghua University	China	71.3	90.4	25	93.2	84.6	42.9
	20	Hong Kong University of Science and Technology	Hong Kong	71.3	58.4	92.4	52.6	60	95.2
	22	University of Tokyo	Japan	70.4	89.4	19.4	Data not supplied	91.1	39.1
	22	Ecole Polytechnique	France	70.4	66.8	68.3	Data not supplied	60.6	84.2
	24	École Polytechnique Federale of Lausanne	Switzerland	69.4	65.3	99.6	35.0	67.2	76.3
	25	Peking University	China	69.1	62.6	46.5	89.7	58.4	86.8
	26	University of Massachusetts	United States	67.5	69.8	23	59.0	77.6	64
	27	University of Minnesota	United States	67	58.8	23.1	Data not supplied	64.2	85.3
	28	Pohang University of Science and Technology	Republic of Korea	66.4	61.9	29.7	99.6	58.5	79.2
	29	Brown University	United States	64.7	54.9	51.3	Data not supplied	52.8	88.5
	30	University of Melbourne	Australia	64.4	55.3	82.5	32.7	59.1	81.2
	31	University of California San Diego	United States	63.6	54.2	30.7	56.5	65.8	77.4
	32	Rice University	United States	63.5	53.8	29.3	29.5	48.8	99.3
	33	Delft University of Technology	Netherlands	63.2	75.8	44.3	84.2	83.1	30.3
	34	Purdue University	United States	62.8	72.2	58.2	Data not supplied	77.5	39.4
	34	University of Wisconsin	United States	62.8	57.4	39.2	Data not supplied	63.3	71.6
	34	Ecole Normale Superieure, Paris	France	62.8	56	39.7	31.3	41.8	99.7
	37	University of Queensland Australia	Australia	62.3	58.1	69.7	73.2	53.6	72.2
	38	University of British Columbia	Canada	62.1	61.2	85.5	45.6	64.3	59.6
	38	University of Freiburg	Germany	62.1	50.4	45	96.0	43.5	89.6
	40	University of Sydney	Australia	61.6	54.5	91.6	95.4	57.5	62.1
	41	University of Southern California	United States	60.9	60.1	28.9	Data not supplied	50.4	77.5
	42	University of California Davis	United States	60.7	50.9	53.3	52.0	57.9	75.8
	43	Birkbeck, University of London	United Kingdom	60.6	42	92.9	27.4	39.9	100
	44	Australian National University	Australia	60.4	45.9	83	Data not supplied	50.8	80.8
	45	University of Science and Technology of China	China	60.2	52.9	Data not supplied	28.0	47.6	85.3
	46	National Taiwan University	Taiwan	60.1	61.3	33.2	35.1	59.3	68.3
	47	University of Notre Dame	United States	59.9	49.5	33.5	Data not supplied	42.3	92.2
	48	Nanjing University	China	59.7	47.3	49.9	46.5	42.8	92.7
	49	Bielefeld University	Germany	58	39.2	Data not supplied	Data not supplied	37	97.9
	50	Ohio State University	United States	57.4

wangshuashuaUID: 2753838

额。。。那个PEKING UNIVERSITY的工科不知道在CHINA MAINLAND能不能排到25哦，除了计算机，电子信息外，工科的其他专业像机械，电气，能源，动力，材料之类的学科他家都没有吧。。。。法国的大学和工程师教育完全是2个体系，大学比较不受人待见，不过6大和11大还是很强大的，在欧洲大陆也可以进TOP10吧，主要是可以在欧洲到处旅游。。。香港太无聊了

wuhuaming2006UID: 2923170

5# turkeyk
这个工科排名是在哪找到的？

turkeykUID: 208840

times higher education, world university ranking里。

子剑寒舍UID: 2790971

谈谈城市环境。同样是读书，不一样的城市环境心理感受的差别还是很大的。香港很繁华，欲望都市一枚，周围都是中国人，香港人也可以讲普通话，中国大陆学生也多，群众基础好；巴黎相对清净些，而且多数人说法语，即使有不少中国人，很多是年轻过去打工的。归属感方面香港大于巴黎，但是论文化底蕴，巴黎胜过香港，整个巴黎都是传统的欧式楼盘，读几年书切身体验一下也是蛮值得的。香港生活节奏快过巴黎。供参考~