- 最后登录
- 2013-6-18
- 在线时间
- 800 小时
- 寄托币
- 1501
- 声望
- 67
- 注册时间
- 2009-3-6
- 阅读权限
- 30
- 帖子
- 45
- 精华
- 0
- 积分
- 1105
- UID
- 2612029
 
- 声望
- 67
- 寄托币
- 1501
- 注册时间
- 2009-3-6
- 精华
- 0
- 帖子
- 45
|
本帖最后由 bzr2915 于 2010-2-19 14:58 编辑
TOPIC: ISSUE43 - "To be an effective leader, a public official must maintain the highest ethical and moral standards."
words:545;
观点:不同意;
提纲: 定义effective为有专业能力和能处理好人际关系
1:专业能力的重要性
2:处理好人际关系的重要性;
3:伦理道德的标准的争议,和监督的作用。
关于关键词的理解建议去看一下https://bbs.gter.net/thread-988726-1-1.html
A public official has significant influence on the distribution of public resources, therefore his/her decision will have important impacts on the public life. To be an effective leader, the public official should make decisions and carry out the plan that can benefit the governed. In modern society, the leaders needs more professional knowledge and capacities to make wise decisions, and more importantly, skilled personal relationship to carry out the plan. Although the ethical and moral reputation can help(help什么?), yet I think the effective leaders should have more professional capacities to perform the responsibility(这个责任指的是?). And meanwhile, the public supervision will be necessary. (这句话很唐突)
In a society where the public become more enlightened and the challenges continuously emerge, the decision made by public official is of great importance to the well-being of the citizens. An effective leader should make the right decision, and manage to perform it with the help of the subordinates. While most of us will agree that there is little causal link between this capacities and maintaining the highest moral code. The role of an effective leader of the financial regulation aptly illustrates one of my points. In the recent economical crisis, to map out effective recession-fighting plan, the financial officer need to develop a comprehensive understanding to the domestic and international market, the role of bank, consensus and the attitude of the public. But meanwhile, maintaining the highest ethical and moral code lend little help. Since what is functioning here is the principle of market and capitalism. Hence at least, in the commercial world, the highest ethical and moral code is not a necessary condition to an effective leader.
Another significant factor for an effective leader is the skill to deal with diverse inter-personal relationship. To carry out the plan efficiently and smoothly, teamwork is needed, and this is particularly true in the public office. Before making a public decision, tons of information should be gathered, each party involved should be considered and the possible consequences should be fully evaluated. All of these works can only be accomplished with comprehensive concern and synergic action by the team. To coordinate the potential ability and effort of the subordinates, a effective leader should act with inspiration and enthusiasm. Although the ethical and moral code can influence positively, knowing how to praise and punish always receive the result more efficiently.
Admittedly, the moral and ethical standards are sometimes necessary to carry out the public policy. (没看懂,伦理道德准则执行public policy?)It is, on one hand, satisfy the expectation of the stereotype, and on the other hand, become a drug with which the public leader instills the value he favors towards the public. (这是是把道德比作了毒药?)The scenario in mainland (大陆?老外看的懂这个?) serves as an vivid example. Since the standard of being moral and ethical itself is often controversial and confusing, maintaining the highest part of it is therefore as dangerous as the possible beneficial. That is why the public should rely on the supervision more than the illusion of wise and considerate kingdom.(这个结论很唐突,国家和道德伦理准范之间的关系前文并没有说明,而且此段对文章中心帮助不大) It may less efficient than the moral promise, but in most history it is more reliable. (这里的IT指的什么,看不懂)
In sum, the public official should master professional knowledge and necessary skills for the position and meanwhile, accept the obligation of being supervised. Only in this way can the leader be effective, and the decision be beneficial.(结论里没有见到ethical and moral standards 的影子?这里应该是讨论LEADER是否要MAINTAIN THE HIGHEST XXX 而不是 如何才能成为一个 EFFECTIVE LEADER)
以上仅代表个人意见 如果哪个地方拍错了 请见谅!
|
|