有个关于过敏的问题

萝卜须根多UID: 3008387

我妈妈是过敏性皮肤，特别容易生东西，比如衣服上不能有塑料蹭着皮肤啦，比如油漆味不能多闻啦
特别是大夏天，不能出汗，积汗的地方会生很多小点点
治了很久都不见好
大概三年前，他听了一个老中医的方法，抽自己的血（3CC）然后肌肉注射回去
然后这两年就没犯病了
当然，你可以和我argue很久关于时间上的相关性是否成因果的问题
我只是奇怪，因为这个医生还是当地蛮有名望的
可是这个方法西医上解释不了啊

nynyaaaUID: 204913

that's not logical.

hua11UID: 3027785

unbelievable

H1BMatch2012UID: 2790388

That's something very very old but no medical evidence, kind of like middle age method. No morden medicine will use that method any more.
The only thing that might tell the logic there is that it could be some kind of stimulation to one self, but I can hardly believe it is safe.
Better not to do that. Personally I would say that "Doctor" is a cheater.
I have seen several "famous" and rich "Doctors" just cheating in China. Some of them use useless treatment but put some small amount of corticosteroid in the drug, which will make most kinds of disease feel better far a short term.

angelwypUID: 2803734

我不同意ls的看法。。中医就是这样的啊。。。就像经络这个东西。。西医也解释不了。。可是针灸就是有效果啊
我自己小时候有阵子只要春天夏天在北京就一直咳嗽不止。。我家里试了很多医生啊。。都没有用。。最后去看了中医。。我妈咪说那个老中医可神乐。。他问过症状搭完脉就说我一个月就会好。。然后我就吃了他一个月的药就真的好了。。而且再也没复发过。。。所以我觉得既然你妈咪过敏好了。。说明有效就好。。中医这个东西。。不懂地方多还是很正常的。。要不刮痧也不会被告虐待儿童啊

H1BMatch2012UID: 2790388

我不同意ls的看法。。中医就是这样的啊。。。就像经络这个东西。。西医也解释不了。。可是针灸就是有效果啊
我自己小时候有阵子只要春天夏天在北京就一直咳嗽不止。。我家里试了很多医生啊。。都没有用。。最后去看了中医。。我妈咪说那个老中医可神乐。。他问过症状搭完脉就说我一个月就会好。。然后我就吃了他一个月的药就真的好了。。而且再也没复发过。。。所以我觉得既然你妈咪过敏好了。。说明有效就好。。中医这个东西。。不懂地方多还是很正常的。。要不刮痧也不会被告虐待儿童啊angelwyp 发表于 2011-9-14 05:33

I never said that traditional medicine is fake. I believe it works for most times, too. I personally used some traditional medicine myself, like for my poor leg.
However, the method LZ cited is never from traditional medicine. Have you ever heard that any classic traditional medicine book said using syringe to take blood? It is impossible.
The medhod LZ said was used for a long long time in western world but not in China, actually. It worked for some case, and I have said the reason, but it is not safe for health and never used any more, which is one of the reason why western world never use it again.
Actually, this method was used a lot before 1960s in China when people were under the control of Si Ren Bang.

And the thing I said about some fake "Doctors" is truely happening, but just lots of people do not know the truth of their special drugs or treatments. Yes, most of them use traditional medicine as their way to cheat patients. That does not mean old classical traditional medicine is not good, but just these people's fault. Also, remember what I said, these fake doctors actually used strong western medicine mixed into useless traditional medicine drugs, but not really using traditional medicine.

萝卜须根多UID: 3008387

谢谢大家，这几天家里猫坏了，才上的网，没看到。。。

猛农过江UID: 2597848

chinese traditional medicine belongs to bullshit department

nynyaaaUID: 204913

我不同意ls的看法。。中医就是这样的啊。。。就像经络这个东西。。西医也解释不了。。可是针灸就是有效果啊
我自己小时候有阵子只要春天夏天在北京就一直咳嗽不止。。我家里试了很多医生啊。。都没有用。。最后去看 ...
angelwyp 发表于 2011-9-14 05:33

你们啊，Naive

nynyaaaUID: 204913

I never said that traditional medicine is fake. I believe it works for most times, too. I personally used some traditional medicine myself, like for my poor leg.
However, the method LZ cited is n ...
H1BMatch2012 发表于 2011-9-14 05:52

你太留面子了

dearmonetUID: 2616341

关键是现在国内中医很多都是假的，我是说那些打着中医的旗号行骗的人。我身边有悲惨的实例，那人和我妈妈得一样的病，我妈妈在大医院里配合医生治疗治好了，但那人偏要找什么中医，结果延误了手术最佳时间，现在已经恶化成癌症了。
至于真正的中医如何神奇，我木有见过，所以也不大相信。

sonicjamUID: 2507839

SCIENCE:PSEUDOSCIENCE
astronomy:astrology
chemistry:alchemy
modern medicine:chinese traditional medicine

不能因为中医神奇过几次 就说中医是有效的 这个归纳逻辑也太弱了

nynyaaaUID: 204913

SCIENCE:PSEUDOSCIENCE
astronomy:astrology
chemistry:alchemy
modern medicine:chinese traditional medicine

不能因为中医神奇过几次 就说中医是有效的 这个归纳逻辑也太弱了
sonicjam 发表于 2011-9-17 01:58

那个id向来没逻辑，她有逻辑就不合逻辑了

jiang08UID: 2391146

for me it is only in games.........

sonicjamUID: 2507839

呃。。我只是想说logic比较weak。。。。没别的意思。。。