- 最后登录
- 2007-1-23
- 在线时间
- 0 小时
- 寄托币
- 202
- 声望
- 0
- 注册时间
- 2006-11-2
- 阅读权限
- 15
- 帖子
- 0
- 精华
- 0
- 积分
- 174
- UID
- 2269470

- 声望
- 0
- 寄托币
- 202
- 注册时间
- 2006-11-2
- 精华
- 0
- 帖子
- 0
|
各位,到现在为止,我只收到Ammmy2000和hjacky的第一次作业提纲。
Ammmy2000
issue 36
1. Within the ability of public appreciation and comprehension, the masterpiece created by celebrities could be understood and appreciated by the public. Mark Twain's novel; A father of computer, Neumann
2. The greatness of individuals can't be decided by their contemporaries since the capacity of comprehension of science and appreciation at art couldn't reach the same level of creator's talent. Galois's Group theory, Van Gogh
3. Under the control of some politicians or religions, some ture theory couldn't be accepted by people, however, the posterities can't be controlled any more, that is why they can understand the theory.
argument 147
1.the author fails to testify the accuracy of this recent survey. In one hand, we can hardly see the number of total people,In another hand, people at different ages may have different preference.
2.if the survey is precise, there is no causal relationship between the games directed at 10 to 25 years old and the popularity of such games.
3.even if the assumptions above are correct and reasonable, the author never convinces us that people will probably buy the video games producted by Whirlwind since the factors effecting the sales are multiplicate.
Lih008
Issue36
1) On the one hand, many individuals' greatness was recognized by their contemporaries soon after they had delivered great contributions to the society.
证明这个观点主要用了李嘉诚和周恩来的例子
2) On the other hand, in the long history, there were many individuals whose greatness just could be decided by their offspring for the complex politic and social background at that time or the profundity of the masterpieces the great people brought to the society.
证明这个观点主要用了凡高、哥白尼的例子
3) Finally, from the above statement, it is not difficult to conclude that whether the greatness of individuals could be decided by the people who live after them or by their contemporaries is related to many factors.
Argument147
1) In the first place, the survey referred in this argument is not necessarily reasonable.
2) In the second place, even though the survey is sound, there is no guarantee that people will really play such games which could provide lifelike graphics.
3) Finally, this argument fails to take into account many other factors which could influence the sales of Whirlwind video games.
Issue36
OPINION: In my opinion, the greatness of individuals is objective, and unless we get the two essential factors--scientific thinking and enough message—which are required to make a true judgment, we cannot expect people at any time to decide.
1 Firstly, it is true that not all the greatness of diverse individuals can be recognized and understood by their contemporaries, not to mention be decided by them.
2 Nevertheless, does that the greatness of individuals cannot be decided by contemporaries equals thatthey can and only can be decided by the people who live after these great persons?Obviously, the answer is no.
3 In fact, in my opinion, the greatness of individuals before is somehow objective, which means no matter what people at any time think of them, their greatness cannot be changed a bit.
hjacky
Issue36
OPINION: In my opinion, the greatness of individuals is objective, and unless we get the two essential factors--scientific thinking and enough message—which are required to make a true judgment, we cannot expect people at any time to decide.
1 Firstly, it is true that not all the greatness of diverse individuals can be recognized and understood by their contemporaries, not to mention be decided by them.
2 Nevertheless, does that the greatness of individuals cannot be decided by contemporaries equals thatthey can and only can be decided by the people who live after these great persons?Obviously, the answer is no.
3 In fact, in my opinion, the greatness of individuals before is somehow objective, which means no matter what people at any time think of them, their greatness cannot be changed a bit.
主要例子:And that's why people in Athens supported the verdict of Socrates’ sentence, and despised Van Goth’s paintings during his life path, and the church which was also patronized by the contemporary people would burn the scholar Bruno who insisted on his scientific truth, which only turn had turned out to be recognized by people nearly 100 years after his death.
我个人认为:这篇文章很有思想,很有深度。一般,我们中国大陆学生(包括我在内)在写这些艺术、历史性的话题时,总是难于入手,难于表达自己的思想。可是,我自己得反复看这篇文章了。
_By SUBFENG |
|