关于ARGUMENT的忠告:读题需注意:In reading the argument, you should pay special attention to
•
what is offered as evidence, support, or proof
哪些被作为证据、支持或者证明?
•
what is explicitly stated, claimed, or concluded
哪些被清晰地陈述、声明或者下结论?
•
what is assumed or supposed, perhaps without justification or proof
哪些假设是未被证明的或没有证据的?
• what is not stated, but necessarily follows from what is stated
哪些是没有说明的隐含假设?
In addition, you should consider the structure of the argument—the way in which these elements are linked together to form a line of reasoning;
寻找逻辑链!!
请牢记你在A写作中的任务!!!
1、You are not being asked to discuss whether the statements in the argument are true or accurate; instead, you are being asked whether conclusions and inferences are validly drawn from the statements. 不是要你去讨论这个陈述是否是正确的还是准确的,是要你去讨论这个结论和推论是否能由这个陈述中有效推出; 2、You are not being asked to agree or disagree with the position stated; instead, you are being asked to comment on the thinking that underlies the position stated. 不是要你去同意或者反对给出的观点,是要你对观点后面的论证给出评价; 3、You are not being asked to express your own views on the subject being discussed (as you were in the Issue task); instead, you are being asked to evaluate the logical soundness of an argument of another writer and, in doing so, to demonstrate the critical thinking, perceptive reading, and analytical writing skills that university faculty consider important for success in graduate school. 不是要你对讨论的对象表达自己的观点(这是ISSUE的任务),是要你对另一个作者的论证的逻辑性给出你的评价。
Reader 所关注的:
The readers' commentaries discuss specific aspects of analytical writing, such as cogency of ideas, development and support, organization, syntactic variety, and facility with language. 考生必须掌握的概念: 【you should be familiar with the directions for the Argument task and with certain key concepts, including the following:
• alternative explanation他因—a possible competing version of what might have caused the events in question; an alternative explanation undercuts or qualifies the original explanation because it too can account for说明 the observed facts
• analysis分析—the process of breaking something (e.g., an argument) down into its component parts in order to understand how they work together to make up the whole; also a presentation, usually in writing, of the results of this process(笛卡尔的理论)
• argument争论—a claim or a set of claims with reasons and evidence offered as support; a line of reasoning meant to demonstrate the truth or falsehood of something
• assumption假设—a belief, often unstated or unexamined, that someone must hold in order to maintain a particular position; something that is taken for granted but that must be true in order for the conclusion to be true提到了被当做理所当然的假设
• conclusion结论—the end point reached by a line of reasoning, valid if the reasoning is sound; the resulting assertion
• counterexample反例—an example, real or hypothetical, that refutes or disproves a statement in the argument】
you should •
carefully read the argument—you might want to read it over more than once •
identify as many of its claims, conclusions, and underlying assumptions as possible •
think of as many alternative explanations and counterexamples as you can •
think of what additional evidence might weaken or lend support to the claims •
ask yourself what changes in the argument would make the reasoning more sound
关于A中的数据、比例、统计问题!!
Remember that any numbers, percentages, or statistics in Argument topics are used only as evidence in support of a conclusion, and you should always consider whether they actually support the conclusion. 这些都是用来支持结论的,所以你要做的不是数学问题,而考虑这些是否有效地支持了结论!! 举个很好的例子: For example, an argument might claim that a certain community event is less popular this year than it was last year because only 100 people attended this year in comparison with 150 last year, a 33 percent decline in attendance. It is important to remember that you are not being asked to do a mathematical task with the numbers, percentages, or statistics. Instead you should evaluate these as evidence that is intended to support the conclusion. In the example above, the conclusion is that a community event has become less popular. You should ask yourself: does the difference between 100 people and 150 people support that conclusion? Note that, in this case, there are other possible explanations; for example, ①天气the weather might have been much worse this year,②时机this year's event might have been held at an inconvenient time, ③费用the cost of the event might have gone up this year, ④其他or there might have been another popular event this year at the same time. Each of these could explain the difference in attendance, and thus would weaken the conclusion that the event was "less popular."很佩服他举反例的能力。。。 Reader所关注的: Readers will see, for example, some essays at the 6 score level that begin by briefly summarizing the argument and then explicitly stating and developing the main points of the critique. The readers know that a writer can earn a high score by analyzing and developing several points in a critique or by identifying a central flaw in the argument and developing that critique extensively.
注意:
(remember, however, that, in terms of your ability to perform the Argument task effectively, it is your critical thinking and analytical writing, not your ability to come up with examples, that is being ssessed) 最后一点:【不论是ISSUE还是ARGUMENT】
You may want to take a few minutes to think about the issue you have chosen and to plan a response before you begin writing. Be sure to develop your ideas fully and organize them coherently, but leave time to read what you have written and make any revisions that you think are necessary |