- 最后登录
- 2011-7-19
- 在线时间
- 324 小时
- 寄托币
- 53977
- 声望
- 35
- 注册时间
- 2004-3-27
- 阅读权限
- 175
- 帖子
- 30
- 精华
- 53
- 积分
- 22276
- UID
- 159645
   
- 声望
- 35
- 寄托币
- 53977
- 注册时间
- 2004-3-27
- 精华
- 53
- 帖子
- 30
|
No.1 issue41 nonmainstream areas 的有益性(当然反对啦)
41"Such non-mainstream areas of inquiry as astrology, fortune-telling, and psychic and paranormal pursuits play a vital role in society by satisfying human needs that are not addressed by mainstream science."
Do nonmainstream areas of inquiry satisfy human needs in some realms in stead of mainstream science so that it is vital for the whole society? The author claims so. 【用问句restate了一下,首先要说,restate的写法我不支持的,而且,问句开头现在也是被用的太多了】 However, for my part, the claim is far less dear and seems to veil the ugly truth of these nonmainstream areas--that is to push the people and society into abyss. 【说的很吓人哦:D 】
To support the contention, the author perhaps【是你要猜想题目结论的前提吗?不如肯定一点,你可以说持这种观点的人一定是立足于这样的前提:ABC】 points out three reasons about the irreplaceable advantage of nonmainstream areas. Learning about the knowledge, people are temporarily satisfied the explanation of some secrets which mainstream science hasn’t answered or formed a uniform and convincible answer. Learning about our own fate connotated by the fortune-telling and astrology, people can escape from the adversities and grasp the opportunities. Learning about the so-called “supreme world” in terms of psychic and paranormal pursuits, we level up the life value and are beneficial to the society as saviors. 【我们是救世主?】 Nevertheless, the reasons which buttress the claim at the first glance are exactly the evidence to justify how fallacious and dangerous they themselves are. 【用argument的语言作出反驳】
【否定了题目观点的前提,论述的不错,总领下文,分三点展开,不过第三点我觉得不是很好】
Notwithstanding many phenomenons, 【这个已经是复数了】 such as the source 【origin好点】 of life and the aftermath of death【感觉aftermath用在这里不是很合适】, are still not clear in the angle of mainstream science, to believe the explanation of nonmainstream areas equals to deny the truth forever. 【太绝对了啊,应该避免用绝对性的语言】 In the nonmainstream areas, people are taught to ascribe the unexplainable phenomenon to the power of the God, who maybe emperor, leader or some fictive identity【该用复数】. These explanations are regarded as the relief of people's fear and worry from the unknown world. Actually, this is other way around. 【新概念patterns of culture里面的句子,不过应该是it is the other way around】 Common sense tells us that to establish a brand new concept is easier than to break the existing fixed concept and re-establish a concept on the original location. That is, people's eyes are blinded by these false explanations so that they are unable to see the sunshine and escape from the black【dark ,gloomy,murky会好一点】 evening of ignorance. Once the scientific sound from the mainstream about these elusive problems comes to the world, their view and understanding about the world will collapse so that they will live at sea 【你指的是什么啊?】
【说理还不错,但是,没有例子,所以让人感觉生硬枯燥了点】
Referring to the healthy life attitudes, although nonmainstream areas seem owning the marvelous power to foresee the fate of individual as well as the world, it leads to pessimist【你想说pessimism?】 and negative attitudes. They【who?】 are worried about encountering the “fated” adversities all the times and be unable to experience and cherish the happiness. Consider the "centuries", which was written by Notradamus. 【诸世纪我看过,嘿嘿,不过诺查丹玛斯的名字你拼错了,是Nostradamus,好像这个名字是一个单词,或者说引申成了一个单词】 In the book, it 【这里说he感觉比较好】 foretells several catastrophes in the course of human's history. The recent so-called "evitable【你想说inevitable?】 catastrophe" is the year of 2000, 【应该是1999年7月,Century X 72—《诸世纪》第十章第72篇】 which was described as the doomsday. Many people are so obsessed with the foretelling that they had been frightened even committed suicide before the year of 2000 came. Nonetheless, now is the year of 2005 and the world does exist even become 【去掉】 more beautiful. 【这里应该说safe,secure之类的吧】 Thus, the future is hold by people’s own hands not【but not】 determined by the ridiculous prediction of nonmainstream areas.
【这段的例子很好,不过,引用的时候注意准确,尤其是人名一定要写对】
Additionally, to pursue the psyche 【题目的psychic我觉得不是取其精神的意思而是超自然的意思,所以不应该用psyche做为其名词形式,应该用psychic,它本身就是名词,表示“psychic phenomena”】 and paranormality【没查到这个词,用paranormal phenomena表达好一点吧】 is deleterious for human and the stability of a society. Advocating the psychic and paranormal pursuit, many heresies attempt to control people's mind and reach their confidential 【surreptitious 好一点吧】 goals through the so-called psychic and paranormal pursuits. Many giaours 【这个词是伊斯兰教指基督教徒的用语,不太合适】 are sacrificed for the name of kindness, beauty and truth. Nevertheless, the deceptive kindness, beauty and truth are the trick of the heresy leader. In their eyes, the sacrificed people are merely instruments which they take advantage of for the aim of money, fame or status. Additionally, 【前面用过了,换一下,furthermore,moreover等等】 the heresies threaten the stability of the society. Accompanying with the death of the innocent people, how many families suffer from the breaking up? How many couples suffer from losing the husbands or wives? Also, how many children lose their parents? Disguising the symbol of kindness, truth and beauty, these nonmainstream areas, in fact, embody the hangman.
【第一个问题是你一再的用heresy,你的意思是要说邪教,但是,这个不是很准确的。第二个问题是,邪教的问题似乎不是psychic and paranormal的典型,而你到后面有点偷换概念的嫌疑,把反驳psychic and paranormal变成反驳邪教了,这里再斟酌一下】
As the evil with a mask of angel, such nonmainstream areas of inquiry have no good to the human. Instead, they destroy the harmonious society by trap, trick and lie【through trapping tricking/cheating and lying会不会好点】. In fact, although mainstream science is impossible to expel all muddle now, human are available to acquire satisfaction from various positive and healthy entertainments. 【这句说的不好,这些困惑其实是对于一些未知世界的困惑不解,我觉得这种困惑不是entertainments可以解决的】 For my belief, only holding the scientific view about the world, we will enjoy the kindness, truth and beauty!
【结构清楚,语言流畅,有一些小错误,而且B1的第三点和B4有点问题。不过,文章给我的感觉是写成了一篇argument,一直在反驳反驳反驳,issue应该是立论文的,你这样写的风险很大,很可能会被认为对于issue写法理解不清而低分的。加油!】 |
|