EX16 Q6

HardyNiborUID: 3461489

By writing in English and experimenting with European literary forms, contemporary American Indian writers have broadened their potential audience, while clearly retaining many essential characteristics of their ancestral oral traditions.

6. Which of the following is most likely one of the
reasons that the author mentions the work of
N. Scott Momaday?

(A) To illustrate how the author believes that
some American Indian writers have broadened
their potential audience

(D) To suggest that contemporary American Indian
writers have sacrificed traditional values for
popular literary success

应该是D更全面吧

HardyNiborUID: 3461489

小飞行UID: 2980207

sacrificed traditional values这个地方不准确，并不是原文表达的内容。问题是说author mentions，表示的是表面的推断，不需要你去深入理解。

HardyNiborUID: 3461489

小飞行 发表于 2013-9-15 15:48
sacrificed traditional values这个地方不准确，并不是原文表达的内容。问题是说author mentions，表示的是 ...

作者紧接着引用的这句就举例子，并且例子也是得到了什么又失去了什么。A只有得到没有失去，D两个都有。如何判定作者只是为了强调得到而不是相反的那个，或者两个并重呢

小飞行UID: 2980207

HardyNibor 发表于 2013-9-15 16:11
作者紧接着引用的这句就举例子，并且例子也是得到了什么又失去了什么。A只有得到没有失去，D两个都有。如 ...

你截取的不是题目的定位？这是红书里面的阅读题吗？

小飞行UID: 2980207

By writing in English and experimenting with European literary forms, contemporary American Indian writers have broadened their potential audience, while clearly retaining many essential characteristics of their ancestral oral traditions.

蓝色的部分只是补充作用，感觉作者重点突出的还是红色部分，提及当代印第安作者的发展，才是文章的主线。那么auther提及Scott的理由应该是为主线服务的。

小飞行UID: 2980207

这套题还没做到，晚上回寝室做了再看看。以上是个人的浅见。

HardyNiborUID: 3461489

小飞行 发表于 2013-9-15 16:28
这套题还没做到，晚上回寝室做了再看看。以上是个人的浅见。

如果主线真的如此那你说的都对。我也再研究一下。谢谢啦