寄托天下
查看: 1154|回复: 1
打印 上一主题 下一主题

[i习作temp] issue4 [0710G +U Aug小组]第6次作业 [复制链接]

Rank: 2

声望
0
寄托币
355
注册时间
2007-1-3
精华
0
帖子
2
跳转到指定楼层
楼主
发表于 2007-7-30 21:39:27 |只看该作者 |倒序浏览
立场是小反对,提纲:
一、       肯定interdisciplinary study的重要
1、        其他学科的观点和方法对某一学科重大进步有帮助,因为共通相关的东西
2、        交叉学科和学科中的新分支。biologychemistry发展成为biochemistry,法学中引入经济学的分析框架-〉法律经济学
. 但不能认为outsider是唯一的因素,学科内部也能产生重大的创新,比如研究comparative literature

It is definitely true that outsiders can contribute greatly to brilliant advances in any field of study by lending their knowledge and experience, while it is unfair to highlight the values of knowledge and experience outside because there are other resources to great advances.

Scores of important advances in any certain field are put forword with the help of outsiders’ theories and research methods. In social science, philosophy is the basic subject and the original resource of other disciplines such as literature, politics, and sociology. For a long period after those disciplines emerging and becoming independent, they are connected closely because most their basic conceptions and research methods come from philosophy. And during their development, the interactions between each other greatly contribute to the prosperity of these displines. For example, in 20th century distinguished philosophers pointed out that we should reflect the dilemmas of modern people, which resulted in the prosperity of post-modernization and de-constitution in literature. Millions of novels were created to describe how the changing-rapidly society makes us indifferent with each other and nervous in our own heart. The reflections on modernization also resulted in the great progress of some topics in psychology research, which include solving mental problems and improving psychological ability to adapt to the complex environment. Due to the relationship among different fields of study, the outsiders’ stimulation and enlightenment cannot be overlooked.   

Aside from furthering study on some certain topic, outsiders’ methods and views are helpful to build up a cross-discinpline or a new sub-branch which is considered the brilliant advance in any field of study. Biologists and chemists cooperate on the experiments and investigations, analyze the gathered information and data in their perspective ways. Thus a new subjects, biology, is created. In the field of law study, researchers borrows economical analyzing frame to determine and predict the effect of an enforcing act, which is called Law and Economics, a sub-branch in law. It is a trend for different subjects to merge in a certain point in which creative perspectives is more likely to emerge.

However, the outsider is not the only factor leading to great success on the way of research. Since every discipline has its own developing history, distinguished researchers always create their own theory on the base of knowledge and experience which their precedents have achieved. Specialists in some field of study, for example the comparative literature, can also get their breakthrough in theory by comparing different cultures of various countries and areas. The significant developments also depend on other factors such as the financial aids.

In sum, outsiders with different knowledge and experience can bring a broader view, a stimulated method and can help researchers to find new areas to explore. But these cannot overlap the value of inner theories and methods which is of the same importance to make glorious advance.
0 0

使用道具 举报

Rank: 2

声望
0
寄托币
266
注册时间
2007-7-12
精华
0
帖子
1
沙发
发表于 2007-8-1 19:32:57 |只看该作者
issue4 0710G +U Aug小组第6次作业
立场是小反对,提纲:
一、       肯定interdisciplinary study的重要
1、        其他学科的观点和方法对某一学科重大进步有帮助,因为共通相关的东西
2、        交叉学科和学科中的新分支。biology和chemistry发展成为biochemistry,法学中引入经济学的分析框架-〉法律经济学
二. 但不能认为outsider是唯一的因素,学科内部也能产生重大的创新,比如研究comparative literature

It is definitely true that outsiders can contribute greatly to brilliant advances in any field of study by lending their knowledge and experience, while it is unfair to highlight the values of knowledge and experience outside because there are other resources用因素这个词更好 to great advances.
Scores of important advances in any certain field are put forward with the help of outsiders’ theories and research methods. 你这句话是分数的增长与…有关对吗,score和put forward with是什么意思?有空讨论一下In social science, philosophy is the basic subject and the original resource of other disciplines such as literature, politics, and sociology. For a long period after those disciplines emerging and becoming independent, they are connected closely because most their basic conceptions and research methods come from philosophy. And during their development, the interactions between each other greatly contribute to the prosperity of these disciplines. For example, in 20th century ,distinguished philosophers pointed out that we should reflect the dilemmas of modern people, which resulted in the prosperity of post-modernization and de-constitution 不太懂这2个词的意思in literature. Millions of novels were created to describe how the changing-rapidly 这个词是不是要颠倒一下society makes us indifferent with each other and nervous in our own heart. The reflections on modernization also resulted in the great progress of some topics in psychology research, which include solving mental problems and improving psychological ability to adapt to the complex environment. Due to the relationship among different fields of study, the outsiders’ stimulation and enlightenment cannot be overlooked.   题目的意思是外界的发展将会导致某个领域研究的巨大进步,你第一个例子在说什么,世界的变化对人类心里的变化,这好像不是某个研究吧。第二个例子比较恰当,但只有一句话。我觉得把一方面说透就行了。
Asideapart有aside from这种说法? from furthering study on some certain topics, outsiders’ methods and views are helpful to build up a cross-discipline or a new sub-branch which is considered the brilliant advance in any field of study. Biologists and chemists cooperate on the experiments and investigations, analyze the gathered information and data in their perspective ways. Thus a new subjects, biologybiochemistry, is created. In the field of law study, researchers borrows economical analyzing frame to determine and predict the effect of an enforcing act, which is called Law and Economics, a sub-branch in law. It is a trend for different subjects to merge in a certain point in which creative perspectives is more likely to emerge.这段中心偏离啊,我们题目要说的是一个发展对另一种研究的促进,你讲的是2个学科综合成另一种新学科
However, the outsider is not the only factor leading to great success on the way of research. Since every discipline has its own developing history, distinguished researchers always create their own theory on the base of knowledge and experience which their precedents have achieved. Specialists in some field of study, for example the comparative literature, can also get their breakthrough in theory by comparing different cultures of various countries and areas. The significant developments also depend on other factors such as the financial aids. 分析不够具体深入
In sum, outsiders with different knowledge and experience can bring a broader view, a stimulated method and can help researchers to find new areas to explore. But these cannot overlap the value of inner theories and methods which is of the same importance to make glorious advance.
Charming Agilent!

使用道具 举报

RE: issue4 [0710G +U Aug小组]第6次作业 [修改]

问答
Offer
投票
面经
最新
精华
转发
转发该帖子
issue4 [0710G +U Aug小组]第6次作业
https://bbs.gter.net/thread-712736-1-1.html
复制链接
发送
回顶部