请教一道manhattan的逻辑题

mailliw1UID: 3206693

这是关于这道选项的解释
(D) CORRECT.  This statement explains that the number of diners in the town of Montrose as a whole has increased due to the opening of Bob’s Bistro, and also explains why the patronage at Andrew’s Eatery has increased. Bob’s Bistro has apparently brought in many out-of-towners to eat at Montrose, and many of these first-time diners, when turned away from Bob’s Bistro, arrive at Andrew’s Eatery as the only alternative in town.
这个解释不是主观的认为多余的顾客会去旁边的餐厅了么？既然是被B餐厅吸引，那顾客为什么不能等位或者在这个town吃了？感觉这个选项也不是很对啊。不一定能解释为什么上座率提升

希望中的玫瑰UID: 2909568

我觉得这题的gap要找的关键在于BB的opening does not threat the business of A.
用elimination来试试。
A项，A's price lower than B's，we cannot promise the lower price is the wish of the customers. so eliminate it.
B项，a neighboring town is out of scope, eliminate
C, the profit is irrelevant to the context
E, serves more meal does not mean that more people will buy this meal, omit E
D, B bring lots of patron who first dined in M, and the seats of B cannot accommodate these people, as the A is the only another restaurant in M, so these new customers will go to A, which caused the increase in business of A in last year.

mailliw1UID: 3206693

希望中的玫瑰 发表于 2013-8-24 20:54
我觉得这题的gap要找的关键在于BB的opening does not threat the business of A.
用elimination来试试。
...

是这样的，我的意思是说答案本身也不是很对。也不能认为有更多的顾客来town就有更多的顾客去A啊

Leon-WangUID: 2772364

关键是要看，为什么有竞争对手之后到AE就餐的数量反而上升了，D说有本来打算到BB吃饭的人（说不定BB营销做得好，吸引了一些本来不在外面吃饭的人）因为BB客满就去AE吃饭了。

希望中的玫瑰UID: 2909568

mailliw1 发表于 2013-8-24 21:07
是这样的，我的意思是说答案本身也不是很对。也不能认为有更多的顾客来town就有更多的顾客去A啊

这题里面说，A是这个town里除了B之外的唯一一个restaurant呀。

mailliw1UID: 3206693

希望中的玫瑰 发表于 2013-8-25 09:01
这题里面说，A是这个town里除了B之外的唯一一个restaurant呀。

就算是唯一的餐厅，那b满了就一定要到a吃？为什么不能等位或者干脆就不吃了？D选项也没说多余的顾客去a了啊，只是说有时候餐厅爆满坐不下了。然后就推出这些多了的顾客去a吃了？