阅读36套-7英法妇女沙龙对比这道题大家还有印象吗？我纠结呀。。。

sirjasonUID: 3489676

原文
In the 1750‘s, when salons were firmly established in France, some English women, who called themselves ―Bluestocking,‖ followed the example of the salonnieres (French salon hostesses) and formed their own salons. Most Bluestockings did not wish to mirror the salonnieres; they simply desired to adapt a proven formula to their own purpose—the elevation of women‘s status through moral and intellectual training. Differences in social orientation and background can account perhaps for differences in the nature of French and English salons. The French salon incorporated aristocratic attitudes that exalted courtly pleasure and emphasized artistic accomplishments. The English Bluestockings, originating from a more modest background, emphasized learning and work over pleasure. Accustomed to the regimented life of court circles, salonnieres tended toward formality in their salons. The English women, though somewhat puritanical, were more casual in their approach.

问题3. According to the passage, a significant distinction between the salonnieres and Bluestockings was in the way each group regarded which of the following?
(A) The value of acquiring knowledge
(B) The role of pleasure in the activities of the literary salon
(C) The desirability of a complete break with societal traditions
(D) The inclusion of women of different backgrounds in the salons
(E) The attainment of full social and political equality with men
正确答案是B，楼主可以理解 pleasure，可是原文没说literary啊，为什么可以选？这不应该属于无中生有的错误么。。。还有D，答案解析说，两个沙龙背景不同，不是招募的女人背景不同。这在我看来分明就是一个意思嘛，不同背景的沙龙肯定招不同背景的女人嘛。我觉得相比B，D更正确啊？求大神解答~~

噢GOGOUID: 3481439

Differences in social orientation and background can account perhaps for differences in the nature of French and English salons.  这个说的是英国和法国的salon的人的背景不一样

(D) The inclusion of women of different backgrounds in the salons  这个说的是在salon中的女人有不一样的背景  和原文说的不是一个概念

crazyrobinUID: 2368627

D是错在他并没有谈两个salon是否包括不同背景的人。
B的literary只是对salon的一个下行概念（salon里主要进行的就是literary activities)。你POE的话也知道只能选B

sirjasonUID: 3489676

crazyrobin 发表于 2014-4-23 17:12
D是错在他并没有谈两个salon是否包括不同背景的人。
B的literary只是对salon的一个下行概念（salon里主要进 ...

哇 传奇的ben！谢谢大神解答！你是我的偶像 我最近天天在拜读你的帖子。。