GRE考试综合论坛

金少UID: 3169262

大家有做新G的36套阅读吗？请问第32套的第8题为咋会选D

dandelionttUID: 2852417

如果问题的话，请把题目贴上来，谢谢。

金少UID: 3169262

The painter Peter Brandon never dated his work,and their chronology is only now beginning to take shape in the critical literature.A recent dating of a Brandon self-portrait to 1930 is surely wrong.Brandon was 63 years old in 1930,yet the painting shows a young, dark-haired man-obviously Brandon,but clearly not a man of 63.
     which of the following,if justifiably assumed,allows the conclusion to be properly drawn?
A.There is no securely dated self-portrait of Brandon that he painted when he was significantly younger than 63.
B.In refraining from dating his works,Brandon intended to steer critical discussion of them away from considerations of  chronology.
C.until recently,there was very little critical literature on the works of Brandon.
D.Brandon at age 63 would not have portrayed himself in a  painting as he had looked when he was a young man.
E.Brandon painted several self-portraits that showed him as a man past the age of 60.
答案是D,why?

苏梳眠UID: 2717864

原因：Brandon was 63 years old in 1930,yet the painting shows a young, dark-haired man-obviously Brandon,but clearly not a man of 63.
结论：A recent dating of a Brandon self-portrait to 1930 is surely wrong.
1930自画像>自画像为年轻人+B为63岁>自画像不是在1930年画的
要保证上述推论正确，必须确定B在63岁年龄一定会画63岁年龄的自画像，而不是63岁时画自己23岁是的自画像。
看选项。
A.在B63岁前，没有明确标注日期的自画像。不能揭示上面的假设前提。
B.B试图通过不标注日期，从而将公众的评论从对其作品年代史研究上转移开。也未揭示。
C.目前为止，对B作品的评论很少。无关选项。
D.B在63岁时，不会去画自己年轻时的自画像。完全符合。
E.B画过几幅自画像，这些自画像显示其年龄大于60。但是这个并不能确定假设，可能是70岁时画的，也可能是同年龄时画的。
文章的中逻辑存在等价转换。

金少UID: 3169262

多谢了，了解