请教大家1个阅读问题 谢谢

hgfrytyUID: 3139065

Many critics of Emily Brontë’s novel Wuthering Heights see its second part as a counter
point that comments on, if it does not reverse, the first part, where a romantic reading
receives more confirmation. Seeing the two parts as a whole is encouraged by the
novel’s sophisticated structure, revealed in its complex use of narrators and time shifts.
Granted that the presence of these elements need not argue for an authorial awareness
of novelistic construction comparable to that of Henry James, their presence does
encourage attempts to unify the novel’s heterogeneous parts. However, any interpretation
that seeks to unify all of the novel’s diverse elements is bound to be somewhat
unconvincing. This is not because such an interpretation necessarily stiffens into a thesis
(although rigidity in any interpretation of this or of any novel is always a danger),
but because Wuthering Heights has recalcitrant elements of undeniable power that, ultimately,
resist inclusion in an all-encompassing interpretation. In this respect, Wuthering
Heights shares a feature of Hamlet.


The author of the passage would be most likely to agree that an interpretation
of a novel should
A not try to unite heterogeneous elements in the novel
B not be inflexible in its treatment of the elements in the novel
C not argue that the complex use of narrators or of time shifts indicates a
sophisticated structure
D concentrate on those recalcitrant elements of the novel that are outside
the novel’s main structure
E primarily consider those elements of novelistic construction of which the
author of the novel was aware

我觉得A和B 都对，我实在不明白A 错哪了？红色部分能说明A对啊？谢谢。

苏梳眠UID: 2717864

你的那句话和A选项有出入。
原句中是指unify all不合适，但是A选项中不去unite part~
而且A选项在文中是Henry James的观点，前面作者已经表示了need not to be comparable to Henry James 's ~

hgfrytyUID: 3139065

谢谢，我也觉得原句中是指unify all不合适，但是A选项中不去unite part是对的（赞同斑竹前1句的解释），但后面我认为A选项在文中不是Henry James的观点，而是Emily Brontë’s novel的一个特点。

w_wbyUID: 2942658

苏梳眠 发表于 2011-8-23 03:34
你的那句话和A选项有出入。
原句中是指unify all不合适，但是A选项中不去unite part~
而且A选项在文中是H ...

仍旧不大明白为什么B是对的...