这段话该如何理解？

rabbit2012UID: 3050939

第4 套重最点机经20100306NATask 3
Student Notice
There has been a suggestion submitted by the student body regarding the need of certain students. The suggestion states that as a result of the contribution of the universities chemistry department, it has been suggested that the students from the school of chemistry should receive scholarships. The university school board will consider this suggestion carefully and provide an answer for this proposal in the following weeks.

A: Did you hear the news about the school of chemistry?
B: Do you mean the letter one of the students wrote to the school board about giving the chemistry students extra scholarships because of their school’s contribution to the university?
A: Yes, how could anyone argue that the students from their school should get extra scholarships because of something they didn’t do? The university is providing them with the opportunity to gain a degree; they shouldn’t receive any other benefit from the school unless they have earned it.
B: I understand your point of view.
A: Also, if the school of chemistry has made large contributions to the university, there can be other forms of benefits the school can provide for the department and the students. I think it would be a lot better to invest the money in equipment and facilities instead of giving them directly to the students. This method would be beneficial to the students as well as the department.


请问A说的第一个理由是什么意思？

hycqyUID: 2819662

1# rabbit2012 你指的是Yes, how could anyone argue that the students from their school should get extra scholarships because of something they didn’t do?这句话么？
我的理解是contribution是chemistry department做出的而不是某一个人做出的 所以chemistry department的学生不应该因为他们没做过的事情得到额外奖学金

肉肉的包子脸UID: 3085318

呀，楼主，你这个jj太详细了

meverickUID: 2955424

看看

学习下