关于出国读PhD回国教书的一些读博择校的讨论

红颜殁UID: 3594978

zhizihuakai 发表于 2015-2-12 21:07
TAMU的甘犁老师在西南财经，做的特别不错。我觉得TAMU的名声在国内也慢慢起来了。而且看TAMU的faculty，感 ...

同意~~~~

socialeconUID: 3594467

zhizihuakai 发表于 2015-2-12 21:07
TAMU的甘犁老师在西南财经，做的特别不错。我觉得TAMU的名声在国内也慢慢起来了。而且看TAMU的faculty，感 ...

是的，TAMU在国内的placement超级好，几乎比肩top20的，比同档次的北美的高出一大截

伪摇滚爱好者UID: 2990861

skyindeer 发表于 2015-2-12 21:39
看来鄙校真的在国内名声有限啊，卡洛斯三世的确是西班牙的国王，但校名里面木有国王的，中文全称叫马德里 ...

谢谢提醒，已修改，还有一个胡安卡洛斯国王大学，容易混淆

伪摇滚爱好者UID: 2990861

skyindeer 发表于 2015-2-12 21:39
看来鄙校真的在国内名声有限啊，卡洛斯三世的确是西班牙的国王，但校名里面木有国王的，中文全称叫马德里 ...

为什么说有限，我感觉挺出名的，全名能否叫对，感觉不影响名气

ＨＥ→赫γUID: 3382109

优柔 发表于 2015-2-12 17:37
想请教下，去业界为什么要读PHD？一直对这个问题很不明白。谢谢哈～

据层猪听国内人士反映，现在想升上去比较senior职位基本上都要MBA+ 10年以上经验 or PHD加 3年以上经验。。。。。。虽然我有MBA但是感觉找工作的时候大家都优先考虑phd。。。尤其一直心水的金融业和医疗业.....如果只是手持MBA去找工作，在医疗业根本拼不过M.D+MBA的人...然后在金融业的话。。。phd一直都是strictly dominating MBA in finance or MSF or MFE的。

cheesechanUID: 3505689

ＨＥ→赫γ 发表于 2015-2-12 23:52
据层猪听国内人士反映，现在想升上去比较senior职位基本上都要MBA+ 10年以上经验 or PHD加 3年以上经验。 ...

1. I guess this highly depends on the nature of the role..................e.g. if one go to quant, risk and etc......a PhD will be (very) useful; but one plan to go to IBD, ER and etc, PhD is indeed......sometime a con.
2. the value of the MBA is opening new doors by leveraging previous experience, and thus it is quite useless to do an MBA without some years of working experience.
3. actually I don't quite understand why "去业界为什么要读PHD" is a question..........there're tons of research in industry...

ＨＥ→赫γUID: 3382109

cheesechan 发表于 2015-2-13 00:13
1. I guess this highly depends on the nature of the role..................e.g. if one go to quan ...

赞。。。。。。很精辟。。。。。其实之前有些F500和merger paralegal经验才决定去读MBA啦（无法抗拒奖的诱惑，尤其是在MBAtuition普遍高地吓人的情况下）。。。。最后一点严重同意。。。。业界现在其实还是phd更吃香。。。。

cheesechanUID: 3505689

ＨＥ→赫γ 发表于 2015-2-13 01:28
赞。。。。。。很精辟。。。。。其实之前有些F500和merger paralegal经验才决定去读MBA啦（无法抗拒奖的诱 ...

yup......totally understand, US MBA is crazily expensive.........i give up this choice exactly for this reason (one of)
as I will not consider anything out of S16 (or at most top 20) for US (as far as I had read in CD, and some other forum, and also company recruitment list), no matter how high the scholarship is. opportunity cost can never be waived. <--- doesn't mean I am good enough to get such admission though (I think I will be marginal), but simply means the ROI is too low for the rest.....

at the end, MBA is a game for a name, and the network.

If one really wants / needs an MBA, and not willing to do it in two year (coz double tuition), 1 year program will be a very suitable one (if one don't plan to change field), e.g. top European one.

PhD is quite preferred in some roles......but when one also consider the time cost of getting it, the choice is not really that clear......