寄托家园留学论坛 › 论坛 › 寄托学术类备考版 › GRE作文互动版 › Argument177【0706G－MYTH-II小组】第9次作业 by pengya ...

查看: 778|回复: 0

上一主题

下一主题

[a习作temp] Argument177【0706G－MYTH-II小组】第9次作业 by pengyanj [复制链接]

pengyanj
UID：2169490

Rank: 2

声望: 0
寄托币: 309
注册时间: 2005-12-21
精华: 0
帖子: 0

电梯直达

跳转到指定楼层

楼主

发表于 2007-3-27 00:36:21 |只看该作者 |倒序浏览

In this argument, the author concludes that membership in Oak City's Civic Club(CC) should continue to be restricted to people who live in Oak City(OC). To justify his conclusion, the author reasons that people who work in OC but live elsewhere cannot truly understand the business and politics of the city. Additionally, the author assumes that such restriction is not likely to disappoint many of the nonresidents employed in OC by citing the neighboring Elm City’s (EC) CC .However; I found his analysis ungrounded in several aspects.

In the first place, the author unfairly assumes that only those who live in OC and pay city taxes can fully understand how the money could best be used. However, there is no causal relationship between living location and understanding about conditions of the city. Those who live outside the city probably work for companies or government in OC. Thus, they might better understand the business and politics of this city. Moreover, considering that other cities might develop fast, the nonresidents’ experience is valuable for OC to borrow. They could bring along their own cities' experience, which is a paramount supplement and reference for recommendation of OC's development. Furthermore, if the residents living in the city have a inferior educational level, they are not likely to come up with judicious proposals. Hence, such restriction might turn out to be unreasonable and shortsighted.

In the second place, the author's assumption that such restriction will not disappoint many of the nonresidents is open to doubt, since the situation of neighboring city does not necessarily applicable to OC. To begin with, the author provides no information about the population of nonresidents in two cities. Probably EC is much smaller than OC, and the number of nonresidents is much smaller than OC. In that case, to ignore a considerable number of nonresidents would not be advisable. Moreover, it also might be the case that the nonresidents in EC less concerned about the EC's development, while the nonresidents in OC show more enthusiasm to get participated in public affairs. Still, it is also likely to be that the CC in EC does not weigh much in public. And government seldom adapts their proposals or recommendations. So the nonresidents lose interest to get into it. Thus, the conditions of two cities might differ greatly, the OC cannot safely borrow the experience of EC.

To sum up, this argument is not well reasoned as it stands. Further investigation and meticulous consideration should be taken before hastily restricting membership of nonresidents.

回应
0

使用道具举报

问答

Offer

投票

面经

【问答】推荐信只需要老师签字就可以吗？

根据院校要求

港中文phd申请很慌

其实不用太担心，你能做的也都做了，接下来好好查邮件，尤其是垃圾信箱，太着急就打电话问问

【问答】新加坡那边GRE是不是必须选项？

是的。像NUS要求必须提供GRE成绩作为申请材料，且总分不低于320，写作不低于3.5。

【问答】想请问一下威斯康星麦迪逊MSFE有去的价值吗？

STEM，21fall新开的项目，官方就业数据还没有。适合读博跳板的多问问吧，有选择了可以来说一下波

日内瓦大学

ChemicalBiology

MSc | 24Fall | Offer

丹麦技术大学

MSc | 24Fall | 被拒

MSc | 24Fall | Offer

巴塞尔大学

生物医学工程

MSc | 24Fall | Offer

新加坡一年硕可以当读博跳板吗

布里斯托和利兹

985计算机本跨申商科硕士，均分83.7，4年工作经验，只申请了英国，QS前50的目前只有KCL没通知了，估计也没信，爱丁堡、曼大、UCL都拒了，目前只有利兹和布里斯托的offer，麻烦大家给给建议！谢谢！

美国政治学master项目选择

Pros： 1. UChicago：认可度高，给奖 2. Columbia：认可度高，有和我方向接近的老师 3. UCSD：有和我方向接近的老师，给奖 Cons： 1. UChicago：担心师生比 2. Columbia：担心学费贵 3. UCSD：认可度不如前两位小弟对计算社科、政治传播、中国政治感兴趣，希望毕业后能申请美国的政治学博士项目，谢谢大家的投票

是否应该让APS审核验证我未完成的求学经历？

APS审核告诉我说可以自行选择是否认证博士阶段的求学经历，但是由于是不会再完成的学位，所以之后无法再补审。我是否应该选择认证？（博士阶段绩点比较高；但是我验毕了一年后才选择退学）

The Hong Kong Polytechnic University

1.自我介绍2.你认为作为一个communicator需要有哪些特点？3.怎么知道这个项目的4.怎么看待ai...

The University of Hong Kong

25fall hkumed phd informal meeting实验室ap和research officer一起问的1.自我介绍，ap介绍了一下实验室2....

Lingnan University

1.自我介绍2.你的专业背景和工作经历可以怎么帮助你学习这个项目3.职业规划4.工作中遇到的困难，你是如何应...

The University of Hong Kong

1.why港大 2.why MIPA3.时政类问题

最新

精华

新加坡国立大学南亚地缘政治学授课型硕士

女留學新人

2023级课程小结（一）丨医疗卫生管理与市场营销的奇妙碰撞

2023级课程小结（二）丨欧洲课堂初体验，多维度探索运营管理

当我有一个金融行业的老妈，留学买买买

新加坡国立大学Faculty of Science2025spring入学硕士项目

最近tracker好像无法注册了

申请25Fall人类学 CUHK/ 美国澳洲其他院校

新加坡国立大学王牌专业介绍（2）

新加坡国立大学Business School 2025spring硕士项目

西北大学推出通识文科硕士MALS

澳洲申请费涨价了

超低GPA想有个书读

新加坡国立大学王牌专业介绍（1）

迪肯大学语言中心英语课程更新

【寄托私房话】热点讨论：港硕生就读时如何提高自己的就业竞争力？

学签timeline及相关信息分享

【申请心得】我的政治学、传播学、计算社会科学美国硕士项目申请心得

港澳居住证+社保医保地税+银行卡改用回乡证登记

父母香港探亲签注一年多次+中国驾驶证改回乡证登记+中国移动号码改回乡证登记

瑞典硕士DIY申请攻略——申请指南（完全版）

网上核实永居+walkin申请特区护照+walkin注销户口(广州)+申请回乡证

加硕coop指北

【干货】教你如何写MBA简历

毕业工签踩大雷 - unauthorized work before submitting PGWP - 附解决办法

经验分享：陆本商科跨专业申请文学录取Oxbridge

巴政Sciences Po Econ Master 体验 & Placement

伯明翰MSW面试&卡内基梅隆MSPPM录视频题目

加拿大法学院JD申请，学习+找工作经验答疑帖

加拿大主流ece/cs授课项目录取bar和质量的主观印象

工作党（RA）记录一下药学PhD申请过程

一个大龄女生的二硕学签（普签）成功过签经验——给辛苦DIY的你

转发

转发该帖子

Argument177【0706G－MYTH-II小组】第9次作业 by pengyanj

https://bbs.gter.net/thread-635913-1-1.html

复制链接

发送

报offer 祈福爆照

回顶部