- 最后登录
- 2015-3-19
- 在线时间
- 851 小时
- 寄托币
- 6504
- 声望
- 435
- 注册时间
- 2009-12-18
- 阅读权限
- 100
- 帖子
- 140
- 精华
- 1
- 积分
- 5173
- UID
- 2739489
  
- 声望
- 435
- 寄托币
- 6504
- 注册时间
- 2009-12-18
- 精华
- 1
- 帖子
- 140
|
本帖最后由 weasel 于 2010-4-20 22:20 编辑
改 sola
红色:flaw
粉红:comment
蓝色:good job
With the allegationthat the future of society is established by how children are socialized and wehave not yet learned how to raise children, the speaker implies the conclusion thatwe cannot make a better future(创造一个更好的未来?make这个词似乎太笼统,是否可以换个具体的词). Frommy perspective, this allegation is the speaker’s subjective judgment, so, (这里so后面为什么要打逗号呢?前后都打逗号不是变成了插入语了吗,那么前后这两个长句没有连词连接了? PS.这方面我不是太确定,望讨论)I can partlyagree with it in some certain conditions.
总体这一段是标准北美范文式的,第一次写的话可以理解怎么干,希望以后渐渐脱去
First of all, I concede that, in most cases, how our children are socializeddetermines the future of our society, and there are indeed some flaws in oursocial education system, including the neglect of psychological health and thewrong induction of mass media. As we can see in the school shooting(which) happened in VirginiaTech, the criminal was considered as solitude(n. the quality or state of being alone or remote from society,来源于韦氏,没有形容词的意思), autistic with many obvious(是不是加个strange或者odd 好一点呢) behaviors as he would never greetwith others initiatively, or even give any responses to others’ greetings. Thecollege did not realize the potential danger, which could be prevented(明白意思,不过prevent不太准确,可以用阻止潜在的危险?建议整句改成这样if the college realized the potential danger,this kind of tragedy could not happen) before the tragedy happened.{ Afterthe school shooting, the media, as one of the main approaches through whichmass get to know our society that have a vital effect on mass’s ethics andvalues, we real ways using the word ’tragedy’instead of ‘murder’. Definitely, American media leaded by Modern liberal havethe responsibility in implying the mass that the criminal is a victim as wellby using neuter words, which vague(只有adj.的意思)the concept of justice(只有n.的意思) an devil.} It cannot be denied thatthe tragedy could be avoided if our education system could do well in the twoaspects above.
大括号里的两个句子不是太理解,词性有点乱
Besides,though how socialized our children determines the future of our society, by and large, we have done quite a good job inteaching. History is replete withsuch evidence. Plato could not become a philosopher everlasting in history, if hedid not meet with his mentor, Socrates, who had a big influence on Plato’schoice of life, and there would not be Academy which is the earliestinstitution of higher education.(这里应该加个连接词) Aristotle,famous philosopher, scientist and educator in ancient Greek, as a student ofPlato, is one of the most important founding figures in Westernphilosophy. Aristotelianism had a profound influence on philosophical and theological thinking in the Islamic andJewish traditions in the Middle Ages, and it continues to influence Christiantheology, especially Eastern Orthodox theology,and the scholastic tradition of the CatholicChurch.
这里举了很多的例子,缺少一个总结
However, in some situations, how socialized our children are could notdetermine the destiny of our society. Some children live in enclosedenvironment at an early age, such as acrobats and athletes, or researchers whostay in the laboratory all day long. Training and experiment have taken almostall of their time from dawn to dusk. And theyhardly have any contact with the society or they dislike the outside world as aresult of being used to their enclosed life. After all, they are minority whichcould not determine the destiny of our society as the politicians do.
怎么觉得这个例子证明不了你的观点啊,反而是反驳你的观点。。你看我这样理解,运动员和飞行员以及研究人员长期住在封闭的地方不跟外界来往,只有训练和研究,但是他们仍然有机会能改变社会,是不是差不多这样呢?虽然这句话还是有些瑕疵,但是这样逻辑才对吧,你这样是不是默认这些人不能make our society better?
看了最后一句结尾,就更不明白了
In sum, it is indispensable that children should be well socialized as they arethe future of our society. While, at the same time, we still have a long way togo improving our education, not only in the classroom, but also in the wholesociety.
最后总结一下,这个思路是新东方的是吧?虽然我新东方的作文课,没有讲这些,但是我猜测:你上面的三条提纲,应该是三种写作整体的逻辑思路,而不是把三种写作思路用在一篇文章的三段,理由有下面几个。
(1)
你前两段都有一个未经证实的论点就是,how socialized our children determines thefuture of our society
(2)
第三段又提出how socialized our children are could notdetermine the destiny of our society;这就是自己在否定自己,这种自己否定的情况出现在一篇文章的唯一情况就是case by case的手法,略微看出来你有这方面的倾向,但是case by case首先要分清本质,这一点在imong追星箭里有介绍
我举个例子,如果按你第2段的思路来说,提纲应该这样
(1)
howsocialized our children determines the future of our society
(2)
however,我们没能培养好孩子
(3)
因此,我们将不能缔造一个美好的未来
这只是一个逻辑链,内容和观点可以再充实
总体来说,建议浏览一遍论坛的精华帖,推荐追星箭和comorain系列的,在这不是否定尊敬的新东方老师们,但是看看论坛上前辈们的精华才能博采众长,运用好手中的武器。
第一篇,看得出非常认真,继续加油,
欢迎来讨论,本着负责的态度,言语过直,见谅! |
|