一些经济系排名

turkeykUID: 208840

有板油问如何界定美国top20, 30,50的学校。虽然这个问题版主们也不能给出权威的回答（我们不是专业搞排名的）。但是可能把相关的排名信息综合起来，然后界定一个大概还是好的。于是先把tilburg排名的三种算法结果贴出来。这个排名的好处是新。有人批评它选的期刊过多，我就用它的sandbox限制到top5和top5+very good试试看。我觉得最后的结果很可能是严格界定是不可能的。正如我们谈到国内的top5学校，实际指的学校大概有6-8所。anyway，先搞一点。然后看看如何继续吧。tilburg economics ranking 2006-2010原版.

Rank  University
1 HARVARD UNIVERSITY
2 UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO
3 NEW YORK UNIVERSITY
4 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
5 COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY
6 STANFORD UNIVERSITY
7 MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
8 YALE UNIVERSITY
9 NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY
10 UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA
11 UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN
12 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, LOS ANGELES
13 PRINCETON UNIVERSITY
14 DUKE UNIVERSITY
15 UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND
16 CORNELL UNIVERSITY
17 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO
18 UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS
19 UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN
20 UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
21 WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY
22 OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY
23 BROWN UNIVERSITY
24 PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA
26 BOSTON UNIVERSITY
27 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, DAVIS
28 CALIFORNIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
29 BOSTON COLLEGE
30 VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY
31 UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA, CHAPEL HILL
32 MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY
33 DARTMOUTH COLLEGE
34 INDIANA UNIVERSITY
35 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, IRVINE
36 UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA
37 ARIZONA STATE UNIVERSITY
CARNEGIE MELLON UNIVERSITY
39 RUTGERS STATE UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON
41 TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY
42 PURDUE UNIVERSITY
43 GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO
UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS, AUSTIN
46 EMORY UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA
48 SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITY OF IOWA
50 UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER
51 SOUTHERN METHODIST UNIVERSITY
52 IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY
53 RICE UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH
UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS
56 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SANTA BARBARA
UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA
58 JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY
59 GEORGIA STATE UNIVERSITY
60 UNIVERSITY OF HOUSTON
61 UNIVERSITY OF GEORGIA
62 UNIVERSITY OF OREGON
63 UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY
UNIVERSITY OF NOTRE DAME
65 UNIVERSITY OF UTAH
66 GEORGE WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI
68 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SANTA CRUZ
69 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, RIVERSIDE
70 BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY
TUFTS UNIVERSITY
72 NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY
73 FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY
GEORGIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
75 CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK
UNIVERSITY OF CONNECTICUT
77 GEORGE MASON UNIVERSITY
78 CASE WESTERN RESERVE UNIVERSITY
79 TULANE UNIVERSITY
80 CLEMSON UNIVERSITY
81 LOUISIANA STATE UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITY OF TENNESSEE
UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS, DALLAS
84 CLAREMONT MCKENNA COLLEGE
SUNY, ALBANY
UNIVERSITY OF KANSAS
UNIVERSITY OF MIAMI
88 UNIVERSITY OF DELAWARE
89 DREXEL UNIVERSITY
VIRGINIA POLYTECHNIC INSTITUTE AND STATE UNIVERSITY
WILLIAMS COLLEGE
92 OREGON STATE UNIVERSITY
SANTA CLARA UNIVERSITY
SUNY, STONY BROOK
UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL FLORIDA
96 SUNY, BINGHAMTON
UNIVERSITY MASSACHUSETTS
98 SUNY, BUFFALO
UNIVERSITY OF OKLAHOMA
UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA

turkeykUID: 208840

tilburg economics ranking based on Top 5期刊(AER, Econometrica, JPE, QJE, RES)+Journal of Finance only 2006-2010.

Rank         University
1        HARVARD UNIVERSITY
2        UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO
3        MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
4        STANFORD UNIVERSITY
5        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
6        NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY
7        COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY
8        NEW YORK UNIVERSITY
9        YALE UNIVERSITY
10        PRINCETON UNIVERSITY
11        UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA
12        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, LOS ANGELES
13        DUKE UNIVERSITY
14        UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND
15        UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN
16        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO
17        BROWN UNIVERSITY
18        UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA
19        CORNELL UNIVERSITY
20        CALIFORNIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
        UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
        UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN
23        DARTMOUTH COLLEGE
24        BOSTON UNIVERSITY
        WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY
26        BOSTON COLLEGE
27        OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, DAVIS
29        CARNEGIE MELLON UNIVERSITY
        PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY
31        UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS
        UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA
33        ARIZONA STATE UNIVERSITY
34        VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY
35        UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS
36        UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER
37        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SANTA BARBARA
        UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS, AUSTIN
39        GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF IOWA
41        UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA
        UNIVERSITY OF NOTRE DAME
43        GEORGIA STATE UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO
        UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA, CHAPEL HILL
46        EMORY UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON
48        INDIANA UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SANTA CRUZ
50        JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY
        MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY
52        BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY
        IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY
        PURDUE UNIVERSITY
        RUTGERS STATE UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, IRVINE
        UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS, DALLAS
58        DREXEL UNIVERSITY
        TUFTS UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF GEORGIA
61        CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK
        CLAREMONT MCKENNA COLLEGE
        GEORGE MASON UNIVERSITY
        MONTANA STATE UNIVERSITY
        RICE UNIVERSITY
        TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, RIVERSIDE
        UNIVERSITY OF CONNECTICUT
        UNIVERSITY OF DELAWARE
        UNIVERSITY OF HOUSTON
        UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH
        UNIVERSITY OF UTAH
73        CASE WESTERN RESERVE UNIVERSITY
        GEORGE WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY MASSACHUSETTS
        UNIVERSITY OF KANSAS
        UNIVERSITY OF OREGON
78        BRANDEIS UNIVERSITY
        DEPAUL UNIVERSITY
        MIDDLEBURY COLLEGE
        SAN DIEGO STATE UNIVERSITY
        SOUTHERN METHODIST UNIVERSITY
        SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY
        UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI
86        BLACK HILLS STATE UNIVERSITY
        CLEMSON UNIVERSITY
        COLGATE UNIVERSITY
        CUNY, BARUCH COLLEGE
        FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY
        KANSAS STATE UNIVERSITY
        KELLOGG SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT
        NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY
        NORTHEASTERN UNIVERSITY
        SANTA CLARA UNIVERSITY
        SUNY, ALBANY
        SUNY, BINGHAMTON
        UNIVERSITY OF ALABAMA
        UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS
        UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL FLORIDA
        UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA
        UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA
        UNIVERSITY OF NEVADA
        UNIVERSITY OF TENNESSEE
        WESLEYAN UNIVERSITY
        WILLIAMS COLLEGE

turkeykUID: 208840

tilburg economics ranking 2006-2010 based on top5期刊+J of Finance, JFE, IER, EJ, GEB, J O Econometrics, Rand J of Econ, JET, J of Public Econ, JET (通常说的very good和field top。)

Rank         University
1        HARVARD UNIVERSITY
2        UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO
3        MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
4        NEW YORK UNIVERSITY
5        STANFORD UNIVERSITY
6        NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY
7        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
8        COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY
9        UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA
10        YALE UNIVERSITY
11        PRINCETON UNIVERSITY
12        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, LOS ANGELES
13        DUKE UNIVERSITY
14        UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN
15        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO
16        UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND
17        CORNELL UNIVERSITY
18        UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN
19        UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
20        CALIFORNIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
21        WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY
22        BROWN UNIVERSITY
23        UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS
24        OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY
25        UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA
26        PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY
27        BOSTON UNIVERSITY
28        BOSTON COLLEGE
29        ARIZONA STATE UNIVERSITY
30        CARNEGIE MELLON UNIVERSITY
        MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY
        VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY
33        INDIANA UNIVERSITY
34        GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA
36        DARTMOUTH COLLEGE
37        UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER
38        UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA
        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, DAVIS
40        RUTGERS STATE UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS, AUSTIN
42        UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS
43        UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA, CHAPEL HILL
44        EMORY UNIVERSITY
45        UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON
46        TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY
47        PURDUE UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF IOWA
49        UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH
50        RICE UNIVERSITY
51        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SANTA BARBARA
52        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, IRVINE
53        SOUTHERN METHODIST UNIVERSITY
54        JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO
        UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA
57        GEORGIA STATE UNIVERSITY
        IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF OREGON
60        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SANTA CRUZ
61        UNIVERSITY OF NOTRE DAME
        UNIVERSITY OF UTAH
63        GEORGE MASON UNIVERSITY
        SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY
66        UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, RIVERSIDE
        UNIVERSITY OF GEORGIA
        UNIVERSITY OF HOUSTON
69        UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI
70        FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF CONNECTICUT
72        NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY
        SUNY, STONY BROOK
        UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS, DALLAS
75        BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY
        CASE WESTERN RESERVE UNIVERSITY
        CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK
        DREXEL UNIVERSITY
        GEORGE WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY
        TUFTS UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY OF DELAWARE
        UNIVERSITY OF KANSAS
83        CLAREMONT MCKENNA COLLEGE
        MIDDLEBURY COLLEGE
        SUNY, ALBANY
        UNIVERSITY OF TENNESSEE
        WILLIAMS COLLEGE
88        GEORGIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
        SUNY, BINGHAMTON
90        CUNY, BARUCH COLLEGE
        UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL FLORIDA
        UNIVERSITY OF MIAMI
        UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH FLORIDA
94        BRANDEIS UNIVERSITY
        CHAPMAN UNIVERSITY
        LOUISIANA STATE UNIVERSITY
        MONTANA STATE UNIVERSITY
        SANTA CLARA UNIVERSITY
        TULANE UNIVERSITY
        UNIVERSITY MASSACHUSETTS
        UNIVERSITY OF ALABAMA

37°蓝调UID: 2816577

:lol大叔辛苦了~~

wangxi0728UID: 2784118

NYU在这几个统计下很强健！

donna2011UID: 3199992

很新的数据，THX

deepimpactUID: 2446184

太感谢啦！

gavinfengUID: 2720524

nyu的强势应该不止经济系的贡献吧？