一短阅读求指点~

WWOWUID: 3649627

Scholars often fail to see that music played an important role in the preservation of African culture in the United States. They correctly note that slavery stripped some cultural elements from Black people-their political and economic systems-but they underestimate the significance of music in sustaining other African cultural values. African music, unlike the music of some other cultures, was based on a total vision of life in which music was not an isolated social domain. In African culture music was pervasive, serving not only religion, but all phases of life, including birth, death, work, and play. Music, like art in general, was so inextricably a part of African culture that it became a crucial means of preserving the culture during and after the dislocations of slavery.

10. In the argument given , the two highlighted portions
play which of the following roles?
○A The first sentence introduces the topic of the
passage and the last one summarizes the passage.
○B The first sentence presents a thesis and the last one
further develops the thesis.
○C The first sentence summarizes the main idea of the
passage and the last one paraphrases it literally.
○D The first sentence presents a context for the
discussion of the passage and the last one
summarizes the discussion.
○E The first sentence presents the negative thesis of the
passage and the last one presents the positive thesis.

答案是E，但B和D好像也挺对的，哪位大神帮我分析一下~~谢谢

crazyrobinUID: 2368627

B不对，如果是develop最后一句话应该是说怎么fail，在讲原因过着结果后果。但是最后一句话说的完全是另外一回事。

D错在前面的部分，并没有提供一个discussion，如果是discussion应该会谈论怎么fail了，为什么fail，etc

crazyrobinUID: 2368627

另外你的文章请标明下出处，标题不要总是说“问一篇短文”你标一下出处，以后的版友可以更方便的搜索

WWOWUID: 3649627

crazyrobin 发表于 2015-9-18 20:59
B不对，如果是develop最后一句话应该是说怎么fail，在讲原因过着结果后果。但是最后一句话说的完全是另外一 ...

好的明白了，谢谢R神！ 另外这是阅读36套E25中的，以后会注意标注的~