转贴：《日本，听我对你说》 水均益

汉魂唐魄UID: 115649

CARPATHIA:你陈述的内容中.第4项NORTHRIVE已经作出了精确的陈述,我不赘言.如果你能应用"部分""一些"这类的词语,我对于2,6表示基本赞同.1,3与主题无关.同意前提:水均益所说的也不会是100%的正确.
第5项日本国内有很多这样的说法,但是对于5项,我只想知道你是什末观点?

KaliUID: 110664

You misunderstood my argument entirely. The crux of my argument is to evaluate the situation objectively and without personal emotions.  Most people in the political science academic discipline are realists, not idealists. As a human being, I wish for peace. As a student, I believe perptual peace is impossible.

Now, to the specific issue of China-Japan.  What am I saying? I am saying that those who dream of a Tokyo Massacre are hypocritical, those who advocate boycotting Japanese goods are naive, and those who believe in internet hearsays are....unfortunate. All three behaviors will only do harm to China and not good.

As to Ms. Hanzi, about the spelling of "Japan" in Japanese: I happen to be studying Japanese, and I can say quite responsibly that the relevant words should all be in kanji, unless the user is a literal illiterate.  Does this mean I'm accusing your teacher of misleading you? Judging from some people's behavior, I would not be at all surprised if that were the case.

So, shrugs, this is my last post on the matter. Like I said, I didn't expect to be able to change anybody's opinions, and the reaction has been quite expected (like I said, I'm a realist).

汉魂唐魄UID: 115649

我也不想在和你讨论这个问题了,因为忘记了民族差异的根本--文化,忘记了民族矛盾的根本--历史.无论如何研究东亚文化,也只能浮于浅表难取精髓.

很佩服你的客观,我也尽量客观的在谈论问题,先入为主的意识对解决问题从来是没有帮助的.

hanziUID: 105086

最初由 汉魂唐魄 发表
[B]我也不想在和你讨论这个问题了,因为忘记了民族差异的根本--文化,忘记了民族矛盾的根本--历史.无论如何研究东亚文化,也只能浮于浅表难取精髓.

[/B]

这几句话说到了点子上！
有时研究史啊，文化啊的人以为自己是最清醒的，实际上是“人在此山中”！

我转这个帖子的目的只是一种提醒，没想到引来了Ms Kali的如此大的反应，不明是什么原因，想还是不明为好。这也是我的最后一个回帖吧。因为不想在这个坛子里闻到硝烟味。如果这个帖子转的不好，我给大家道歉！真诚的道歉!

erduooUID: 111093

这个帖子挺好，让大家说出了些心里的东西，无论我们谁对谁错。。。或许，不同的文化，历史背景和对自身定位的认知，导致很多事情很难用对错来判定。
我以为没什么可道歉的  :)

northriverUID: 115502

我还是想知道KALI的那些日文签名档写的是什么。。。

hanziUID: 105086

谢谢耳朵，如果是这样偶心里就舒服多了。