【Persistence小组】第1次作业提纲

vinnieUID: 2104933

ISSUE 提纲
I121. At various times in the geological past, many species have become extinct as a result of natural, rather than human, processes. Thus, there is no justification for society to make extraordinary efforts, especially at a great cost in money and jobs, to save endangered species."
disagree
1 Although some species become extinct as a result of nature, there are still many species disappear because of human behavior.
2 Whatever species disappear as a result of nature or human behavior, it doesn’t mean people have no responsibility to save them.
3 Making efforts to save endangered animal at a great cost in money or jobs doesn’t make no sense. People can benefit much from it such as environment…..

I149 The most practical and effective way to protect wilderness areas is to attract more tourists to these areas through environmentally sensitive projects.
disagree
1 Too many tourists going to one area may harm the environment and the wildness animal living there, too many noise and rubbish.
2 In order to attract more tourists, the manager needs to invest money first in service establishment. It may diminish wilderness areas. And there is still a doubt that it can really attract more tourists coming and spending money.
3. Although more tourists can be there for holiday, how can manager assure that all income from tour spent in protecting wilderness areas.

I145 A crucial test of character is whether one is able to adapt to changing social conventions without sacrificing one’s principles.
Partly agree
1 although there are many things luring us nowadays, everyone should have one’s principles in the heart.
2 one’s principle should change with the society developing.
3 If one’s principle is not proper at first, there is no need to stick to it.

I242 Societies should try to save every plant and animal species, regardless of expense to human in effort, time, and financial well-being
Disagree
1 Some species disappear not because of human activity , it is the rule of natural challenge, there is no need to break it.
2 The goal to save endangered animals is to let people benefit from it. If people can’t live well as the spend too much time and money in saving animals, it does not make sense.
3 Sometimes people can do nothing to help when the specie disappear like weather changing. If that, there is no need to spend on it.

I169 Those who treat politics and morally as though they were separate realm fail to understand one or another
Agree
1 In truth, politic is strongly related to moral fiber. The men who gain great success are all have a high moral standard.
2 Only the politics that have a high moral standard, the society can be in the right direction under their leading.
3 Although sometimes politic can play some dirty tricks to obtain a short term success, but they separate them as they don’t really understand them. They must fail in the near future.

ARGUE 提纲
A42
1        The increase of number of foreign visitors may be not because of the advertising campaign to promote ecological sound tourism.
2        The reason why per capita income increase is not the development of tourism.
3        The situation in different countries is different, so the director of Bellegea may not fit here.

A25
1 同理，旅客的增加，开设新的商业这些未必是由于 Ocean view 建造了新的高尔夫或旅馆的缘故
2 税收的增加未必是由于旅游业带来的，很有可能是本国居民消费的增长。
3 每个地区的情况不同，建造新的高尔夫或旅馆需要大量的投资，在没有仔细进行调查之前不要做最后的结论

A 156
1 对高层管理人员的调查发现的问题未必新员工同样具有
2 对高层管理人员的调查是所有的人员，还是仅仅局限于几个部门，如果技术部门出现欠缺沟通能力的问题很正常
3 参加课程后销量上升与课程未必有显然的联系，销量上升也不能说明不满意的顾客数量下降，因为用的人多了，数量反而上升。

A 239
1 宵禁期间青少年犯罪下降并不代表整体犯罪下降，很可能，在这段时间，成人的犯罪大大上升。
2 市镇广场没有一起犯罪被上报可能并不是因为宵禁，因为白天也可能发生犯罪，可能是有隐瞒
3 要防止青少年犯罪宵禁是不够的，现在犯罪成多元化，所以宵禁可能完全没有作用。
，
A 67
1 垃圾部门的投诉很少可能是行业性质决定的，也有可能是因为合并，居民觉得麻烦，并不代表服务质量下降。
2 图书馆的人数减少的原因不一定是服务质量变差了，人们有更好的娱乐的方式或是人数减少了
3 合并两个图书馆不能真正的解决问题，关掉P的图书馆同意使用C的可能使P的居民去图书馆要花费更多的时间，去图书馆的人数会进一步下降

Andy85UID: 2250503

ISSUE 提纲
I121. At various times in the geological past, many species have become extinct as a result of natural, rather than human, processes. Thus, there is no justification for society to make extraordinary efforts, especially at a great cost in money and jobs, to save endangered species."
disagree
1 Although some species become extinct as a result of nature, there are still many species disappear because of human behavior.
2 Whatever species disappear as a result of nature or human behavior, it doesn’t mean people have no responsibility to save them. (Why do people have the responsibility to save them？)
3 Making efforts to save endangered animal at a great cost in money or jobs doesn’t make no sense. People can benefit much from it such as environment…..

I149 The most practical and effective way to protect wilderness areas is to attract more tourists to these areas through environmentally sensitive projects.
disagree
1 Too many tourists going to one area may harm the environment and the wildness animal living there, too many noise and rubbish.
2 In order to attract more tourists, the manager needs to invest money first in service establishment. It may diminish wilderness areas. And there is still a doubt whether it can really attract more tourists coming and spending money.
3. Although more tourists can be there for holiday, how can manager assure that all income from tour spent in protecting wilderness areas. (这是Issue，不是Argument，怎么觉得你写的提纲像是在找错？)
（environmentally sensitive projects 这个词组我就没搞明白什么意思,按你的说法，开放旅游业然后将收入都用来支持环保的项目，好像有点道理，下次大家讨论下）

I145 A crucial test of character is whether one is able to adapt to changing social conventions without sacrificing one’s principles.
Partly agree
1 although there are many things luring us nowadays, everyone should have one’s principles in the heart.
2 one’s principle should change with the society developing.
3 If one’s principle is not proper at first, there is no need to stick to it.
（你真的是Partly agree，而不是agree？还有你好像没看明白题目啊）

I242 Societies should try to save every plant and animal species, regardless of expense to human in effort, time, and financial well-being
Disagree
1 Some species disappear not because of human activity , it is the rule of natural challenge, there is no need to break it.
2 The goal to save endangered animals is to let people benefit from it. If people can’t live well as they spend too much time and money in saving animals, it does not make sense.
3 Sometimes people can do nothing to help when the specie disappear like weather changing. If so, there is no need to spend on it.

I169 Those who treat politics and moral as though they were separate realm fail to understand one or another
Agree
1 In truth, politic is strongly related to moral fiber. The men who gain great success are all have a high moral standard.(太绝对了,好像还跑题了)
2 Only the politics that have a high moral standard (有道德的是politician，而不是politics), the society can be in the right direction under their leading.
3 Although sometimes politic can play some dirty tricks to obtain a short term success, but they [separate them as they don’t really understand them] (这句看不明白啊). They must fail in the near future.

ARGUE 提纲
A42
1        The increase of number of foreign visitors may be not because of the advertising campaign to promote ecological sound tourism.
2        The reason why per capita income increase is not the development of tourism.
3        The situation in different countries is different, so the director of Bellegea may not fit here.

A25
1 同理，旅客的增加，开设新的商业这些未必是由于 Ocean view 建造了新的高尔夫或旅馆的缘故
2 税收的增加未必是由于旅游业带来的，很有可能是本国居民消费的增长。
3 每个地区的情况不同，建造新的高尔夫或旅馆需要大量的投资，在没有仔细进行调查之前不要做最后的结论

A 156
1 对高层管理人员的调查发现的问题未必新员工同样具有
2 对高层管理人员的调查是所有的人员，还是仅仅局限于几个部门，如果技术部门出现欠缺沟通能力的问题很正常 （好！）
3 参加课程后销量上升与课程未必有显然的联系，销量上升也不能说明不满意的顾客数量下降，因为用的人多了，数量反而上升。(这条没有道理，文中讲明了销量上升，不满意顾客也减少了，题目没看清)

A 239
1 宵禁期间青少年犯罪下降并不代表整体犯罪下降，很可能，在这段时间，成人的犯罪大大上升。
2 市镇广场没有一起犯罪被上报可能并不是因为宵禁，因为白天也可能发生犯罪（白天犯罪就不上报了？），可能是有隐瞒
3 要防止青少年犯罪宵禁是不够的，现在犯罪成多元化，所以宵禁可能完全没有作用。
，
A 67
1 垃圾部门的投诉很少可能是行业性质决定的，也有可能是因为合并，居民觉得麻烦，并不代表服务质量下降。(看不懂)
2 图书馆的人数减少的原因不一定是服务质量变差了，人们有更好的娱乐的方式或是人数减少了 （文中并没有提到去图书馆人数减少是服务质量变差）
3 合并两个图书馆不能真正的解决问题，关掉P的图书馆同意使用C的可能使P的居民去图书馆要花费更多的时间，去图书馆的人数会进一步下降    （合并图书馆的目的是降低费用的同时，不引起人们的投诉，也就是不降低服务质量）