- 最后登录
- 2009-6-18
- 在线时间
- 178 小时
- 寄托币
- 3346
- 声望
- 0
- 注册时间
- 2004-7-14
- 阅读权限
- 30
- 帖子
- 1
- 精华
- 5
- 积分
- 2150
- UID
- 169978
 
- 声望
- 0
- 寄托币
- 3346
- 注册时间
- 2004-7-14
- 精华
- 5
- 帖子
- 1
|
非常感谢davidjacky的细致批改:)
非常感谢davidjacky的细致批改,辛苦版主了:)
观点:不同意。
1有必要要求个人负责。
2外力确有影响。
3虽然外力限制,个人仍有很大的选择和行动空间。
4一些情况下,个人能改变阻碍的行动的外力。
例子:贝多芬,文革选择,sars问题揭露有四个段落?但是你这样的安排有些问题,你尝试调整一下,因为你3、4都涉及2外力,那么你干脆先说外力的影响;然后再说3、4,最后说何况,有必要让个人负责
我想是我错了,让步太多,重点太后,谢谢!
Issue93 第20篇 让砖头来得更猛烈些吧!
------摘要------
作者:寄托家园作文版普通用户 共用时间:69分31秒 396-652 words
从2005年2月10日12时3分到2005年2月10日13时69分
------题目------
The concept of 'individual responsibility' is a necessary fiction. Although societies must hold individuals accountable for their own actions, people's behavior is largely determined by forces not of their own making.
------正文------
Is it true that the conception of "individual responsibility is a necessary fiction and although societies must hold individuals accountable for their own actions, people's behavior is largely determined by forces not of their own making?这样的照抄实在不敢恭维,能不能转述一下 I agree that societies must have individuals accountable for their own action. However, I disagree with the speaker's second contention; in my view, people's actionsaction is largely determined by their own making; thus, the conception of "individual responsibility" is not a fiction but a reasonable one?a reasonable fiction吗?.davidjacky好细心,这个问题我几遍没发现
First, it is necessary that society should require individuals to be responsible for what he or she has done; otherwise, society will become a lawless, anarchical one where people have no sense of safety and. reassurance The responsibility forced everyone behaves in a proper way, not hurting others or obey the laws. Although there are some exceptions, for example, psychotics whose behavior are out of control. The most people should be responsible to their own making.看了你这么薄弱的论述,我看这段不要算了论证是薄弱:()
Then consider which can determine people's behavior.
从这里开始写Admittedly, forces outside make an important role byin influencingand changing individuals' behavior, either indirectly by imparting public ideas and well-described value system or directly via limiting our choices to some extent. 谢谢,紧凑多了!The circumstance around us may affect our behavior indirectly by imparting its idea and value system to influence us, also can limited our choices to some extent directly. Indeed, everyone lives in complicated conditions which may change us in some cases, especially to the psychotics who cannot control themselves.这个例子缺乏思考,好好考虑一下继续点头……
However, people can alsoalso不要 determine their actionsby their own efforts in most cases in most cases by their effort. Just as the old saying goes, while God shut a door, he will leave a window天无绝人之路?学习中…..不一定对,是自己翻的西方俗语 We usually have many choices in our life and work, using the current conditions we have. People can make their decision everyday, from what to eat to what to wear; from whom to be friends to whom to lover小声的问一下,你有男友吗?呵呵,事实上我想问的是这种what to do的结构倒问题不大,那个whom to be friends with和whom to be a lover才对,注意一下,lover是不是应该只有一个,要不怎么说来着,红什么出什么省了a,语法疏忽,是用的单数。不过whom to be friends吧,因为前面只说choose; and also the jobs, the ideas alike. Even the forces outside seemsto be too strong to obey, people should also have their waysthere should have some alternatives. For example, a history professor in my university cannot endure the violence and cruelty of abusing even killing inculpable teachers比较残忍,can not bear the violent and cruel persecution to the innocent and armless clerisy, typical of teachers, at the beginning of CR happened about 4o years before in china,when不要了 in Culture Revolution more than 30 years ago when he was a junior student, he choose to leave the city for remote countryside where political老外不太清楚这是political的影响,可以说成these influences are so weak that he 没有作同样的事情 influence are more weak. Thus, he avoid his wrong when many of his classmates just saying that we are determined by force. Also, when Beethoven became deaf, he was not subjective to the strong force of his physical condition; he just continued doing his excellent composing business或work by heart. In short, although the forces outsides might limit or impede people, itforces?单复数指代问题 cannot determine the behavior of people entirely; instead,people can strive to make their choice and take actions as they choice.都对,davidjacky看得好细致,感动!我的语言要达到这一水平还得努力!
What is more, people can also change the forces compelling them to work for their behaviors. Although the forces inside?这是什么呵呵,是不合适,但写时想不到更合适的,就是内力外力 or outside seems powerful and changeable, such as the confine of disability, poverty, the oppression non-democratic circumstance, people can change it in many cases. For example, Washington, who did not believe that forces from British cannot be altered and finally lead people to establish their own country; and now, the opposing from British cannot impede any Americans for ever. Another telling example is the contribution of Doctor Jiang Yanyong in SARS crisis in China, who is a retired doctor in 301 People’s liberation Army in Beijing. While many politicians, doctors and nurses tell lies to public about scale of SARS problem, he disclosed the fact to public by writing to a international media bravely, and his behavior impelled the Chinese government to expose the fact and sacked the health minister and major of Beijing. It seems impossible that a doctor cannot be in accord with his or her superior and government, or cannot change the whole covered things. However, Doctor Jiang did and changed it to some extent Therefore, every doctor and nurse can freely say about the disease now, and government also learn a useful lesson about impeding saying truth. In short, people can change the forces restraining them in some cases to behavior more freely.sars的例子写的比较生动,但是不太贴切,总感觉他说出真相和外界压力没有紧密联系上,人们改变外界压力的话,我想可以才革命、新学说之类的入手,好吧是,再想一个
In sum, society is necessary to hold individuals accountable for their own behavior, and people can determine their action largely, although force might influence or impede them. The conception of “individual responsibility" is necessary and not a fiction.又是照抄,以后要注意,这篇文章集中的问题是开头结尾,好好努力
开头结尾改善中,是我弱项中的弱项……
非常感谢davidjacky! 你说的基本都对!接受修改中!呵呵!
这两天状态不好,学不进去,两天没写了,可能还是畏难情绪吧,抖抖精神,加油:) |
|