一道逻辑题，求思路

bigtraceUID: 3409203

Which of the following most logically
completes the argument?
Virtually all respondents to a recent voter
survey reported allegiance to one of the two
major political parties. But over a third of the
voters from each party reported being so
disenchanted with the governing philosophies
of both parties that they might join a third
major party if one were formed. Even if this
poll reflects general voter sentiment, however,
there is no chance that a new party could
attract a third of all voters, since----.

bigtraceUID: 3409203

(A) the current level of disenchantment with the
governing philosophies of the two major
parties is unprecedented
(B) the disenchanted members of the two major
parties are attracted to very different
governing philosophies
(C) most respondents overestimated the proportion
of voters disenchanted with both parties, saving
that the proportion was more than 50 percent
(D) nearly half of all respondents reported that
they would be more likely to cease voting
altogether than to switch their party affiliation
(E) any new party would be likely to inspire
citizens who have not voted before to join
and to become regular voters

bigtraceUID: 3409203

我觉得按道理应该是说第三个政党不能迎合这部分人的思路的原因，而B选项并没有直接提到为什么新的党就不能吸引这部分选民的注意，我觉得D选项要更好些

crazyrobinUID: 2368627

D是个number game 这 50%可能是1/3除外的50% 那么也就是说还是会有1/3会被swing
B对了在一个地方， very different rulings 那么 third party不可能去分别cater这两种ruling 因此 a new party will never attract the overall 1/3 of the entire disenchanted members

bigtraceUID: 3409203

懂了，多谢版主！

iSNSDUID: 3719887

crazyrobin 发表于 2013-5-11 17:08
D是个number game 这 50%可能是1/3除外的50% 那么也就是说还是会有1/3会被swing
B对了在一个地方， very d ...

你好，请问原文中“But over a third of the voters from each party reported being so disenchanted with。。。” 这句话是什么意思？是所有受访者中的1/3对政策不满（不管是忠于哪个党的），还是各个党的支持者中都有1/3对这个党的政策不满？谢谢

leelightmanUID: 3239996

iSNSD 发表于 2016-6-14 08:55
你好，请问原文中“But over a third of the voters from each party reported being so disenchanted wi ...

我感觉应该是各个党1/3的前支持者