英国读法律本科，Oxford ,LSE, UCL &HKU 双学位，怎么选？

匿名用户799982UID: 3738277

ricky.chou 发表于 2017-2-27 20:10
层主可以去Oxford Law官网翻一翻BCL/MJur的简历合集，在我印象中一年有HKU背景的至少有10个。

OxBridg ...

香港oxBridge随处可见是因为他们都倾向于来英国读书吧 不能说明哈耶斯比oxbridge要怎样把 而且学制问题 美国没有本科法律 所以导致hk英国背景的多一些:p

whxiaofeizaiUID: 2567498

感觉回大陆的话，牛津的LLB比哈佛JD高一个tier，和耶鲁JD是不相伯仲。也许是我的错觉吧。

madisonparkUID: 3726062

michaelchenwish 发表于 2017-2-10 13:39
1. 香港的法律市场不小 - 因为鬼佬基本上都不信任中国法律，而国内的公司和执法环境有不会让一个交易适用 ...

ricky.chouUID: 3553360

whxiaofeizai 发表于 2017-3-13 09:16
感觉回大陆的话，牛津的LLB比哈佛JD高一个tier，和耶鲁JD是不相伯仲。也许是我的错觉吧。

可是能上哈佛JD的，很多本科也是HYPMS blablabla...

totoorawUID: 3240632

whxiaofeizai 发表于 2017-3-13 09:16
感觉回大陆的话，牛津的LLB比哈佛JD高一个tier，和耶鲁JD是不相伯仲。也许是我的错觉吧。

你这HLS也待了快半年多了，竟然还得出这个结论，真有意思。

michaelchenwishartUID: 3673022

totooraw 发表于 2017-3-13 18:18
你这HLS也待了快半年多了，竟然还得出这个结论，真有意思。

我靠，大神你怎么出来了！！！

totoorawUID: 3240632

ricky.chou 发表于 2017-3-12 21:52
亲 这么自信的语气回复 一定是亲手数过吧？

不好意思噢，今年Class of 2016/2017，有HKU背景的刚好10个 ...

好啊，我来看你数的对不对，看你理解是否对：

今年profile book 在这里：

https://www.law.ox.ac.uk/sites/f ... r_profile_book_.pdf

首先，我们要澄清概念，牛津录取读BCL，是看你第一学位。PCLL是个vocational training阶段，所以你要做这个区分。为了在香港职业，刚毕业人必须要读香港的PCLL，没有其他路。所以我们数在HKU 读法律，到底多少人能被BCL录取，我们要看他/她在哪里获取第一学位。第二个需要澄清的是楼主问的是读法律本科孩子的出路。我们对下面这些人还要做这样的必要区别，应为楼主的孩子是高中后去读本科，所以我要看在HKU读本科，最后多少人能进牛津读BCL。

根据以下信息，发现7个HKU申请到去读BCL的- JD毕业人4个， HKU LLB毕业3个人。所以对楼主有用的信息是 --HKU本科毕业，有多少人有这样机会？这么多人中，只有三个人有这样的机会。 今年HKU JD被录取了四个，这个跟今年BCL录取香港学生是个不寻常一年也有关--今年港城大和中大都没有人去读BCL，这是个很不寻常的情况。

根据我查看信息：
1. Tiff Chan
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, PCLL
(06/2016)
UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD, UK, BA JURISPRUDENCE
(06/2015)
Graduated with first-class-honours; studied subjects
included company and family law

这个人第一法学院为Oxford, 读BCL等于自己学生读研究生。他在牛津就是first class，所以符合入读BCL的特点。 前面说过，PCLL是他要在香港职业必经之路。你不能把他归类给HKU申请过去的学生。 这人归类给牛津本科申请牛津BCL。

2.Jasmine Cheung
EDUCATION
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG,
POSTGRADUATE CERTIFICATE IN LAWS (07/2016)
Graduated with distinction; awarded HKSAR Government
Scholarship and Hou De Charitable Foundation Scholarship
for PCLL
UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE, UK, BA (HONS) IN LAW
(06/2015)
Graduated with triple first-class honours; ranked 4th in
second year; awarded a number of scholarships; top score
in ‘criminal procedure and evidence’

这个人是剑桥本科，剑桥法学里面极其优秀毕业生，然后申请BCL路。他在香港读PCLL情况跟上面人一样。

3. Dominic Chiang
EDUCATION
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, PCLL
(06/2016)
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, JD
(07/2015)

这人是否符合HKU 申请过去读BCL，所以我编号为第一个。

4.Nicole Chui

EDUCATION
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, PCLL
(06/2016)
Graduated with distinction
UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD, UK, BA JURISPRUDENCE
(06/2015)
Graduated with first-class honours; studied subjects
including taxation law and family law; Keble College Prize
for performance in the Final Honours School
Graduated with first-class honours
CHINESE UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG,
BBA (06/2013)

Graduated with first-class honours

这人也是牛津本科申请BCL，读HKU PCLL道理如上。

5.Jennifer Fan

EDUCATION
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, PCLL
(07/2016)
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, JD
(06/2015)
Graduated with first-class honours; Betty Ho Prize in Law;
HKU JD Prize
HARVARD UNIVERSITY, USA, BA (05/2013)
Graduated cum laude with honours in field; Phi Beta Kappa;
John Harvard Scholar

这人符合HKU 申请过去读BCL， 所以编号为第二个。

6.Rosa Ka Yee Lee,
EDUCATION
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, PCLL
(06/2016)
Graduated with distinction
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, LLB
(06/2015)
Graduated with first-class honours
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, BBA (LAW)
(06/2013)
Graduated with first-class honours
这人符合HKU 申请过去读BCL， 所以编号为第三个。

7.Erica Li

EDUCATION
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, LLB
(06/2016)
Graduated with first-class honours
这人符合HKU 申请过去读BCL， 所以编号为第四个。

8. Hin Ting Liu

EDUCATION
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, LLB
(06/2016)
First-class honours; graduated 1/172; published eight
articles in peer-reviewed law journals; best performance
in LLB for seven subjects; received ten awards and
scholarships
UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE, UK, LAW TRIPOS PART II
(06/2015)

这人符合HKU 申请过去读BCL， 所以编号为第五个。

9.  Florence Sit

EDUCATION
UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HK, JD (07/2016)
Graduated with first-class honours; awarded Betty Ho
Prize for Overall Academic Excellence, subject prizes in
constitutional law, tort law, and criminal law
POLITICS AND ECONOMICS, UNIVERSITY OF
PENNSYLVANIA, USA, BA IN PHILOSOPHY (05/2013)
Graduated with magna cum laude honours; received
Outstanding Leader award

这人符合HKU 申请过去读BCL， 所以编号为第六个。

10 Sicheng Zhu

EDUCATION
THE UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG, HONG KONG, JURIS
DOCTOR (07/2016)
XI’AN JIAO TONG UNIVERSITY, CHINA, BACHELOR OF
LAWS (07/2013)
这人符合HKU 申请过去读BCL， 所以编号为第七个。

总结：7个HKU申请到去读BCL的- JD毕业人4个， HKU LLB毕业3个人