问一个阅读，机经里长江水稻的那个。。。

timohuuUID: 3213764

Since the 1970s, archaeological sites in China's Yangtze River region have yielded evidence of sophisticated rice-farming societies that predate signs of rice cultivation elsewhere in East Asia by a thousand years. Before this evidence was discovered, it had generally been assumed that rice farming began farther to the south. This scenario was based both on the geographic range of wild or free-living rice, which was not thought to extend as far north as the Yangtze, and on archaeological records of very early domestic rice from Southeast Asia and India (now known to be not so old as first reported). Proponents of the southern-origin theory point out that early rice-farming societies along the Yangtze were already highly developed and that evidence for the first stage of rice cultivation is missing. They argue that the first hunter-gatherers to develop rice agriculture must have doneYet while most stands of wild rice reported in a 1984 survey were concentrated to the south of the Yangtze drainage, two northern outlier populations were also discovered in provinces along the middle and lower Yangtze, evidence that the Yangtze wetlands may fall within both the present-day and the historical geographic ranges of rice's wild ancestor.

2.1. Which of the following, if true, would most clearly undermine the conclusion that the author makes based on the 1984 survey?
A. Areas south of the Yangtze basin currently have less wild-rice habitat than they once did.
B. Surveys since 1984 have shown wild rice populations along the upper Yangtze as well as along the middle and lower Yangtze.
C. The populations of wild rice along the Yangtze represent strains of wild rice that migrated to the north relatively recently.
D. Early rice-farming societies along the Yangtze were not as highly developed as archaeologists once thought.
E. In East Asia, the historical geographic range of wild rice was more extensive than the present-day geographic range is.

答案是C，但是为什么C呢？而且我觉得这个和文章没什么关系啊？求解释。。。。

NightzzUID: 3320648

读懂文章吧。读懂了你就知道为什么了

麻倉枼UID: 3376337

They argue that the first hunter-gatherers to develop rice agriculture must have doneYet while most stands of wild rice reported in a 1984 survey were concentrated to the south of the Yangtze drainage,

这句话取反，就可以得到C了。。虽然我一直做错。。

sheepmiemieUID: 3345086

私以为，这个题目定位自然是在最后一段，讲了1894survey那里，楼上的定位是在southern理论支持者的部分，我不太赞成。。。
我的理解是这样的：
Conclusion: evidence that the 长江湿地属于both now and historical 野祖先的地理范围
Premise： two northern outlier populations were discovered along the 长江
Assumption：premise 真，那conclusion就能得到么？（这两个outlier可以证明是有野稻谷的）
这是weaken题目
A无关，不关南方的事
B上游，这里主要是说的是方向，不是上下游，文章虽然说了中下游，只是为了说明虽然大部分在南方，但也有北方，所以要强调方向才对，无关选项
C否定了最后一句结论，直接否定结论啊，否定了那个both啊啊啊啊~~~赤裸裸的答案啊~~~
D才不管它发不发达呢
E不管广阔与否

NightzzUID: 3320648

sheepmiemie 发表于 2012-11-15 22:33
私以为，这个题目定位自然是在最后一段，讲了1894survey那里，楼上的定位是在southern理论支持者的部分，我 ...

楼上妹子好萌~

麻倉枼UID: 3376337

sheepmiemie 发表于 2012-11-15 22:33
私以为，这个题目定位自然是在最后一段，讲了1894survey那里，楼上的定位是在southern理论支持者的部分，我 ...

私认为，你没有看清楚我写的东西。。

取反，是取反呀。。

考试的时候哪有那么多给你时间conclusion, premise, assumption呀。。虽然这样是对的。。

妹纸你真的萌，LS说得对。。

sheepmiemieUID: 3345086

麻倉枼 发表于 2012-11-16 00:45
私认为，你没有看清楚我写的东西。。

取反，是取反呀。。

私以为，找conclusion，premise不会很花时间啊，虽然会多花那么一点点，但是能更多地保证正确率~
我再看了一遍你写的，不好意思哈，貌似我那天没仔细看~~~赞同你的赞同你的！！！

sheepmiemieUID: 3345086

Nightzz 发表于 2012-11-15 23:16
楼上妹子好萌~

外号的英译~~~
你的也不赖嘛~~~

NightzzUID: 3320648

sheepmiemie 发表于 2012-11-17 23:13
外号的英译~~~
你的也不赖嘛~~~

我的啥啊。。。羊咩咩妹子~我这如果是外号的话应该叫Z大魔王，night是我自己加上去的，变成夜晚睡觉。。。好吧有点儿混乱，不过再赞你一次~找assumption和conclusion的方法起码我很赞同，妹子加油~

麻倉枼UID: 3376337

sheepmiemie 发表于 2012-11-17 23:12
私以为，找conclusion，premise不会很花时间啊，虽然会多花那么一点点，但是能更多地保证正确率~
我再看 ...

连帖子都看不清楚你怎么读阅读好呢？

sheepmiemieUID: 3345086

麻倉枼 发表于 2012-11-18 01:23
连帖子都看不清楚你怎么读阅读好呢？

厄，说得也对，我老是大而化之，颠三颠四的，这也许是我一直还在考G的原因吧~~~
鄙视得对~~

sheepmiemieUID: 3345086

Nightzz 发表于 2012-11-17 23:17
我的啥啊。。。羊咩咩妹子~我这如果是外号的话应该叫Z大魔王，night是我自己加上去的，变成夜晚睡觉。。。 ...

其实我昨晚是想叫你瞌睡虫来着~~哇咔咔~~~
那个方法不是我的，是普林斯顿craking的，上面讲得挺清楚的~~
恩，我加油，这次一定要给力了~~

麻倉枼UID: 3376337

sheepmiemie 发表于 2012-11-18 23:02
厄，说得也对，我老是大而化之，颠三颠四的，这也许是我一直还在考G的原因吧~~~
鄙视得对~~

我没有鄙视你呀。。你这是第几战了？
话说你和楼上的认识？

sheepmiemieUID: 3345086

麻倉枼 发表于 2012-11-18 23:35
我没有鄙视你呀。。你这是第几战了？
话说你和楼上的认识？

不认识~
我啊，这马上，这周末，三战了。。。。

NightzzUID: 3320648

sheepmiemie 发表于 2012-11-19 22:47
不认识~
我啊，这马上，这周末，三战了。。。。

这不就认识了吗~瞌睡虫。。。我囧。。。那就这么叫吧。。我是挺瞌睡的