issue144 考前一周，跪求好心人帮我指点一下，我需要清楚认识自己现在的实力，谢谢！

hrjacoUID: 2660106

TOPIC: ISSUE144 - "It is the artist, not the critic,* who gives society something of lasting value."

*a person who evaluates works of art, such as novels, films, music, paintings, etc.
WORDS: 577
TIME: 00:45:00
DATE: 2009/8/5 22:11:37

When it comes to the value of art, such questions arises: Whether it is the artist or the critic gives society something of lasting value? People, including the speaker, believe it is the former's contribution. However, in my point of view, which I concede the invaluable value artists create to our society, critic also plays a key role in conveying the explicit ideas of the works to the public as well as polishing the works.

Admittedly, artist is the prerequisite of the value of art. It is the artist not the critic that creates the work of art. The ideas, the themes and the objectives all sprang from the sophisticated minds of artists. Without artists, we would never have the opportunities to enjoy the pleasure in tasting the nectar of these masterpieces. Without Monet, for instance, we would not see the fantastic impressionistic work of Sunrise. Without Beethoven, we would not hear the attractive melody of Chorus. In short, artists are the origin of the values of art, without whom value comes no way from.

While we should place emphasis on the status artists should obtain, critics also play an indelible role in giving society lasting value.

On one hand, it is the critics that convey the otherwise hidden ideas from the exquisite works to audience. From common sense and personal experiences, we can find it common that some values of work of art cannot be comprehended by ordinary people. Artists are such people whose minds are sometimes realistic, sometimes idealistic, sometimes abstract, sometimes concrete and even sometimes impressionistic, which make the average populace hard to capture. Then the role of critics becomes indispensible. They help artists convey their otherwise hidden ideas, and help audience better taste the explicit or covert parts. History is replete of works with lasting values but cannot be directly enjoyed by the public. Consider the Sun Flower, the masterpiece form Van Gogh, which is enjoyed by most of people who have ever seen it. However, when asked about the reason of their enjoyment. Nearly the majority of them would just respond because it is beautiful. At this time, critics become the necessity. Only by their enlightening and instilling, can the audience figure out the implicit element of hope from the masterwork. Similarly, without the help of critics, many people would take 'Destiny' as a symphony of depression, while not figure out the understanding of life and death contained in it. In a word, critics shoulder the responsibility to convey the value of works to the public, without whom even masterpieces would amount to an ordinary works.

On the other hand, it is also the critics that help artists polish that work of art. An apt illustration of this point involves Chopin, the eminent and patriotic musician. He had a best friend who worked as a critic and especially had his personal view in the realm of music. Every time Chopin created a new song or symphony, he would ask his best friend to head and make some suggestion. Although the inspirations and ideas always came from Chopin's imagination and patriotism, his friend usually made some advisable proposal to him to make the songs more inspiring and impressing. And this was the exact way in that Chopin created so many impressive works of art. Accordingly, when we owe the lasting value of art to the artists, we should never overlook the important role critics play in.

In summary, artists create works of art, while critics convey their value to the public and help ameliorate them. Thus, it is the marriage between artists and critics that give our society the lasting value.

melodyfeatherUID: 2676881

总体评价：楼主您太强了。以我的实力看不出什么大问题来，基本上就是怀着崇敬的心情拜读大作，所提的意见还不如请教的问题多……汗……

我也马上要考了，所以就以如果是自己就会怎么写来看文章的，不具有代表性


TOPIC: ISSUE144 - "It is the artist, not the critic,* who gives society something of lasting value."
*a person who evaluates works of art, such as novels, films, music, paintings, etc.
WORDS: 577
TIME: 00:45:00
DATE: 2009/8/5 22:11:37
When it comes to the value of art, such questions arises: Whether it is the artist or the critic gives society something of lasting value? People, including the speaker, believe it is the former's contribution. However, in my point of view, which I concede the invaluable（immense也可以吧？） value artists create to our society, critic also plays a key role in conveying the explicit（我怎么觉得是implicit?） ideas of the works to the public as well as polishing the works（我对这个词的用法不熟，楼主能赐教么？谢……）.
Admittedly, artist is the prerequisite of the value of art.（这个……好像直接用art就可以了吧，艺术家是艺术价值的前提……） It is the artist not the critic that creates the work of art. The ideas, the themes and the objectives（用在这里是什么意思楼主恩那个说一下么？） all sprang from the sophisticated minds of artists. Without artists, we would never have the opportunities to enjoy the pleasure in tasting the nectar of these masterpieces. Without Monet, for instance, we would not see the fantastic impressionistic work of Sunrise. Without Beethoven, we would not hear the attractive melody of Chorus. In short, artists are the origin of the values of art，without whom value comes no way from.（可以解释下no way from 的用法么，比如举个有权威性的例子）
While we should place emphasis on the status artists should obtain, critics also play an indelible role in giving society lasting value.
On one hand, it is the critics that convey the otherwise hidden ideas from the exquisite works to audience. From common sense and personal experiences, we can find it common that some values of work of art cannot be comprehended by ordinary people(是有些价值不能被理解么？我觉得用realized 会不会更好). Artists are such people whose minds are sometimes realistic, sometimes idealistic, sometimes abstract, sometimes concrete and even sometimes impressionistic, which make the average populace hard to capture. Then the role of critics becomes indispensible. They help artists convey their otherwise hidden ideas, and help audience better taste the explicit or covert parts. History is replete of（with） works with(of) lasting values but cannot be directly enjoyed by the public. Consider the Sun Flower, the masterpiece form Van Gogh, which is enjoyed by most of people who have ever seen it. However, when asked about the reason of their enjoyment, nearly the majority of them would just respond because it is beautiful. At this time, critics become the necessity. Only by their enlightening and instilling, can the audience figure out the implicit element of hope from the masterwork. Similarly, without the help of critics, many people would take 'Destiny' as a symphony of depression, while not figure out the understanding of life and death contained in it. In a word, critics shoulder the responsibility to convey the value of works to the public, without whom even masterpieces would amount to an ordinary works.
On the other hand, it is also the critics that help artists polish that work of art. An apt illustration of this point involves Chopin, the eminent and patriotic musician. He had a best friend who worked as a critic and especially had his personal view in the realm of music. Every time Chopin created a new song or symphony, he would ask his best friend to head and make some suggestion. Although the inspirations and ideas always came from Chopin's imagination and patriotism, his friend usually made some advisable proposal to him to make the songs more inspiring and impressing. And this was the exact way in that Chopin created so many impressive works of art. Accordingly, when we owe the lasting value of art to the artists, we should never overlook the important role critics play in.
In summary, artists create works of art, while critics convey their value to the public and help ameliorate them. Thus, it is the marriage (希望楼主关于这个词的这种用法给出一些解释)between artists and critics that give our society the lasting value.
希望楼主能给我的文章一点意见：144：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992022&page=1#pid1773039980

如果有空也有兴趣，也可以看一下别的文章，我4天后就得考了，也就是13号
43：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992004&page=1#pid1773039937
48：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992008&page=1#pid1773039946
50：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992012&page=1#pid1773039955
69：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992014&page=1#pid1773039961
88：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992018&page=1#pid1773039969
103：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992020&page=1#pid1773039973
130：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992021&page=1#pid1773039977
144：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992022&page=1#pid1773039980
153：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992023&page=1#pid1773039983
208：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992027&page=1#pid1773039990
17：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992545&page=1#pid1773044578
56：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992548&page=1#pid1773044583
212：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992943&page=1#pid1773047423
40：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=992944&page=1#pid1773047429
221：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=993408&page=1#pid1773050747
11：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=993409&page=1#pid1773050753
120：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=993411&page=1#pid1773050757
184：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=993763&page=1#pid1773053509
147：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=993765&page=1#pid1773053514
131：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=993766&page=1#pid1773053517
70：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=994119&page=1#pid1773055900
51：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=994121&page=1#pid1773055909
36：https://bbs.gter.net/viewthread.php?tid=994120&page=1#pid1773055907
1# hrjaco

melodyfeatherUID: 2676881

汗……word的效果都没了

When it comes to the value of art, such questions arises: Whether it is the artist or the critic gives society something of lasting value? People, including the speaker, believe it is the former's contribution. However, in my point of view, which I concede the invaluable（immense也可以吧？） value artists create to our society, critic also plays a key role in conveying the explicit（我怎么觉得是implicit?） ideas of the works to the public as well as polishing the works（我对这个词的用法不熟，楼主能赐教么？谢……）.

Admittedly, artist is the prerequisite of the value of art.（这个……好像直接用art就可以了吧，艺术家是艺术价值的前提……） It is the artist not the critic that creates the work of art. The ideas, the themes and the objectives（用在这里是什么意思楼主恩那个说一下么？） all sprang from the sophisticated minds of artists. Without artists, we would never have the opportunities to enjoy the pleasure in tasting the nectar of these masterpieces. Without Monet, for instance, we would not see the fantastic impressionistic work of Sunrise. Without Beethoven, we would not hear the attractive melody of Chorus. In short, artists are the origin of the values of art，without whom value comes no way from.（可以解释下no way from 的用法么，比如举个有权威性的例子）

While we should place emphasis on the status artists should obtain, critics also play an indelible role in giving society lasting value.

On one hand, it is the critics that convey the otherwise hidden ideas from the exquisite works to audience. From common sense and personal experiences, we can find it common that some values of work of art cannot be comprehended by ordinary people(是有些价值不能被理解么？我觉得用realized 会不会更好). Artists are such people whose minds are sometimes realistic, sometimes idealistic, sometimes abstract, sometimes concrete and even sometimes impressionistic, which make the average populace hard to capture. Then the role of critics becomes indispensible. They help artists convey their otherwise hidden ideas, and help audience better taste the explicit or covert parts. History is replete of（with） works with(of) lasting values but cannot be directly enjoyed by the public. Consider the Sun Flower, the masterpiece form Van Gogh, which is enjoyed by most of people who have ever seen it. However, when asked about the reason of their enjoyment, nearly the majority of them would just respond because it is beautiful. At this time, critics become the necessity. Only by their enlightening and instilling, can the audience figure out the implicit element of hope from the masterwork. Similarly, without the help of critics, many people would take 'Destiny' as a symphony of depression, while not figure out the understanding of life and death contained in it. In a word, critics shoulder the responsibility to convey the value of works to the public, without whom even masterpieces would amount to an ordinary works.

On the other hand, it is also the critics that help artists polish that work of art. An apt illustration of this point involves Chopin, the eminent and patriotic musician. He had a best friend who worked as a critic and especially had his personal view in the realm of music. Every time Chopin created a new song or symphony, he would ask his best friend to head and make some suggestion. Although the inspirations and ideas always came from Chopin's imagination and patriotism, his friend usually made some advisable proposal to him to make the songs more inspiring and impressing. And this was the exact way in that Chopin created so many impressive works of art. Accordingly, when we owe the lasting value of art to the artists, we should never overlook the important role critics play in.

In summary, artists create works of art, while critics convey their value to the public and help ameliorate them. Thus, it is the marriage (希望楼主关于这个词的这种用法给出一些解释)between artists and critics that give our society the lasting value.