36套EX20阅读求助~~~~短文章啊,不长的~~~

w_wbyUID: 2942658

Discussion of the assimilation of Puerto Ricans in the United States has focused on two different factors: social standing and the loss of national culture, depending on whether the commentator is North American or Puerto Rican. Many North American social scientists consider Puerto Ricans as the most recent in a long line of ethnic entrants to occupy the lowest rung on the social ladder. Such a ―socio-demographic‖ approach tends to regard assimilation as a benign process. In contrast, the ―colonialist approach of island-based writers tends to view assimilation as the forced loss of national culture in an unequal contest with imposed foreign values. There is, of course, a strong tradition of cultural accommodation among other Puerto Rican thinkers, like Eugenio Fernandez Mendez. But the Puerto Rican intellectuals who have written most about the assimilation process in the United States all advance cultural nationalist views, advocating the preservation of minority cultural distinctions and rejecting what they see as the subjugation of colonial nationalities.

7. It can be inferred from the passage that a writer such as Eugenio Fernandez Mendez would most likely agree with which of the following statements concerning members of minority ethnic groups?

(A)It is necessary for the members of such groups to adapt to the culture of the majority.
(B)The members of such groups generally encounter a culture that is static and undifferentiated.
(C)Social mobility is the most important feature of the experience of members of such groups.
(D)Social scientists should emphasize the cultural and political aspects of the experience of members of such groups.
(E)The assimilation of members of such groups requires the forced abandonment of their authentic national roots.

我选E啊,答案是A诶...求解~~

samanthalycUID: 2968067

我认为：
这是个取非题，所以答案只需把PR的观点取非（即最后一句话），perserve minority 取非就是adapt to majorty.

pigletvincentUID: 2539817

今天也做了这套。ls应该是正解，而且还有这句, a strong tradition of cultural accommodation among other Puerto Rican thinkers, like Eugenio Fernandez Mendez.

w_wbyUID: 2942658

samanthalyc 发表于 2012-7-26 23:01
我认为：
这是个取非题，所以答案只需把PR的观点取非（即最后一句话），perserve minority 取非就是adapt  ...

我是这样想的啊 确实是取非
a strong tradition of cultural accommodation among other Puerto Rican thinkers, like Eugenio Fernandez Mendez. 然后后面转折
But the Puerto Rican intellectuals who have written most about the assimilation process in the United States all advance cultural nationalist views,
advocating the preservation of minority cultural distinctions and rejecting what they see as the subjugation of colonial nationalities.
and连接了啊,PR是对于subjugation reject的,那么取非不就是E选项吗??

w_wbyUID: 2942658

pigletvincent 发表于 2012-7-26 23:13
今天也做了这套。ls应该是正解，而且还有这句, a strong tradition of cultural accommodation among other ...

同上一楼啊....

zy3854UID: 3316828

我觉得的  题干中出现的人Eugenio Fernandez Mendez  是前面的一个举例，后面紧跟着BUT，表转折，所以把but后 取非即可了

w_wbyUID: 2942658

zy3854 发表于 2012-7-27 16:38
我觉得的  题干中出现的人Eugenio Fernandez Mendez  是前面的一个举例，后面紧跟着BUT，表转折，所以把but ...

我上面是把but取非的呀...你看看我上几楼的回复.....

samanthalycUID: 2968067

w_wby 发表于 2012-7-27 09:27
我是这样想的啊 确实是取非
a strong tradition of cultural accommodation among other Puerto Rican t ...

对啊~rejecting what they see as the subjugation of colonial nationalities.
取非不就是subjugation (也就是adapt to 的同义转换呀)。

w_wbyUID: 2942658

samanthalyc 发表于 2012-7-28 09:03
对啊~rejecting what they see as the subjugation of colonial nationalities.
取非不就是subjugation  ...

subjugation是压制的意思呀
E选项The assimilation of members of such groups requires the forced abandonment of their authentic national roots.不就是这个意思吗??

samanthalycUID: 2968067

w_wby 发表于 2012-7-28 09:55
subjugation是压制的意思呀
E选项The assimilation of members of such groups requires the forced aba ...

subjugation 服从就像subdue一样咯

laoma19901990UID: 3276462

w_wby 发表于 2012-7-27 09:27
我是这样想的啊 确实是取非
a strong tradition of cultural accommodation among other Puerto Rican t ...

这题当时我是从上面推出来的，上面说的是文化被 forced loss了，而E选项说的是需要abandonment，我觉得说反了！前者是被动，后者是主动！！

laoma19901990UID: 3276462

w_wby 发表于 2012-7-27 09:27
我是这样想的啊 确实是取非
a strong tradition of cultural accommodation among other Puerto Rican t ...

从BUT后面的部分去非来推我感觉还真不好推！BUT后面的意思是要保存本民族文化的独特性，拒绝把看到的成为对于殖民文化的屈服。去非之后好像和The assimilation of members of such groups关系不大！！

个人感觉，不对之处还请提出！！

涳格simbaUID: 3374594

同楼主疑惑，还木有看到比较convincing的解释。。