36套Section 23中的一道逻辑题求讨论

希望中的玫瑰UID：2909568

Like most other coastal towns in Norway, the town of
Stavanger was quiet and peaceful until the early 1960's,
when it became Norway's center for offshore oil
exploration. Between then and now, violent crime and
vandalism in Stavanger have greatly increased.
Stavanager's social problems probably resulted from the
oil boom, since violent crime and vandalism have
remained low in coastal towns in Norway that have had
no oil boom.

Which of the following most accurately describes the
method of reasoning employed in the argument?
(A) Arguing that a circumstance is not a precondition
for a phenomenon on the grounds that the
phenomenon sometimes occurs where the
circumstance is not present
(B) Arguing that a circumstance is a cause of a
phenomenon on the grounds that the
phenomenon has not occurred where the
circumstance is not present
(C) Arguing that a particular thing cannot have
caused a phenomenon because that thing was not
present before the phenomenon occurred
(D) Attempting to establish a claim by arguing that
the denial of the claim is inconsistent with the
observed facts
(E) Attempting to establish that certain circumstances
that would have had to occur for a particular
explanation to be correct could not have occurred


我选了B，后面给出的答案是E，求解答！

天薇凉UID：3403940

你看错答案了

希望中的玫瑰UID：2909568

天薇凉 发表于 2013-4-15 16:06
你看错答案了

我觉得是36套在这道题上的答案错了

天薇凉UID：3403940

希望中的玫瑰 发表于 2013-4-15 16:14
我觉得是36套在这道题上的答案错了

36套给的就是B

天薇凉UID：3403940

希望中的玫瑰 发表于 2013-4-15 16:14
我觉得是36套在这道题上的答案错了

2012-1版答案

希望中的玫瑰UID：2909568

天薇凉 发表于 2013-4-15 16:21
2012-1版答案

可能是我下的这个版本这题答案错了。但是好在我自己的思路是对的就行。PS：想问下，你几时考呢？

天薇凉UID：3403940

希望中的玫瑰 发表于 2013-4-15 16:55
可能是我下的这个版本这题答案错了。但是好在我自己的思路是对的就行。PS：想问下，你几时考呢？

5.4

希望中的玫瑰UID：2909568

天薇凉 发表于 2013-4-15 18:30
5.4

What a coincidence! 我也是这场！ 我们可以互改作文哎~

天薇凉UID：3403940

希望中的玫瑰 发表于 2013-4-16 14:06
What a coincidence! 我也是这场！ 我们可以互改作文哎~

可以呀~
我写issue的一些跟抽象概念的题很困难呢现在。。。

北平吊客UID：3426843

我也是选B。老实讲，E的选项我看都看不懂。

希望中的玫瑰UID：2909568

天薇凉 发表于 2013-4-16 16:39
可以呀~
我写issue的一些跟抽象概念的题很困难呢现在。。。

你的Q多少，我加你！我的122711745

天薇凉UID：3403940

希望中的玫瑰 发表于 2013-4-16 19:12
你的Q多少，我加你！我的122711745

我加了你了。你验证吧