TPO 8 W by li

lijr03UID: 2522963

The lecturer completely refuses the statements in the reading passage. The lecturer says that Chevalier’s memoir is reliable. She refuses the statements in the reading passage in three aspects.

First, Chevalier is rich. Chevalier had to sell something first to get money. Indeed he was quite rich. Sometimes he had to borrow some money form others and waited for his money to get back. But this does not mean that he is poor.

Second, the conversations of Chevalier and Voltaire are accurately. This is because Chevalier wrote down everything he remembered immediately after he talked with Voltaire in the hotel. So the conversations are accurately.

Third, she says that it is hard to bribe the jailers to free Chevalier. Other prisoners had even more powerful friends than Chevalier. But they could not bribe the jailers to be free. So Chevalier had to escape from prison. There is another evidence is that the prison that Chevalier was in is repaired.

梦灵草UID: 2600629

The lecturer completely refuses(refutes比较合适) the statements in the reading passage. The lecturer says that Chevalier’s memoir is reliable. She refuses(同上) the statements in the reading passage in three aspects.

First, Chevalier is rich. Chevalier had to sell something first to get money. Indeed he was quite rich. Sometimes he had to borrow some money form others and waited for his money to get back. But this does not mean that he is poor.

Second, the conversations of Chevalier and Voltaire are accurately. This is because Chevalier wrote down everything he remembered immediately after he talked with Voltaire in the hotel. So the conversations are accurately.

Third, she says that it is hard to bribe the jailers to free Chevalier. Other prisoners had even more powerful friends than Chevalier. But they could not bribe the jailers to be free. So Chevalier had to escape from prison. There is another evidence is that the prison that Chevalier was in is repaired.

我觉得总体的结构很好,细节也基本都说到了,但是没有与阅读内的对比,在主段落中几乎没有说到阅读.

lijr03UID: 2522963

谢谢