这题目啥意思啊

狐狸大叔UID: 2342950

15. If Local A.A. (Alcohol Anonymous) rehabilitation facilities are forced upon us – and society is determined that they should be forced – then it should be society that pays for them.
Considering the statements below, which one would weaken the argument above?
A. Many groups have been convinced by a government committee that the local rehabilitation facilities are unsuccessful.
B. The cost of A.A. facilities are too high to be funded locally.
C. Rehabilitation facilities are supported by many neighborhood groups.
D. The expense to maintain an A.A. rehabilitation facility is too costly.
E. Alcoholics may not want to accept treatment.

duijinxiaoziUID: 2585955

A.A. (Alcohol Anonymous) rehabilitation = 戒酒的康复中心
题目：如果康复中心是强制性的，民众也认为应该是强制性的。社会就要付钱给康复中心。
问削弱选项。

狐狸大叔UID: 2342950

我怎么觉得第二个意思是 社会认为是强制的。。。

当地人觉得如果是被迫建立一个rehab，而且社会觉得应该建，那应该让社会出钱

狐狸大叔UID: 2342950

答案给的是A

怎么个weaken法呢。。。。

A的意思是说政府说服团体，local inhab不成功

所以A之所以能weaken是因为A的意思是别搞inheb了（而原题是如果搞inheb应该让社会出钱）

duijinxiaoziUID: 2585955

嗯。2个society 都是指社会。

duijinxiaoziUID: 2585955

facilities are forced upon us (X)  &  society is determined that they should be forced (Y)------------------------------------------>   society that pays for facilities (Z)

X & Y--->Z       equals to        非Z---> 非X  or 非Y

选项（A）的逻辑是：
Z----->非Y

与题干的  非Z---> 非X  or 非Y   逻辑 矛盾。

Weaken   :dizzy:

狐狸大叔UID: 2342950

神人啊

谢谢

duijinxiaoziUID: 2585955

np