申请加精：世界商学院研究能力排名（BUZ PHD申请的重要参考）

applejerryUID：180429

大家在准备申请商学院PHD的时候都遇到过选校的问题，可是由于商学院的特殊性质，很多机构办的商学院排名都是针对MBA学生而言的，比如著名的USNEWS,BUSINESS WEEK和FINANCIAL TIMES。

和MBA学习不同，PHD的学习主要是为学术研究做准备的，所以针对MBA的商学院排名对与PHD申请者其实参考价值并不是很大。
9 M8 g& S7 Z' _5 ~) T
4 {, _& t2 m, t* Q最近看到UT-DALLAS对世界研究性商学院做了个排名，个人觉得蛮有参考价值的，和大家分享一下。网址：http://citm.utdallas.edu/utdrankings/RankingWorldwide.aspx
8 V; U7 D7 {5 a: S
他们的RANK METHODOLOGY是：We provide a tool to study research contributions based on publications in 22 leading journals in major business disciplines.  The database contains author and affiliation information on all papers published in these journals since 1990.  Affiliations of the author are recorded at the time of the paper publication.
$ F% @: z# d) g
A single authored paper results in the school of affiliation being credited with a score of 1.  If there are multiple authors the school gets a score of 1/n for each of their faculty members, where n is the number of authors.  The database can be searched for any period between 1990 to the current year, for any combination of journals resulting in aggregated scores for schools (SEARCH BY JOURNAL).  This provides a clear picture of contributions from each school for the selected journals and time period.  One can also search the database by school names, author names and key phrase in the title (SEARCH BY SCHOOL NAME, AUTHOR NAME, ARTICLE NAME, respectively)

We also provide a ranking of top one hundred schools in North America and World wide based on publications in all 22 journals for a five year time period between 2000-2005.

1 r/ k5 V" }( x! s[ 本帖最后由 applejerry 于 2006-1-9 05:06 编辑 ]

applejerryUID：180429

参考的JOURNAL总共22个，都是各商学研究的TOP A JOURNAL, 比如会计类著名的Accounting review, JAE, JAR,

; Y7 t  \, O) d1 t  g以下是具体TOP 100的排名：
$ A: h5 {+ x& I2 D5 V: W5 P+ V
The UTD top 100 World Wide Rankings of Business Schools based on Research Contribution 2000-2004 (All Journals).

( D, f, y* h, |0 dRank University Name Number of Articles Score Country
1 University of Pennsylvania (The Wharton School) 292 176.82 USA
2 Harvard University (Harvard Business School) 164 106.46 USA
3 New York University (Leonard N. Stern School of Business) 180 100.52 USA
( P; [$ c# x  }: Y4 Massachusetts Institute of Technology (Sloan School of Management) 154 94.10 USA
& U' o% c! ^/ p2 L( Y# `5 Columbia University (Columbia Graduate School of Business) 161 91.93 USA
6 University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA Anderson School of Management) 143 89.17 USA
* t1 O# `0 I! k) S  c7 Stanford University (Graduate School of Business) 141 82.73 USA
) \- L* E; ]* R1 V* ~' C8 University of Chicago (Graduate School of Business) 130 81.25 USA
9 Northwestern University (Kellogg School of Management) 134 80.70 USA
10 University of Michigan at Ann Arbor (Ross School of Business) 141 80.33 USA
9 `. B' ]1 `6 o- T* }" K11 University of Texas at Austin (Red McCombs School of Business) 140 75.03 USA
  b8 Y) c: ~# S9 l4 I6 E4 A" Q12 University of Maryland at College Park (Robert H. Smith School of Business) 117 66.90 USA
, x; ], k# W3 z. E13 Duke University (The Fuqua School of Business) 130 66.00 USA
, b7 z% t: z" f9 `2 M14 University of Southern California (Marshall School of Business) 108 62.30 USA
15 INSEAD ( ) 105 60.17 France
& a0 `) m3 T7 p# M" k: \( \: Q16 University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (Kenan-Flagler Business School) 107 54.53 USA
; S# j5 x- T0 U" w( }. v17 Emory University (Goizueta Business School) 83 50.52 USA
18 Pennsylvania State University at University Park (Smeal College of Business) 95 48.23 USA
: o: D0 M7 W* F/ D7 F19 University of Washington at Seattle (Business School) 85 47.00 USA
20 University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (College of Business) 82 45.58 USA
21 Ohio State University (Fisher College of Business) 79 44.70 USA
8 d2 ]7 K/ j2 t) n( @/ r22 Carnegie Mellon University (Tepper School of Business) 83 43.12 USA
23 Washington University at St. Louis (Olin School of Business) 71 42.62 USA
: W5 z# x' r. J* o24 Hong Kong University of Science and Technology ( ) 74 42.37   
  N# k# [# \; l# D1 `25 Indiana University at Bloomington (Kelley School of Business) 84 42.17 USA
26 Purdue University (Krannert Graduate School of Management) 75 41.17 USA
27 University of Minnesota at Twin Cities (Minneapolis) (Carlson School of Management) 82 40.25 USA
' b2 F8 t. G& T* {28 University of California at Berkeley (Walter A. Haas School of Business) 71 39.50 USA
9 K% L; o6 [" Z. F" W3 U29 University of Wisconsin at Madison (School of Business) 65 38.58 USA
" s# t1 y0 }2 b2 n* K& m% T30 Cornell University (Samuel Curtis Johnson Graduate School of Management) 67 38.18 USA
9 t6 l8 ~1 X3 s0 P6 N) d0 C( @31 University of Florida (Warrington College of Business) 64 36.82 USA
# f# J, e& [( c: P. Q) J; X+ Y! Q+ |32 University of California at Irvine (Paul Merage School of Business) 60 36.53 USA
33 Michigan State University (The Eli Broad College of Business) 73 35.07 USA
34 London Business School ( ) 58 34.53 United Kingdom
2 m# E: }7 b, s7 [0 h5 `35 Arizona State University (W.P. Carey School of Business) 60 30.12 USA
9 J/ w& C( W9 |. z3 S; h36 University of Rochester (William E. Simon Graduate School of Business) 47 28.45 USA
37 Dartmouth College (Tuck School of Business) 50 27.83 USA
38 Yale University (School of Management) 47 27.17 USA
39 University of Notre Dame (Mendoza College of Business) 46 27.08 USA
40 University of Texas at Dallas (School of Management) 50 26.73 USA
41 Case Western Reserve University (Weatherhead School of Management) 45 25.28 USA
7 e/ Y6 ]% K5 e2 G: N. C; D- V42 Georgia State University (J. Mack Robinson School of Business) 53 25.08 USA
43 University of Toronto (Joseph L. Rotman School of Management) 41 23.87 Canada
: L4 l, Q1 Y' Q$ h: v: Y$ m7 L44 University of Utah (David Eccles School of Business) 43 23.33 USA
3 J) f% b' M& V8 y45 Texas A&M University at College Station (Mays Business School) 47 23.05 USA
( ?+ H% `" Z+ `$ U! w( |46 University of Pittsburgh (The Joseph M. Katz Graduate School of Business) 47 22.89 USA
47 University of Colorado at Boulder (Leeds School of Business) 42 22.20 USA
48 University of British Columbia (Sauder School of Business) 42 22.18 Canada
49 Southern Methodist University (Edwin L. Cox School of Business) 42 22.17 USA
50 Georgetown University (The McDonough School of Business) 37 21.18 USA

applejerryUID：180429

51 University of Connecticut (School of Business) 38 21.13 USA
52 University of Arizona (Eller College of Management) 43 21.08 USA
53 University of Western Ontario (Richard Ivey School of Business) 42 20.95 Canada
54 Tilburg University ( ) 44 20.67 The Netherlands
* m% U- M6 v1 ?' G$ b55 Rice University (Jesse H. Jones Graduate School of Management) 36 20.20 USA
56 Boston College (Carroll School of Management) 41 20.17 USA
57 Rutgers University at New Brunswick & Newark (Rutgers Business School) 36 19.65 USA
5 E8 c1 n% v+ U* n58 Boston University (School of Management) 39 19.58 USA
59 University of Miami (School of Business) 33 18.98 USA
60 University of South Carolina at Columbia (Moore School of Business) 35 18.13 USA
% p, i4 _9 Q2 o" x7 J4 X9 |! Y, C61 Brigham Young University (Marriott School of Management) 33 18.08 USA
62 Tulane University (A. B. Freeman School of Business) 34 17.53 USA
63 McGill University (Faculty of Management) 27 16.42 Canada
64 University of Georgia (Terry College of Business) 34 15.75 USA
& H4 E2 h, \4 M- K2 z65 University of Iowa (Henry B. Tippie College of Business) 30 15.73 USA
" l/ A- P  v' j9 U4 q) o66 University of Cincinnati (College of Business) 34 15.17 USA
9 m8 w3 _1 z+ }* ?5 s& g3 C67 City University of New York, Baruch College (Business School) 32 15.00 USA
5 I" a* j4 ?4 ~* q: O68 Chinese University of Hong Kong ( ) 31 14.90 China
69 University of Houston (C.T. Bauer College of Business) 29 14.58 USA
% E# u0 {$ o$ b70 Vanderbilt University (Owen Graduate School of Management) 30 14.58 USA
$ U4 K. h$ {! r4 X, u( p: h, w71 University of California at Davis (Graduate School of Management) 23 14.42 USA
72 University of Alberta (School of Business) 25 14.33 Canada
73 University of Oregon (Charles H. Lundquist College of Business) 23 13.92 USA
74 Virginia Polytech Institute of Technology and State University (Pamplin College of Business) 30 13.83 USA
75 Nanyang Technological University ( ) 22 13.58 Singapore
76 University of Kentucky (Gatton College of Business and Economics) 28 13.50 USA
77 Erasmus University Rotterdam ( ) 25 13.25 The Netherlands
78 University of Kansas (College of Business) 21 13.08 USA
* a  F: H  G; N  k. \5 g$ f79 University of Oklahoma (Michael F. Price College of Business) 29 13.00 USA
80 State University of New York at Buffalo (School of Management) 24 12.92 USA
81 Florida State University (College of Business) 26 12.50 USA
7 j5 N5 |& n0 j* R9 K82 Georgia Institute of Technology (College of Management) 22 12.33 USA
8 ^( k( S$ D% _8 a* v' i: ^83 University of Virginia, McIntire (McIntire School of Commerce) 23 12.20 USA
, m! ?6 ^5 ], M" L. V84 University of Virginia, Darden (Darden Graduate School of Business Administration) 22 11.67 USA
85 City University of Hong Kong ( ) 21 11.45 China
86 Louisiana State University at Baton Rouge (E.J. Ourso College of Business Administration) 22 11.00 USA
87 Northeastern University (College of Business Administration) 18 10.83 USA
' v7 C, A4 n& A0 \( F& B5 s- j88 Hong Kong Polytechnic University () 19 10.50 China
# V* u" M  v. ]" G$ k# I$ o; ^89 University of New South Wales ( ) 18 10.45   
90 University of Delaware (Alfred Lerner College of Business and Economics) 21 10.33 USA
/ u% d5 E. q6 [8 s( Y% |91 Washington State University at Pullman (College of Business and Economics) 21 9.83 USA
92 George Washington University (School of Business) 19 9.42 USA
93 York University (Business School) 15 9.33 USA
94 Hebrew University of Jerusalem ( ) 13 9.00 Israel
95 Tel Aviv University ( ) 18 8.87 Israel
% Q4 F* x2 [3 e! a/ V* y96 Santa Clara University (Leavey School of Business) 18 8.67 USA
1 U, `( L) C# o" C3 j0 m! o97 Syracuse University (The Martin J. Whitman School of Management) 16 8.58 USA
/ R: a" Q5 C7 q0 l: V& V  I' ?1 C98 University of Calgary (Haskayne School of Business) 17 8.58 Canada
7 L' k9 B1 w$ r" Q* @99 University of California at Riverside (A. Gary Anderson Graduate School of Management) 16 8.58 USA
! P# G. V3 C7 q+ ~, ]! w100 University of Colorado at Denver (The Business School) 13 8.50 USA

applejerryUID：180429

通过分析我觉得这个排名还蛮客观反应了目前世界商学研究的趋势和情况。
$ D& H# X! B( J- m: s' A( {0 r( v1，美国商学院是当之无愧世界商学研究的老大，TOP 100里面估计90%是来自美国，可能也是因为目前基本所有TOP A 的商学期刊都是美国人办的，人家不牛也不行。
: Q6 [& i  R8 o# J( ^. A2，欧洲普遍排名不高，进入TOP 20的只有INSEAD一家，还是按美国制度来设立的。老牌教育强国如英国，德国没有学校进入TOP 100（除了按美国制度走的LBS进入TOP 50),CAM 和OX都没有的。可想而知兴起BUSINESS SCHOOL教育的美国实力多么强大。所以美国是大家申请BUSINESS SCHOOL的当然选择。
! Z; H" `) R3 a; `9 |( D& Y! {3，和MBA商学院排名不同的是，这个排名反应了各个高校商学院教授和博士生的研究能力情况，所以有很多着重MBA教育忽视RESEARCH的学校被刷了下来，如VIRGINIA。虽然其MBA排名高，但是好像教授们并不重视研究，所以如果大家打算去做RESEARCH可能要考虑下了。
4，亚洲高校总共有5所挤入 TOP 100, 除SINGAPORE的NTU外，香港占了四所，反应了香港对商学研究的重视。尤其是UST排名24。加上CUHK, CITYU, POLYU，我觉得大家可以充分考虑申请美国的同时申请香港这四所高校。HKU没有入选和众所周知其BUSINESS一直不强有关。

, `  m' K; O' n8 z7 z' E[ 本帖最后由 applejerry 于 2006-1-9 05:23 编辑 ]

applejerryUID：180429

因为PHD主要是学术教育，所以我觉得大家应该更加重视学校的研究环境和导师的研究能力，多于MBA的专业教育排名。毕竟我们毕业的时候主要是去高校做研究的，研究能力的培养是很重要的。希望这个帖子对大家选校的时候有帮助。
; H$ Q6 w. L) K' J4 }6 I5 w8 C& w
  I3 U) d6 V7 K- B0 X0 e不知道斑竹可不可以帮忙把帖子也转到其他申请板块去让更多的GTER了解下。谢谢了！

[ 本帖最后由 applejerry 于 2006-1-9 05:10 编辑 ]

lakeqianUID：157560

如果大家想看学术一点的排名。。。很好办。。各大经济学杂志上有很多关于排名的研究。

ESeraphUID：2152020

不错的材料

wangseedUID：157699

research 不重要，关键是placement