argument88中的前提问题

蜥蜴也飞UID: 2894889

最近本人处于逻辑混乱彷徨中。。。
argument88
到底什么是前提呢？今天想了很很很很很久。。。
TOPIC: ARGUMENT88 - The following appeared in a newsletter about health published in the country of Sauria.
"According to Sauria's leading nutritional experts, a diet high in complex carbohydrates, and low in fat is optimal for good health and longevity. Because this was the diet of the people who lived in ancient Sauria, one would expect them to have had long and healthy lives. Yet the mummified remains of Sauria's ruling classes from two to three thousand years ago show the existence of many medical problems among the ancient Saurians, including dental problems, elevated blood pressure, obesity, heart disease, and early mortality. Clearly, the diet of the ancient Saurians was responsible for these problems. The high incidence of high blood pressure, obesity, and heart disease in Sauria today even among those who have tried low-fat, high-carbohydrate diets further proves that Sauria's leading nutritional experts are wrong."
我认为前提是a diet high in complex carbohydrates, and low in fat is optimal for good health and longevity 即专家得出的结论，碳水化合物是好的
可是有人认为是and heart disease in Sauria today even among those who have tried low-fat, high-carbohydrate diets 即现在人们吃碳水化合物但是依然得病。。。


求助。。。。哪个是前提。。。
另外。。。到底什么样的东东才算前提呢？？？


谢谢了。。。

咖啡盐UID: 2973669

不必要纠结神马是前提，神马是证据。文章没有要求辨析成分.....

只要能写出合情合理的文章就好了.......

而且很多题目的前提是隐含的，并不是文中的哪句话。就像这篇文章中说的那个古人有这么多种病，那么现代人也有这么多种病，那么它的前提就是S人没有发生过变化，只有根据这个前提，文中的这部分推论才能够成立。

我觉得吧，不必钻这个牛角尖，考试这么紧张也没有这个时间，思路才是王道。如何切题，如何展开。

蜥蜴也飞UID: 2894889

2# 咖啡盐
啊哈。。。这样啊 。。。好吧。。。嘻嘻
考前综合症了。。。

咖啡盐UID: 2973669

唉~~~额滴isuue啊~~~~不想写了，曾想两篇全是argument