HKUST VS HKU 求选校建议！！！

cheesechanUID: 3505689

lun1001 发表于 2016-4-26 20:32
非常感谢你的详细回复！！！因为这个两个专业都不是我的首选，所以真的比较纠结。我本人毕业后并不打算长 ...

但是在内地的话，非盈利这块可能主要还是政府职能方面居多，像非营利组织的发展比较有限，这个是我比较担忧的地方，在大陆不好就业。

<--- This makes sense, but then why do you think a social science major will be a better choice in China then?


另外就是，港大在大陆的认可度貌似还是高于科大？
<--- yes. especially not in business/science/engineering.

cindykissUID: 2692541

lun1001 发表于 2016-4-26 20:38
谢谢你的回复！！！我这些天也在网上查资料，但是这两个专业有点冷，我能找到的资料有限，都是学校官网上 ...

你可以综合以后就业的需求判断，如果回内地的话差别不大。

cheesechanUID: 3505689

cindykiss 发表于 2016-4-26 21:04
1，您随便问问全国top5社会学和政治学老师，问问他们hkust的情况
2，eco又不是只有bschool才有，科大ss  ...

1. You made this claim, and thus it should be you yourself to show the evidence, instead of asking others to do it.

2a. Showing one data point is useless. Outliers is everywhere. if you want to make your claim valid, you have to show that it is easier to become an economics faculty in HKUST Social science when compared with HKU one.
2b. Obviously OP don't plan for PhD. Showing views from academics doesn't matter at all.

cindykissUID: 2692541

cheesechan 发表于 2016-4-26 21:11
1. You made this claim, and thus it should be you yourself to show the evidence, instead of asking ...

学科学术综合水平看同行认可度和论文发表你是否认可。ss又不像b school有utd排名，论文没有绝对权威的排行；同行认可度我前面说了这几年正在进行的一项全国高校合作的大规模抽样社会调查，香港地区科大拿到而不是港大或者中文，你又不看。
第二个只是为了证明经济学不仅仅在b school，ss教出来phd，据我所知至今至少5人，去经济学院教书算不算证据呢？

cheesechanUID: 3505689

cindykiss 发表于 2016-4-26 21:19
学科学术综合水平看同行认可度和论文发表你是否认可。ss又不像b school有utd排名，论文没有绝对权威的排 ...

1. it is quite a joke to use only 一项社会调查 as an indicator of 同行认可度.

2. Please understand what others is asking before replying.

cindykissUID: 2692541

cheesechan 发表于 2016-4-26 21:34
1. it is quite a joke to use only 一项社会调查 as an indicator of 同行认可度.

2. Please underst ...

1  as long as you even do not know which project I am talking about and how that project is influential, I can say for sure you are not a insider of ss. So, well, say whatever you feel happy :)
2  I mentioned eco was strong in ss of hukst and you said I cannot locate eco to social science and it belongs to b school. So I replied eco is in both b school and ss, also to support this point I said phds from ss can go to eco for faculty positions. what is the problem??? are you using English for a long time so you cannot recognize Chinese words?

I guess you are doing eco or similar thing. One last sentence, many scholars from b-school like om finance mkt do not really believe eco is so "b-school". talk to them boy, contentious never helps

cheesechanUID: 3505689

cindykiss 发表于 2016-4-26 21:47
1  as long as you even do not know which project I am talking about and how that project is infl ...

1.a even if the survey is so representative, I will still doubt if it is a good indicator. Firstly, is the school solely selected based on academics excellence? Secondly, China is just a small part of the worldwide academic world. Their view is surly far from the full picture, and can just served as one of a useful reference.

1.b. again, given OP is not planning to do a PhD in SS or econ or whatever, why he/she has to care about how the insider think about this? what is relevant is what the outsider feels instead.
What you had said is irrelevant for OP. all those example you made is about their PhD program, but not the MA.

2. What I mean is not that you cannot allocate economics to social science, but you cannot allocation the HKUST economics to HKUST social science.

P.S. and I also feel that it is quite hard to say, academically, a aggregate ranking in social science, since social science is such a big field, which include politics, economics, psychology, and etc.....

RankMatrixUID: 3785858

哈登天下无敌 发表于 2016-4-26 20:48
HKUST ＋ 社科or文科，不是一般odd，而是very odd。
CUHK，HKU两个在社科文科方面在香港被认为是一流的。 ...

这么黑我科大，良心不痛吗

Rachel的2019UID: 3889780

小姐姐我也想申请2019fall的HKU，npo这个项目，想咨询仙女一些事情不知道仙女方不方便加我v信：15567431660，灰常感恩，十分感激，谢谢????。