寄托天下
查看: 5676|回复: 1
打印 上一主题 下一主题

[经典批改讨论] ISSUE17 望各位多提宝贵意见! [复制链接]

Rank: 4

声望
1
寄托币
823
注册时间
2003-8-20
精华
1
帖子
1
跳转到指定楼层
楼主
发表于 2003-12-6 16:39:48 |只看该作者 |倒序浏览

首先这篇文章的格式是最标准的:题目,提纲,总论点,分论点
再有这篇的语言很不错,尤其是句子读着很通顺.
最后逻辑清晰.

  by 木耳


17"There are two types of laws: just and unjust. Every individual in a society has a responsibility to obey just laws and, even more importantly, to disobey and resist unjust laws."

Position: It is our obligation to obey all of the laws, no matter it is just or unjust. However, if we think a law is unjust, we can amend it through a legal way .
A  Laws ensure the stability of  the whole society and the nation. If they, even though having some flaws, are easy to resist, a disarster will come sooner or later.
B  Different people has different views. A law that is considered unjust may be in fact just.
C  Even if a law is indeed unjust, it should be corrected legally, and before the amendment comes out, everyone ought to obey it.

  Laws are the principle of a country or a society, and needless to say, it plays an important role in stablizing the nation. But, sometimes, we can feel that some law are not fit, that is to say, unjust in some sense. Thus, some, who believe in just, disobey and resist these so-called unjust laws. The resistance to laws, I take leave to doubt, is not right, even though the law they resist indeed has some weakpoint. It is the obligation of us citizens to obey all of the laws, no matter it is just or unjust. However, if a law is definitely unjust, we can amend it through a legal way.

  The important function of laws is that they ensure the stability of the whole society and the nation. If they, even though having some flaws, are easy to resist, a disarster will come sooner or later. In modern society, almost all the movements are based on laws, the lack of which will damage the society seriously. Each of us must communicate with different persons, including those with a high spirite and those boors. To defend our own interests, preventing it from damaging, the most effective measure that we can take is law, which serves as a God, regulating everyone's behavior. Think yourself as a businessman, who make a trade with a company. You are so unfortunate that the company has deceived you and shifted a mint of monry from your account surrepticiously. What should you do? Yes, what is the most important is to prosecute the company. Only in this way can we protect ourselves, and only in this way, can a country work well. History has proved that the nation without a mature structure of laws, in the end, will be trapped into confusion. We can see the case of China in 1910s, when the former Dynasty Qing had nearly been overturned and the laws had lost their effect completely. Disorder of the whole society, just like a demon, made Chinese suffer a lot. This had maintained for nearly 40 years until the newbirth of the People's Republic of China. After 1949, laws were regulated and the society returned to peace. From it, it is obvious that law, the fundametal of the nation, is indispensable.

  Further more, different people has different views about the extend of justice of a law. It is likely that the law who think is unjust is, from a high level, just and suitable to the society. If it receives resist, the nation will receive harmness. The well-being of the individual citizens, on most occasions, has a lot in common with the interest of the whole society. But, sometimes, they are in the opposite directions. Whenever this happens, the law, which represents the interest of the nation and the majority of the people, will inevitably deprive that of some persons or groups. In a giant country, it is common. Just put yourself in the position of those whose interest is deprived by the law and it is quite possible that you will say that the law is unjust, because it brings you negative influence. Then, rechange yourself into another, whose is just an outsider, and probably, you will change your mind. And that the crux. Sometimes, law is unjust when it is opposite to us, even though it is actually just. If we risist it, just because we only fix our eyes on ourselves, the society will be damaged as a result of the resist. Thus, when we resist a law, we should think twice before leap.

  However, we can not say, that all the laws are absolutely correct, and they are all just without any exeption. If, after a careful examination and a wide-range discussion, some law is asserted unjust or unsuitable, it is our obligation the resist it and amend it. However, that does never mean we could violate it if we like, at anytime, on any circumstances, but we should amend it with the legal right. Before the amendment is enacted, what we should do is still to obey the law. The reanson of this is nothing but the order is the crucial principle that makes sure of the vectification of the law. Merely with this method can we expect a new, more just law.

  In sum, obeying to laws is the obligation of every citizens, whether it is just or unjust. On the other hand, to resist a really unjust law is permitted, not disorderly, but legally.
0 0

使用道具 举报

Rank: 9Rank: 9Rank: 9

声望
7
寄托币
7885
注册时间
2003-1-17
精华
7
帖子
17

Scorpio天蝎座 荣誉版主

沙发
发表于 2003-12-6 18:10:38 |只看该作者
Laws are the principle of a country or a society, and needless to say, it (单复数要统一)plays an important role in stablizing the nation. But, sometimes, we can feel that some law(复数) are not fit, that is to say, unjust in some sense. Thus, some, who believe in just(belive in:信任.这个搭配在这里怎么讲?), disobey and resist these so-called unjust laws. The resistance to laws, I take leave to doubt, is not right, even though the law they resist indeed has some weakpoint. It is the obligation of us citizens to obey all of the laws, no matter it is(用复数) just or unjust. However, if a law is definitely unjust, we can amend it through a legal way.

从第一段看出语言很不错,看得出你基本功很扎实.逻辑也挺清晰.

The important function of laws is that they ensure the stability of the whole society and the nation. If they, even though having some flaws, are easy to resist, a disarster will come sooner or later. In modern society, almost all the movements are based on laws, the lack of which will damage the society seriously. Each of us must communicate with different persons, including those with a high spirite and those boors. To defend our own interests, preventing it from damaging, the most effective measure that we can take is law, which serves as a God(serves as a God?怎么理解?), regulating everyone's behavior(复数). Think yourself as a businessman, who make a trade with a company. You are so unfortunate that the company has deceived you and shifted a mint of monry from your account surrepticiously. What should you do? Yes, what is the most important is to prosecute the company. Only in this way can we protect ourselves, and only in this way, can a country work well. History has proved that the nation without a mature structure of laws, in the end, will be trapped into confusion. We can see the case of China in 1910s, when the former Dynasty Qing had nearly been overturned and the laws had lost their effect completely. Disorder of the whole society, just like a demon, made Chinese suffer a lot. This had maintained for nearly 40 years until the newbirth of the People's Republic of China. After 1949, laws were regulated and the society returned to peace. From it, it is obvious that law, the fundametal of the nation, is indispensable.

感觉有些罗嗦.还有人称问题.习惯上比较严谨的论述文一般很少用第一和第二人称.
论点的第二部分: even though having some flaws, are easy to resist, a disarster will come sooner or later.好像论证的不是很充分

Further more, different people has different views about the extend of justice of a law. It is likely that the law who think is unjust is, from a high level, just and suitable to the society. If it receives resist, the nation will receive harmness. The well-being of the individual citizens(直接用individuals就可以了), on most occasions, has a lot in common with the interest of the whole society. But, sometimes, they are in the opposite directions. Whenever this happens, the law, which represents the interest of the nation and the majority of the people, will inevitably deprive that of some persons or groups. In a giant(这个词不太恰当.用复杂更好) country, it is common. Just put yourself in the position of those whose interest is deprived by the law and it is quite possible that you will say that the law is unjust, because it brings you negative influence.(带来负面的影响还不如直接说损害了当事人的利益)Then, rechange yourself into another, whose(whose?) is just an outsider(局外人也不是很恰当.前面既然已经讲了法律是关系到整个社会的,保护大众利益的,那谁也不能说是局外人), and probably, you will change your mind. And that(is) the crux. Sometimes, law is(用复数要好一些) unjust when it is opposite to us, even though it is actually just.(这句话和上面好像没有什么更深的逻辑关系,重复了吧? If we risist it, just because we only fix our eyes on ourselves, the society will be damaged as a result of the resist. Thus, when we resist a law, we should think twice before leap.

前面写的还不错,但后面的重复了.
However, we can not say, that all the laws are absolutely correct, and (or)they are all just without any exeption. If, after a careful examination and a wide-range discussion, some law is(复数) asserted unjust or unsuitable, it is our obligation the(to) resist it and amend it. However, that does never mean we could violate it if we like, at anytime, on any circumstances, but we should amend it with the legal right. Before the amendment is enacted, what we should do is still to obey the law. The reanson of this is nothing but the order is the crucial principle that makes sure of the vectification of the law. Merely with this method can we expect a new, more just law.

In sum, obeying to laws is the obligation of every citizens, whether it is just or unjust. On the other hand, to resist a really unjust law is permitted, not disorderly, but legally.
写得很不错!印象最深的是你的语言,没有一般人常犯的胡写长句的毛病.词语,搭配,句子的把握都很不错.不过还是有些小问题:
1 注意单复数
2 注意人称
逻辑上也挺清晰,段与段之间没有重复的地方.不过每一段都略显罗嗦了一些.而且查了一下,正文竟然有760多字!这样的字数在考试的时候是很难按时达到的.
还有一点,我个人不是很同意你的论点.我觉得在必要的时候unjust laws就要用暴力反抗.你在稳中只是强调了稳定的重要性和社会的复杂性而没有提unjust laws可能给社会带来的害处.这篇文章以前也有不少人写过,我好像也写过.你可以去习题库中查一下.
加油!
生活在此处

使用道具 举报

RE: ISSUE17 望各位多提宝贵意见! [修改]

问答
Offer
投票
面经
最新
精华
转发
转发该帖子
ISSUE17 望各位多提宝贵意见!
https://bbs.gter.net/thread-153873-1-1.html
复制链接
发送
回顶部