36套EX16求助

瓶子要学习UID: 2999456

Innovative as it is, Luis Valdez' acto owes much to the theater traditions or other periods and regions. Like early Spanish American religious dramas, secular folk dramas,
Line and the Mexican carpas of a somewhat later period, actos are usually performed outdoors by traveling groups of players or by local theater groups. The improvised comic satire of the actos is often attributed to Valdez' study of the Italian commedia dell' arte of the sixteenth century, although some critics see it as a direct reflection of the comic and improvisational qualities of the more contemporary and local carpas of Mexican theater. The Italian influence is likely, whatever Valdez‘ immediate source: the Mexican carpas themselves are said to have originated from the theater pieces of a sixteenth-century Spanish writer inspired by encounters with Italian commedia dell'arte troupes on tour in Spain.
5. Which of the following, if true, most strengthens
the author's argument concerning the debt of the
acto to the theater traditions of other periods and
regions?
(A) Many popular forms of theater rely heavily
on improvisation.
(B) Plays resembling the acto in structure were
written in the 1970's by West African playwrights who are interested in dramatizing the richness of their own cultures.
(C) The use of masks has, at one time or another,
been characteristic of the theater traditions
of almost all cultures, even those most isolated
from outside influences.
(D) During a strike, it is common for union members
to present musical skits dramatizing the
values of solidarity and resistance.
(E) Before 1965 Luis Valdez had attended many
performances of traditional Mexican theater
groups touring the western United States.


答案选E 请问为什么啊？？这个1965年出现的也是相当的诡异啊。

watertcafeUID: 2999484

同问……我在别的帖子里问没人睬我= =

瓶子要学习UID: 2999456

2# watertcafe   好吧，让我再自己顶一下...

szmanutdUID: 2727152

定位是这段么

瓶子要学习UID: 2999456

4# szmanutd 是啊，那篇文章就只有这一段...

wdingUID: 3169423

除了这个1965 其他的内容都很符合答案 这篇阅读应该是从长文章压缩过来的 估计关于具体写作时间的内容被陈老师给漏了

瓶子要学习UID: 2999456

7# wding 排除1965其它的怎么符合问题了？？能不能解释的详细点啊？？问题里说other periods and regions ，但E只是提到什么westerne USA

瓶子要学习UID: 2999456

硬着头皮再给自己顶帖，桑心啊，大家都不回我

nbvc1UID: 2917452

这篇文章要证明的逻辑是Italian->spanish->mexico->Luis Valdez‘ acto 这点在文章的最后几句说的比较清楚（The improvised comic satire of the actos is often attributed to Valdez' study of the Italian commedia dell' arte of the sixteenth century, although some critics see it as a direct reflection of the comic and improvisational qualities of the more contemporary and local carpas of Mexican theater（这可以不看，这是作者的一个小解释）. The Italian influence is likely, whatever Valdez‘ immediate source: the Mexican carpas themselves are said to have originated from the theater pieces of a sixteenth-century Spanish writer inspired by encounters with Italian commedia dell'arte troupes on tour in Spain.）这样，佐证Luis Valdez' acto 和之前那个证明的逻辑链条中的任何一个元素（Italian，spanish，mexico）发生关系都可以被认为是对作者观点的加强。因此正确选项的关键点就应该是（Italian，spanish，mexico）->（Luis Valdez‘ acto）来看选项，A项中没有出现关键点，B项是Luis Valdez‘ acto->West African, C项没有关键点，D项也没有关键点，而E项中Luis Valdez‘ acto （attend）mexico，正好是佐证了Luis Valdez‘ acto和mexico有关系，所以选择它。
这是我的理解，希望能够帮助到你

瓶子要学习UID: 2999456

10# nbvc1 thxs!!!

晓之风UID: 3342832

谁能帮我解释下这个题目是什么意思吗？
Which of the following, if true, most strengthens   
the author's argument concerning the debt of the   
acto to the theater traditions of other periods and   
regions?
特别是那个debt看着别扭！

hot13399UID: 3598120

看了这个题我顿时无语了。只有放弃。