寄托天下
查看: 19124|回复: 0
打印 上一主题 下一主题

[专项资料] Argument常见逻辑错误及描述 [合辑] [复制链接]

Rank: 2

声望
0
寄托币
1179
注册时间
2003-6-3
精华
1
帖子
0
楼主
发表于 2003-7-8 01:41:32 |显示全部楼层

老外的逻辑错误分类〔分享〕〔也有问题请帮忙〕

这个转自满分网,在搜索时发现的。可能对大家有用:)
我感觉老外的比较严谨和专业。而新东方的更实用。
转过来时自己翻译了一下,其实看英文效果更好,只是想和手头的中文逻辑错误分类对照一下。
有几个分类不太明白,在文中用问号标出,希望大家能指点一二。


1、Loose generalizations 过于宽泛的概括
Drawing conclusions about groups of people on the basis of stereotypes.
在原型的基础上得出关于整个群体的某个结论
Example: French people are more romantic.

2、Hasty generalizations 草率概括
Arriving at a conclusion without enough evidence.
没有足够证据得出一个结论
Example: Asian-American students are better in math.

3、Circular Reasoning 循环论证
Restating in different words what has already been stated.
用不同的词重新论证已经论述过的东西
Example: Dieting is hard because it requires consuming fewer calories.

4、Single cause-effect 单调因果
Claiming that only one event caused another when there may be no real connection.
声称只有一个事件引起另一个事件,而它们之间可能没有真正的联系
Example: When I sat down at the computer it stopped working, so I must have done something wrong.

5、Slippery Slope
Assumes a chain of cause-effect relationships with very suspect connections.
以非常可疑的联系假定一个因果关系
Example: Because I failed my exam, my parents were mad, I lost my wallet, my car wouldn't start, and I got fired.
???请问一下大家Slippery Slope是什么意思,还有那个例子也不太明白~~

6、Non Sequitur 没有推理
The first part of the idea does not relate to the other.
观念的第一个部分和其他部分没有关系
Example: I did well in school because I always wore nice clothes.
???Non Sequitur 确切的意思是什么?怎么说清?

7、Either/Or 非此即彼
Suggesting only two alternatives when the issue may be much more complex.
认为只有两个选择,非此即彼,然而可能复杂得多(有第三、四种可能)
Example: America--love it or leave it!

8、False Authority 错误的权威
Draws attention away from the evidence and leans on the popularity of someone who may have little knowledge of the issue or product.
将注意力从证据上引开,而依赖一些在这方面了解很少的流行人物
Example: Kathie Lee Gifford, a popular TV celebrity, says that cruises are wonderful, so they must be.

9、Ad Hominem 从个人偏好出发
Attacking the person instead of the ideas.
攻击人而非观点
Example: Don't vote for Jerry Brown; he's a left-wing fanatic, a throwback to the 60s who meditates and eats health foods.

10、Bandwagon Thinking
Claiming that most people agree so it must be right.
声称大多数人赞成所以就一定是对的
Example: I wouldn't have cheated on my income taxes, but everyone else does, so why shouldn't I?
???Bandwagon Thinking 这个我不知道怎么翻译,请大家指教一下

11、Stacking the deck
Giving a slanted view of the issue by focusing only on one side.
仅集中在某一面,而得出一个关于这个问题的歪曲的观点
Example: I deserve to get an A in the class because I like the teacher, work hard, and attend class.
???Stacking the deck 是什么意思?

12、Appeal to Emotion 诉诸情绪
Exploiting the audience's feeling in order to get them on your side.
激起读者的情绪感受,以使他们站在作者这边
Example: I believe I deserve a scholarship because I am an orphan who grew up in a dysfunctional foster family.

13、Ignoring the question 忽略问题
Changing the topic before it is really considered
???这句是什么意思
Example: The criminal won't say where he was on the night of the crime, but he does remember being teased relentlessly as a child.
???这个例子到底在说什么?

14、Trivial objections 琐碎的缺陷(微不足道的反驳理由)
Can be similar to ad hominem in that it focuses on things unimportant to the issue at hand.
当“从个人偏好出发”关注于对这个问题不重要的东西时,Trivial objections的这种逻辑错误和其相似
Example: I think Ross Perot would make a terrible president. His ears are huge.
人绝不能依附着别人的梦想……
在没有被任何人强迫的情况下,自己的生存理由要自己去确定!

使用道具 举报

RE: Argument常见逻辑错误及描述 [合辑] [修改]
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 立即注册

问答
Offer
投票
面经
最新
精华
转发
转发该帖子
Argument常见逻辑错误及描述 [合辑]
https://bbs.gter.net/thread-26836-1-1.html
复制链接
发送
报offer 祈福 爆照
回顶部