逻辑题求助~

keyukeUID: 3276988

Color-tinting of movies originally photographed in
black-and-white is inappropriate．Hundreds of the
original artistic choices would have been made
differently had these movies been filmed in color．
Lighting on the sets of these movies was arranged
to make highlights and shadows look right in
black-and-white．
Which of the following claims, if substituted for the
claim about the lighting of movie sets, would lend
the same type of support to the argument above？
(A) An important part of what gives these movies
their identity is the result of the black-and-
white format．
(B) Color film would have better captured the film-
makers' intentions．
(C) Color film is superior to black-and-white film
for making movies．
(D) Makeup for the actors was applied so as to look
best in black-and-white films．
(E) The choice of black-and-white film over color
film is entirely a matter of taste．

其实整道题都没怎么读懂。。。麻烦各位大侠帮帮忙讲解一下~

846136085UID: 2987171

把黑白片转换成彩色电影是不可取的，因为以前的灯光是为了在黑白片里看起来效果最好

选一个也可以提供类似证据的

alteraUID: 2724954

答案应该是D。结论是，

alteraUID: 2724954

pad不能编辑帖子。。
结论是，开始就拍黑白的电影是很不明智的，如果用彩色，选择是非常广泛的。此外彩色电影通过灯光效果也能做出黑白的样子，感觉像是向下兼容性。题目问的是，选择一个论据来代替灯光兼容性，哪个最好。所以答案选择演员化妆的兼容性。希望能帮到你

alteraUID: 2724954

2楼是正解。。我题目都理解错了。。。囧

keyukeUID: 3276988

2# 846136085

谢谢。

keyukeUID: 3276988

5# altera

谢谢。