hku和hkust的phd申请疑惑望大神解答

waYolandaaaaaUID: 3808647

真的十分困惑  有没有大神可以解答一下

申请的是哲学的PhD

个人情况：目前研三211院校  均分86左右  雅思6.5 有国企两次实习和三年志愿者经历 发表论文和参会收录论文一共10+篇 推荐信是我的硕导和同济的一位教授写的 本科毕业获优秀毕业生奖学金

目前状况：
1、港大12月初提交的申请，之后一点音信都没有，系统查询一直都是Pending。
今天发邮件问了一下小米，小米的回复是：I’m sorry to say that the process is very slow here in terms of applicants being officially informed by the university.I’m also sorry to say that we did not recommend that you be offered a place. The number of places we have to offer is very limited, and we are forced to reject many good candidates for all kinds of reasons.I hope that you are able to find a satisfactory alternative, and I wish you well for your future career.

2、港科大也是12月初提交的申请,系统查询一直都是Submitted and under consideration.今天也发邮件问了小米，还未回复。
但是在12月13日收到港科大的一封系统发的邮件，是关于HKPFS的。
邮件内容如下：We have received your HKUST application for PhD admission where you have included an HK PhD Fellowship reference number.   This is to confirm the following status of your application:
− You will be considered for regular PhD admission to HKUST and you still stand the chance to be given a studentship (current rate is HK$16,330/m) upon admission.  If admitted, you will be provided university housing in the first two years of your full-time research postgraduate program at HKUST.
− Upon cross-checking with the Hong Kong Research Grants Council (RGC), you will not be considered for the HK PhD Fellowship.  This is because either or both of the following data in the HKUST admission system does not match with the data in RGC record:

· HKPFS reference no.

· HKUST program choice

港科大今天小米回复了：Your application is under consideration.  You will be notified of the result by mid-July.  Please logon to the Online Admissions System to track the progress of your application from time to time.

我想问的：
1、港大小米的回复是不是意味着我没戏了？
2、我只申了港大和港科大，至今没有收到任何面试通知，以大家的经验觉得，是不是都很悬了？

申请时套瓷过 两个学校各联系过两个老师 但是没有明确跟我说要我的 有的说研究方向不是非常契合 但是鼓励我报 说学院里有其他教授对我的研究方向满意 有的说近年不招新生了  有的就是客套很官方的说欢迎报他们学院什么的 也算没有套瓷了吧 唉

困扰的是真的搞不懂目前的状况是什么样的，可能是我自己申学校时定位不清吧，希望有没有大神可以解答一下，虚心听取所有人的意见和建议，不甚感激。

好啊嘿嘿嘿嘿UID: 3864989

个人感觉，1.港大没推荐你，且几乎明确拒绝你了，让你另谋高就；2.科大对你比较满意，即便你拿不到奖，也应该有比较大希望去读博（相对港大来说）；3.港大我觉得就不必等了，科大就你现在得到的回复说，还是可以等面试的，虽然有可能是被waitlisted了，你可等几天再多问问。祝拿到offer!我也是申哲学的，不过是mphil~

waYolandaaaaaUID: 3808647

好啊嘿嘿嘿嘿 发表于 2018-2-25 08:14
个人感觉，1.港大没推荐你，且几乎明确拒绝你了，让你另谋高就；2.科大对你比较满意，即便你拿不到奖，也应 ...

港科大今天小米回复了：Your application is under consideration.  You will be notified of the result by mid-July.  Please logon to the Online Admissions System to track the progress of your application from time to time.
我也觉得港大是拒的意思了 唉 等等看只能这样了
希望你也顺利早点拿到offer

waYolandaaaaaUID: 3808647

MSSS 发表于 2018-3-1 19:39
mphil/phd offer港科大会一直发到5月份，可以再等等哈。

3.9hkust的研究生院回复我说：Individual program offices will issue offers according to their own admission schedules. In general, admission results will be available on-line from now until around August and successful applicants will be notified.  Please continue to make use of our online system for the most up-to-date status of your application.
但是我到现在连面试都没接到通知，感觉是没戏了。